The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Basketball (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/)
-   -   Why does this happen? (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/6950-why-does-happen.html)

Dan_ref Sun Jan 12, 2003 10:33pm

This seems to be happening a lot this year on free throws:

Me: (stepping into lane) "Two shots guys"
Player on low post (as I'm backing out): "Hey ref, how many shots?"


mick Sun Jan 12, 2003 10:49pm

Huh?

Mark Padgett Sun Jan 12, 2003 10:49pm

Let me guess - these are all public schools?

just another ref Sun Jan 12, 2003 11:20pm

Quote:

Originally posted by Dan_ref
This seems to be happening a lot this year on free throws:

Me: (stepping into lane) "Two shots guys"
Player on low post (as I'm backing out): "Hey ref, how many shots?"


I see the same thing. Kids not only are not paying attention, but are clueless about so many things. A shooting foul on the first possesion of the game. Isn't everybody supposed to know that it's 2 shots? Beginning of the game. Which goal is ours? Where did you warm up? Duh... Start of 2nd quarter: Hey ref, whose ball is it? This one is the one that really kills me. See that little arrow on the table over there......

rockyroad Mon Jan 13, 2003 12:09am

Quote:

Originally posted by Mark Padgett
Let me guess - these are all public schools?
Ok, now that hurt...even better yet is I step into lane and say "Bonus"...player on low block saya "Hey ref, is that the same as one-and-one"...I thought I was gonna puke on his shoes!

dhodges007 Mon Jan 13, 2003 07:41am

Quote:

Originally posted by Dan_ref
This seems to be happening a lot this year on free throws:

Me: (stepping into lane) "Two shots guys"
Player on low post (as I'm backing out): "Hey ref, how many shots?"


On the next one, just look at him and say O-N-E.

devdog69 Mon Jan 13, 2003 11:36am

The one that kills me is after a team calls a timeout. They always come out of the timeout and ask "who's ball"? Well, son, there's a new rule in town, a timeout is a turnover it's their ball.

Mark T. DeNucci, Sr. Mon Jan 13, 2003 12:34pm

Quote:

Originally posted by Dan_ref
This seems to be happening a lot this year on free throws:

Me: (stepping into lane) "Two shots guys"
Player on low post (as I'm backing out): "Hey ref, how many shots?"



I tell them to ask a teammate how many free throws.

Mark T. DeNucci, Sr. Mon Jan 13, 2003 12:36pm

Quote:

Originally posted by devdog69
The one that kills me is after a team calls a timeout. They always come out of the timeout and ask "who's ball"? Well, son, there's a new rule in town, a timeout is a turnover it's their ball.

Just this fall in a girls varsity game the coach requested a timeout while his player was holding the ball right in front of us. When the timeout was over the same coach asked me who was getting the throw-in and where.

Ron Mon Jan 13, 2003 03:54pm

A few possibilities, Dan.......

1. Kids tend not to pay attention (probably the likely reason),

2. If it's happening alot, as you say, and if it's always a player in the lowest lane space, perhaps you're getting too close to the FT line when stepping into the key to administer, or........

3. Your fellow officials have conspired with several players to make you think you're crazy.

Jurassic Referee Mon Jan 13, 2003 04:15pm

Quote:

Originally posted by Ron
A few possibilities, Dan.......

3) Your fellow officials have conspired with several players to make you think you're crazy.

Aha! Just as I suspected!

It's Chuck's fault!

pizanno Mon Jan 13, 2003 06:21pm

Good advice I've received over the years:

* Players often "hear" only the last word of your statement. I've since had more success just stating "TWO" or "be ready...ONE and ONE!"

* Even though the rule has changed to allow subs only on the last FT, I still tell subs that replace players in the first two FT positions "one shot, okay?"...then state "ONE!" to everyone else. Good preventative mechanic.

Regarding Timeouts:

I actually had a HS player beleive me when I told him "The first team out of a time out gets the ball". Subsequently, he helped get his team out without delay, much to the delight and surpise of my partner!

Hawks Coach Mon Jan 13, 2003 08:57pm

Quote:

Originally posted by Mark T. DeNucci, Sr.
[QUOTEJust this fall in a girls varsity game the coach requested a timeout while his player was holding the ball right in front of us. When the timeout was over the same coach asked me who was getting the throw-in and where.
We played great defense yesterday, earned a 5 second count, and as our players were lining up for the throw-in, B called time out. We set-up for a sideline inbounds against their press. When we returned, the ref gave the ball to B explaining that they couldn't have called timeout if they didn't have the ball. When we reminded him of the five second count, he changed his story and said the five second count happened after the request for TO. Never mind that we all saw B's coach get up to make the request after the 5 second call and and we saw the ref grant it while he was standing OOB awaiting to administer the throwin a good 5-10 seconds after his initial call.

Suffice to say, anybody can lose concentration and screw up (although I didn't like this guy covering his screw up by creating an alternate reality).

Dan_ref Mon Jan 13, 2003 10:20pm

Quote:

Originally posted by Jurassic Referee
Quote:

Originally posted by Ron
A few possibilities, Dan.......

3) Your fellow officials have conspired with several players to make you think you're crazy.

Aha! Just as I suspected!

It's Chuck's fault!

I knew it!!!!

Back In The Saddle Tue Jan 14, 2003 12:35am

Tangent (sorry, it's rather long)
 
In my profession (software engineer with emphasis on human-computer interaction) I have had cause to study some about the limits of human mental ability. I did not do the research on this, I only have read what others have written about it. Still, I find it rather fascinating.

Our conscious and our subconscious are both plugging away, all the time. While the subconscious can handle many tasks at once (e.g., walking and chewing gum :)), our conscious can only handle one stream of thought at a time.

So, while a player is lining up along the lane and desparately trying to remember what his coach said about free throw situations, he is not even capable of also consciously paying attention to the ref. He has got to focus on one or the other.

The player is taking it all in, of course, but subconsciously. We don't yet understand how information goes back and forth across the boundary from concsious to subconscious, but it's an imperfect process. Perhaps especially so when it happens in a moment of panic, like when a player suddenly realizes that he doesn't know how many shots.

It's entirely plausable that he can pull the last thing he heard from the ref across the boundary, but lose all the rest. That being the case, I think pizanno's advice is right on the money--make sure that last word is the important one.

The "usability guy" in me wants to get on the soapbox about it being rather unfair to characterize players as "not paying attention," as if they are somehow misbehaving. They're doing just what the coach wants them to do--think! It's the limitation of the conscious mind that allows only one stream of thought. But I'll resist the urge. ;)

BTW, it's that same "limitation" that allows us to focus on the game and not notice all that is going on around us off of the floor.

Dan_ref Tue Jan 14, 2003 12:44am

Re: Tangent (sorry, it's rather long)
 
Quote:

Originally posted by Back In The Saddle


The "usability guy" in me wants to get on the soapbox about it being rather unfair to characterize players as "not paying attention," as if they are somehow misbehaving. They're doing just what the coach wants them to do--think! It's the limitation of the conscious mind that allows only one stream of thought. But I'll resist the urge. ;)

BTW, it's that same "limitation" that allows us to focus on the game and not notice all that is going on around us off of the floor.

To be honest, the look on these poor guy's faces is what I imagine I look like when I say "Yes dear....what was that again?" Good point.

Back In The Saddle Tue Jan 14, 2003 01:12am

Quote:

To be honest, the look on these poor guy's faces is what I imagine I look like when I say "Yes dear....what was that again?" Good point.
And I thought I was the only one who did that :D

PS. I'm still trying to figure out how to work this gizmo. How do I get the really nice looking quotes with the bold text and the italicized citation (i.e., Originally posted by...)?

dhodges007 Tue Jan 14, 2003 07:34am

Quote:

Originally posted by pizanno
Good advice I've received over the years:

* Players often "hear" only the last word of your statement. I've since had more success just stating "TWO" or "be ready...ONE and ONE!"

* Even though the rule has changed to allow subs only on the last FT, I still tell subs that replace players in the first two FT positions "one shot, okay?"...then state "ONE!" to everyone else. Good preventative mechanic.

Regarding Timeouts:

I actually had a HS player beleive me when I told him "The first team out of a time out gets the ball". Subsequently, he helped get his team out without delay, much to the delight and surpise of my partner!

That is too funny!

Mark Dexter Tue Jan 14, 2003 09:16am

Quote:

Originally posted by pizanno
I actually had a HS player beleive me when I told him "The first team out of a time out gets the ball". Subsequently, he helped get his team out without delay, much to the delight and surpise of my partner!
Yikes!!

What happens when his team is the first to break the huddle, but the other team gets the ball?? :eek:

klancie Tue Jan 14, 2003 10:16am

These kids should've asked
 
Freshman boys. Partner calls foul on black team. White is in the bonus. I go to Lead to administer. As partner is walking to Trail position, he clearly says to me "1&1!" In the lane, I clearly say, "Line up men, 1&1." There is some shuffling along the lane, so I repeat "1&1, men" as I toss the ball to the white team's shooter. Naturally he clanks it off the side of the rim. I guess the players heard me say 2 shots, because no one moves, & ball is bouncing toward sideline. Black team member in lowest lane position, thinking he's being helpful, grabs ball and starts walking toward me. I did my best to not see him travel, while his parents in the stands are yelling at him to dribble. Unfortunately, I did see him throw it to me where I was standing out of bounds.

oc Wed Jan 15, 2003 06:36pm

Re: These kids should've asked
 
Quote:

Originally posted by klancie
Freshman boys. Partner calls foul on black team. White is in the bonus. I go to Lead to administer. As partner is walking to Trail position, he clearly says to me "1&1!" In the lane, I clearly say, "Line up men, 1&1." There is some shuffling along the lane, so I repeat "1&1, men" as I toss the ball to the white team's shooter. Naturally he clanks it off the side of the rim. I guess the players heard me say 2 shots, because no one moves, & ball is bouncing toward sideline. Black team member in lowest lane position, thinking he's being helpful, grabs ball and starts walking toward me. I did my best to not see him travel, while his parents in the stands are yelling at him to dribble. Unfortunately, I did see him throw it to me where I was standing out of bounds.
Had a similar situation--but ball was bouncing in the lane while everyone looked at it. Finally one kid figured it out and grabbed it.

mick Wed Jan 15, 2003 08:59pm

Re: Re: These kids should've asked
 
Quote:

Originally posted by oc

Had a similar situation--but ball was bouncing in the lane while everyone looked at it. Finally one kid figured it out and grabbed it.

I had that happen in a Jr. High game.
The Coach apologized after the game and said, "I'm sorry, but my team hasn't been in the bonus all year."

Let's call those fouls in Jr.High, too. ;)

Dan_ref Wed Jan 15, 2003 10:12pm

Quote:

Originally posted by Back In The Saddle
Quote:

To be honest, the look on these poor guy's faces is what I imagine I look like when I say "Yes dear....what was that again?" Good point.
And I thought I was the only one who did that :D

PS. I'm still trying to figure out how to work this gizmo. How do I get the really nice looking quotes with the bold text and the italicized citation (i.e., Originally posted by...)?

click the tab labelled "quote" under the post you want to....uhmmmm....quote.

ChuckElias Thu Jan 16, 2003 05:53am

Quote:

Originally posted by devdog69
The one that kills me is after a team calls a timeout. They always come out of the timeout and ask "who's ball"?
This kills me too, b/c what the heck was the coach just talking about for the last 60 seconds?!?!

Chuck

ChuckElias Thu Jan 16, 2003 05:57am

Quote:

Originally posted by Jurassic Referee
Aha! Just as I suspected!

It's Chuck's fault!

I'm in the middle of the Carribean, enjoying the sun, miles from the nearest basketball, and I'm <font size = +4 color = red>still</font> taking abuse from you guys!!

At least I know where to stand as Lead during my FTs!

Now. . . As Eric Cartman might (or might not say), screw you guys. I'm going to the breakfast buffet.

Chuck

Jurassic Referee Thu Jan 16, 2003 06:20am

Quote:

Originally posted by ChuckElias
[/B]
I'm in the middle of the Carribean, enjoying the sun, miles from the nearest basketball, and I'm <font size = +4 color = red>still</font> taking abuse from you guys!!

[/B][/QUOTE]Well,I miss ya!:D

Dan_ref Thu Jan 16, 2003 08:16am

Quote:

Originally posted by ChuckElias
Quote:

Originally posted by Jurassic Referee
Aha! Just as I suspected!

It's Chuck's fault!

I'm in the middle of the Carribean, enjoying the sun, miles from the nearest basketball, and I'm <font size = +4 color = red>still</font> taking abuse from you guys!!

At least I know where to stand as Lead during my FTs!


And you obviously know where to go in January. The thermometer on my deck is hovering just above zero right now.

Quote:

Now. . . As Eric Cartman might (or might not say), screw you guys. I'm going to the breakfast buffet.

Chuck
No....more....bacon......

South Bay HHVBC Thu Jan 16, 2003 03:09pm

..
 
In defense of the kids, you have to remember that some of these kids really dont know what the hell is going on regardless if they are on the bench or in uniform starting for a team. Many players are just beginners. Some kids have coaches who dont tell them the rules. Sometimes its pretty loud in the gym and possibly he/she didnt hear the ref signal 2 shots physically and verbally. What I found is that most of the kids are just too damn nervous on the court and really get caught up in what they are supposed to immediately after the free throw/s instead of focus on the exact situation at hand.

Believe it or not, some kids just ask just so they can talk to the ref. It sounds stupid but I used to do this as a player(i guess some of you guys are mad at me). I would ask or just repeat what the ref said in a questioning way so that he can respond to me, 1 on 1. I dont know exactly why I did this but when the ref would make eye contact with me and tell me the situation, it gave me a feeling that I knew that me and the ref were on the same page. This made me at ease for some weird reason.

Either way, the refs are the professionals and have to give some kids a little break. What may be crystal clear to some players may be completely misunderstood by others.

Refs are supposed to be on point with all situations on the court. Sometiems they are not. Same goes with the kids.


LSams Thu Jan 16, 2003 03:49pm

has anyone ever considered this "question" from the players as an "innocent" attmept to disconcert?

There are a couple of schools in my area that do this before every free throw attmepted by the opposition, usually from the player(s) closest to the shooter.

Just another thought.

Back In The Saddle Thu Jan 16, 2003 05:15pm

Quote:

Originally posted by Dan_ref
click the tab labelled "quote" under the post you want to....uhmmmm....quote.
Well that's a LOT easier than building it by hand. Thanks.

Dan_ref Thu Jan 16, 2003 11:24pm

Re: ..
 
Quote:

Originally posted by South Bay HHVBC
In defense of the kids, you have to remember that some of these kids really dont know what the hell is going on regardless if they are on the bench or in uniform starting for a team. Many players are just beginners. Some kids have coaches who dont tell them the rules. Sometimes its pretty loud in the gym and possibly he/she didnt hear the ref signal 2 shots physically and verbally. What I found is that most of the kids are just too damn nervous on the court and really get caught up in what they are supposed to immediately after the free throw/s instead of focus on the exact situation at hand.


Well, yeah, maybe, but I'm talking about kids who shave. And drive.

Quote:


Believe it or not, some kids just ask just so they can talk to the ref. It sounds stupid but I used to do this as a player(i guess some of you guys are mad at me). I would ask or just repeat what the ref said in a questioning way so that he can respond to me, 1 on 1. I dont know exactly why I did this but when the ref would make eye contact with me and tell me the situation, it gave me a feeling that I knew that me and the ref were on the same page. This made me at ease for some weird reason.

Bingo! This is exactly what I think is going on most of the time.

dhodges007 Fri Jan 17, 2003 07:38am

Re: ..
 
Quote:

Originally posted by South Bay HHVBC
In defense of the kids, you have to remember that some of these kids really dont know what the hell is going on regardless if they are on the bench or in uniform starting for a team. Many players are just beginners. Some kids have coaches who dont tell them the rules. Sometimes its pretty loud in the gym and possibly he/she didnt hear the ref signal 2 shots physically and verbally. What I found is that most of the kids are just too damn nervous on the court and really get caught up in what they are supposed to immediately after the free throw/s instead of focus on the exact situation at hand.

Believe it or not, some kids just ask just so they can talk to the ref. It sounds stupid but I used to do this as a player(i guess some of you guys are mad at me). I would ask or just repeat what the ref said in a questioning way so that he can respond to me, 1 on 1. I dont know exactly why I did this but when the ref would make eye contact with me and tell me the situation, it gave me a feeling that I knew that me and the ref were on the same page. This made me at ease for some weird reason.

Either way, the refs are the professionals and have to give some kids a little break. What may be crystal clear to some players may be completely misunderstood by others.

Refs are supposed to be on point with all situations on the court. Sometiems they are not. Same goes with the kids.


Good point. Next time I will just smile and say yes that's right...or something like it. Thanks for your post.

ChuckElias Fri Jan 17, 2003 07:40am

Quote:

Originally posted by Dan_ref
And you obviously know where to go in January. The thermometer on my deck is hovering just above zero right now.
I guess. Unfortunately, I obviously had to make myself "unavailable" to work games for a week, which I didn't like to do. Giving up probably $500-$700 in game fees. But my whole family was going. Priorities, priorities. . .

Quote:

No....more....bacon......
Jeez, I can't even think about eating bacon. . . I've gotta be 20 pounds heavier than I was a week ago.

Chuck

Dan_ref Fri Jan 17, 2003 08:06am

Quote:

Originally posted by ChuckElias
Quote:

Originally posted by Dan_ref
And you obviously know where to go in January. The thermometer on my deck is hovering just above zero right now.
I guess. Unfortunately, I obviously had to make myself "unavailable" to work games for a week, which I didn't like to do. Giving up probably $500-$700 in game fees. But my whole family was going. Priorities, priorities. . .


whoa...that's a LOT of 5th grade girls rec games! :)

Quote:


Jeez, I can't even think about eating bacon. . . I've gotta be 20 pounds heavier than I was a week ago.

Chuck
have fun!

[Edited by Dan_ref on Jan 17th, 2003 at 07:09 AM]


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:27am.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1