![]() |
What is that league teaching its officials?
Watch the third clip from the top and explain to me how this is a blocking foul, even by NBE standards.
Video Rule Book - Home "To get into a legal position, the defender needs to establish himself in the path of the offensive player before contact is made and before he starts his upward shooting motion" Sure looks like he meet those two requirements to me, yet the official position of the league office is that this is a blocking foul. :confused: |
In an attempt to discern what the heck the league is trying to get from its officials, I went and viewed all of the video clips under blocking/charging.
What I discovered is that the charging foul clips are so blatant that Stevie Wonder could call them, while some of those labeled as blocking fouls are debatable. I even believe that one of them is outright incorrect and that is the one I mentioned in the first post in this thread. Therefore, my conclusion is that the league is telling it's officials that if the play isn't so clearly a charge that it is laughable, then a block is the desired call. That seems to fit nicely with what I've always thought about the NBE--FAVOR THE OFFENSE! |
Thanks for posting the link Nevada. As someone who hasn't reached the level of breaking down tape, there's certainly some very interesting and entertaining film here worthy of review and discussion (traveling, jump stops, etc.) at all levels.
|
Quote:
:rolleyes: |
Quote:
|
Quote:
I certainly think that there is benefit to be gained from watching those videos, if done with the proper mindset. |
Quote:
|
Really Nevada? I just don't see that the defender was ever in the path of the offensive player in this one. He was still moving trying to get into the path but didn't quite get there before the contact. It wasn't like he was in the path and moving to maintain position.
|
Quote:
I watched the video before I read any of the commentary about the play. I would have gone with a block as well. It appeared to me, especially from the endline angle, that the defender leaned into the ball handler. On the non official terminology scale, the defender didn't "take it in the chest" which some consider the #1 determinate of a block/charge. It further could be argued, that the defender was out side his vertical plane when you see the way he leans sideways. As to the explaination, the fact that the NBA would favor the offense is a no brainer. Too bad it really doesn't work! |
Al Sleet, The Hippy Dippy Weatherman ...
Quote:
(Note: R rated. Make sure the kiddies, or your Mom, are in another room.) |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
I said SOME not I!!! Plus, since it was a rules thing, JR wants me to use a different color BLUE font and I just cant settle on one.:D
|
Quote:
|
FWIW, I've got a block.
|
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:53am. |