The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Basketball (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/)
-   -   Foul + goaltending (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/55951-foul-goaltending.html)

smbbcoach99 Wed Dec 16, 2009 02:15pm
Foul + goaltending
 
Situation: A3 is shooting a 2 pt shot. And:

(a) is fouled by b4 on the shot- that misses and defensive goaltending is called on b5.

(b) is fouled by b4 on the shot- that makes and defensive goaltending is called on b5

(c)is fouled by b4 on the shot- that misses and offensive goaltending is called on a1

(d) is fouled by b4 on the shot- that makes and offensive goaltending is called on a1.

The question is what is the result of the play as for basket and shots.

tjones1 Wed Dec 16, 2009 02:18pm
Quote:
Originally Posted by smbbcoach99 (Post 643077)
Situation: A3 is shooting a 2 pt shot. And:

(a) is fouled by b4 on the shot- that misses and defensive goaltending is called on b5.

(b) is fouled by b4 on the shot- that makes and defensive goaltending is called on b5

(c)is fouled by b4 on the shot- that misses and offensive goaltending is called on a1

(d) is fouled by b4 on the shot- that makes and offensive goaltending is called on a1.

The question is what is the result of the play as for basket and shots.
(a) Count the bucket - 1 shot.
(b) Count the bucket - 1 shot.
(c) No bucket - 2 shots.
(d) Cancel the bucket - 2 shots.

SAK Wed Dec 16, 2009 02:41pm
Quote:
Originally Posted by smbbcoach99 (Post 643077)
Situation: A3 is shooting a 2 pt shot. And:

(a) is fouled by b4 on the shot- that misses and defensive goaltending is called on b5.

(b) is fouled by b4 on the shot- that makes and defensive goaltending is called on b5

(c)is fouled by b4 on the shot- that misses and offensive goaltending is called on a1

(d) is fouled by b4 on the shot- that makes and offensive goaltending is called on a1.

The question is what is the result of the play as for basket and shots.
a) Foul, 2 shots and 2 points for goaltending.
b) Score the basket and 1 shot
c) Foul 2 shots, and there is no such thing as offensive goaltending.
d) Foul 2 shots, and there is no such thing as offensive goaltending. If you mean basket interference that is possible but not goaltending.

On goaltending the points are awarded due to a violation not due to a good goal.

bob jenkins Wed Dec 16, 2009 02:50pm
Quote:
Originally Posted by SAK (Post 643089)
a) Foul, 2 shots and 2 points for goal tending.
wrong

Quote:
b) Score the basket and 1 shot.
right

Quote:
c) Foul 2 shots, and there is no such thing as offensive goal tending..
wrong

Quote:
d) Foul 2 shots, and there is no such thing as offensive goal tending. If you mean basket interference that is possible but not goal tending.
wrong.

1 out of 4 ain't bad.

(Exhibit 1 in people should look up the rules rather than just post whatever reandom thoughts pop into their heads)

tjones1 Wed Dec 16, 2009 02:53pm
Quote:
Originally Posted by SAK (Post 643089)
a) Foul, 2 shots and 2 points for goaltending.
b) Score the basket and 1 shot
c) Foul 2 shots, and there is no such thing as offensive goaltending.
d) Foul 2 shots, and there is no such thing as offensive goaltending. If you mean basket interference that is possible but not goaltending.

On goaltending the points are awarded due to a violation not due to a good goal.
a) 2 shots, are you sure?
b) Ok
c) No such thing as offensive goaltending, are you sure?
d) Same as c)

representing Wed Dec 16, 2009 07:07pm
So, what's the official ruling on these plays? Where would I find this in the rulebook?

bob jenkins Wed Dec 16, 2009 09:23pm
Quote:
Originally Posted by representing (Post 643195)
So, what's the official ruling on these plays? Where would I find this in the rulebook?
Really!?

tjones gave the correct answers.

Rule 10-Penalty Summary


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:09pm.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1