Nebraska/Texas A&M OOB call

OHBBREF

OOB is not something you can go to the monitor for.

christianH

Defenitely another lesson learned.

I would have called Out of Bounds too

and I would be damn wrong

IREFU2

Nevadaref wrote
Texas A&M vs. Nebraska - Recap - February 24, 2009 - ESPN

This is from ESPN.com. See if this works for people.

Looked like his left foot was inbounds, but could not determine if the other foot was out or not. Too bad they could not use the monitor!!!!

Texas Aggie

His left foot is inbounds. So if his right foot didn't touch out when he still was touching the ball (which it probably wasn't), it was missed. You've got to pass on these unless you clearly see them because the player is simply trying to save the ball and thus is giving the other team time to get into position. In other words, if the call is going to be missed, it needs to be missed by a no-call.

refguy

That really should be the philosophy with most calls. If you think it is, or you thought you saw it, don't put air in the whistle.

Bad Zebra

Texas Aggie wrote
His left foot is inbounds. So if his right foot didn't touch out when he still was touching the ball (which it probably wasn't), it was missed. You've got to pass on these unless you clearly see them because the player is simply trying to save the ball and thus is giving the other team time to get into position. In other words, if the call is going to be missed, it needs to be missed by a no-call.

This seems about as basic as it gets. If you can't see it, you can't call it. NEVER GUESS. Camp 101. They screwed the pooch. However, after viewing it at full speed...that's one tough call!

rbmartin

Where would you inbound the ball after this play?

Scratch85

rbmartin wrote
Where would you inbound the ball after this play?

Where it went OOB. Nebraska's (white) endline.

JeffRobinson

I'm a husker fan and this one was tough to see. Guess they shouldnt have choked an 18 point lead, or missed the front end of a 1 and 1 with 30 sec remaining.

Adam

rbmartin wrote
Where would you inbound the ball after this play?

Scratch85 wrote
Where it went OOB. Nebraska's (white) endline.

Yup, did you have some place else in mind?

JugglingReferee

Bad Zebra wrote
This seems about as basic as it gets. If you can't see it, you can't call it. NEVER GUESS. Camp 101. They screwed the pooch. However, after viewing it at full speed...that's one tough call!

refguy wrote
That really should be the philosophy with most calls. If you think it is, or you thought you saw it, don't put air in the whistle.

I'm going to go out on a limb (😉<GRIN>) and say that at the time of the call, the calling official was certain of his call. I'll also claim that looking at video, he will gladly acknowledge his mistake.

JeffRobinson

I found Nebraska Coach Doc Sadlers comments on the play. Classy way of handling the situation.

Prior to Thursday’s practice, Nebraska head coach Doc Sadler was asked whether he thought senior guard Steve Harley was actually out of bounds while trying to make a save along the baseline in the final seconds of the Huskers’ loss to Texas A&M.

The call was that Harley stepped out of bounds with 5.4 seconds remaining while trying to save the ball after senior Ade Dagunduro threw the ball down court in an attempt to run out the clock.

As a result of the call, the Aggies got one last possession to win the game, and guard Josh Carter drained a 3-pointer as time expired to hand the Huskers a devastating 57-55 loss.

Anyway, here was Sadler’s response to the question:

“No, he was not,” he said. “He wasn’t on the line. But again, that doesn’t matter.”

Despite disagreeing on the crucial call, Sadler said he doesn’t blame the officials for the loss.

“We can sit here and talk about that, because it doesn’t do any good,” Sadler said. “It’s frustrating, but if you were to tell me we’d have a chance play Texas A&M again and we’re going to have those same three officials, I’d say I’d like to have them all 30 games. Those guys did a great job. It just didn’t go our way.”

referee99

JeffRobinson wrote
“We can sit here and talk about that, because it doesn’t do any good,” Sadler said. “It’s frustrating, but if you were to tell me we’d have a chance play Texas A&M again and we’re going to have those same three officials, I’d say I’d like to have them all 30 games. Those guys did a great job. It just didn’t go our way.”

...

bigdogrunnin

Class act by the Nebraska coach. I wish there were more like that.

Also, I do believe the C that made the call was none other than Tom O'Neill. Yeah, we know he missed it, but it's hard to argue with an official with his experience . . . at least at that moment in time. Later . . . sure. 😉