Wrong basket
Jump ball goes to A1 in his backcourt.
A1 dribbles towards the wrong bucket and throws towards the basket (attempt). The ball does not go in and A1 gets the rebound. A1 then begins to dribble back towards his frontcourt realizing his wrongdoing. legal play? Or do we have some sort of violation? |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Illegal dribble
|
Basically, A1 took a shot attempt... everyone was yelling NO, NO - Wrong Way!
A1 realizes this, gets the rebound after it missed. Grabbed the ball and strated to dribble back towards his F/C. I thought this could be called a double dribble. Because the shot is not consider a legal try since it was the wrong basket, therefore you have an illegal dribble. All of the officials I have spoken with in the local association said this was fine and I still was not sure - which is why I posted here. Is this supported in the Rule Book or Case Book. Thanks! |
4.15.4 Situation C
|
Quote:
|
Is my reasoning correct? These guys may argue and one of them is the assignor.
|
Quote:
The ball hitting the opponent's backboard is the same as the ball hitting the floor. (You'll find that statement (or something substantially close to it) in the rules book). So, dribble, followed by hold, followed by throwing the ball against the backboard, followed by touch is the same as dribble, hold, dribble. No one would have trouble calling the second a violation; they shouldn't have any trouble calling the first a violation. You can also point out the case play mentioned in this thread, and the dfinition of "try" (specifically "at your own basket.") |
Quote:
At the very least, you would need to approach them with tact. |
Pefect. Thanks Bob ... one more, but am I correct in saying that you can't have a legal try at your opponent's basket and that adds to why you can't get a rebound and begin to dribble again?
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Another thing to consider on this if AI was fouled as he shot (threw) the ball at the wrong basket. If the ball goes in, I believe, the basket does not count since the foul causes the ball to immediately become dead. If he misses the shot, he gets it out of bounds nearest the spot of the foul (unless they are in the bonus).
|
Quote:
Whether he misses or if the ball goes in, designated throw-in at the spot nearest the foul. |
Just Checking ???
A1 receives a pass in his backcourt. For some reason A1 gets confused and throws a set shot toward the wrong basket, never lifting his pivot foot off the floor. The ball clangs and bounces around the basket and backboard, and finally falls fall off the rim and bounces on the floor. A1, with one hand, taps the ball the the ground and keeps on dribbling, now in the right direction. Legal? Right?
|
Quote:
|
BillyMac, I would say that would be a legal play. The "set shot" would be the start of the dribble, and since they continued the dribble when the ball hit the floor and did not catch and start a NEW dribble - what you described is an illegal dribble.
|
And if a player attempts a jump shot at the wrong basket and gets their own rebound, it's a violation because the dribble was started with the pivot foot off the ground, right?
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
[HEDGE BET]Just in case you weren't being jocular, I was just trying to keep it gender neutral[/HEDGE BET] |
Quote:
"And if players attempt a jump shot at the wrong basket and get their own rebound...." |
Quote:
http://s3.amazonaws.com/readers/2008...o-headed_1.jpg |
Quote:
|
Quote:
BTW - my wife has always objected to the use of the term "mankind" - not because she thinks it's not gender neutral, but because she doesn't think men are kind. :) |
Quote:
|
Sounds easy until it actually happens
Saw this in 7th Grade Girls.
A1 throws the ball at the wrong basket and misses. B1 rebounds the ball and takes two dribbles toward the other end of the court and passes ahead to B2 who lays it in. Tweet. Official waives off the basket. Why? |
Quote:
|
Newbies
Newbies. Should have specified. I think most everyone will get the right answer. The post was more for amusement at the situation then for the ruling.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Johnnie Walker's Blue Label ???
Quote:
|
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:46pm. |