New Correctable error casebook play 2.10.1 - NCAA treatment

[bob jenkins]

Originally Posted by CallMeMrRef

I know that there have been several threads regarding the new NFHS casebook plays on correctable errors. My specific inquiry is if anyone has definitive knowledge as to whether the ruling in 2.10.1 situation A - line up and play off make or miss - is the correct procedure for NCAA men's rules?

If it is not, why not? The wording of NFHS rule 2-10.6 and NCAA 2-12.5 are almost identical and do not give rise to any apparent difference between the tow codes.

A similar play happened with about 3.3 seconds left in a Div-II game and many officials disagree with the treament. In the play B-2 rebounded the first shot miss and immediately called timeout. During the timeout the table informed referees that it should have been 2 shots (additional information: thisis after the table originally told officials that the scoreboard was wrong and it was only 9 fouls!!! - talk about your nightmare).

My view is that the case play is NOT correct at the NCAA level (or, for that matter, at the NFHS level).

That said, I don't have the NCAA case book handy to check on any of its rulings -- but the case book is on-line and since it seems so importatn to you, maybe you would take the initiative to check it out yourself.