Pass to Head to Hoop
You know things are going your way when you make a pass that hits a defender in the forehead and drops in...
YouTube - Tri Unity vs Potters House Off the head shot |
Did I see the official signaled only 2 points?
He was well beyond the arc - should've been 3. |
two
I didn't take the time this weekend to look it up - believe they ruled because it was touched inside the arc it was a two.
You see the assistant coach wanted a three.. |
Quote:
|
By rule, this should be a 3. Any thrown ball that starts outside the arc and then goes in a player's own basket without touching the floor, a teammate or an official counts as 3. I think it's 5-2-1.
Having said that, there's NO WAY that this type of play should be awarded 3 points. It was obviously not a try for goal, it was just a lucky bounce. There is a case play (I can't remember the reference) in which a 3-point try falls short of the goal, bounces off a defender and then goes in the basket. It is ruled as a 2-point basket because the try clearly ended. This, IMHO, clearly contradicts the rule but is the correct ruling. 5-2-1 needs to be re-written so that if it applies only to the "alley-oops" play (where it MIGHT have been a try) and not to "any" thrown ball (which is obviously NOT a try). |
NCAA rules - 2 points?
Using NCAA rules, I would count this as two points. My rationale is that this is not a successful try from beyond the three-point line by the blue player, but rather the white player's directing the ball (with his head) into blue's basket.
Rule 5-1: Art. 1. A goal from the field other than from beyond the three-point line shall count two points for the team into whose basket the ball is thrown, tapped or directed. Art. 2. A successful try from beyond the three-point line shall count three points for the team when the ball is thrown or directed into its basket. a. When a player scores a field goal in the opponent’s basket, it shall count two points for the opponent regardless of the location on the playing court from where it was released. Such a field goal shall not be credited to a player in the scorebook but shall be indicated with a footnote. |
Quote:
Quote:
5.2.1 Sit. C (b) covers the OP's exact play. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
hits the shoulder of: (a) A2; or (b) B1 and rebounds to the backboard and through the basket. RULING: The three-point try ended when it was obviously short and below the ring. However, since a live ball went through the basket, two points are scored in both (a) and (b). (5-1) Quote:
|
Quote:
5-2-1 needs to be re-written to reflect what they really want the rule to be: if it MIGHT be a try, it's 3 points. If it's obvious that it's NOT a try, then it's still 2 points. |
Ever wonder why the man who invests all your money is called a broker?
Rookie officials take note: I believe that goaltending could not be called on this play, it's not a try, however basket interference could be called, because basket interference does not have to involve a try.
|
Quote:
|
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:54pm. |