Coaching Box Question

[jearef]

This issue was raised in another thread, and I want to see what the veteran posters think. Head coach gets ejected in the 1st half. Is the assistant now allowed to stand, or does the loss of the box for HC mean loss of the box for all? I admit that I had always assumed that once it's gone, it's gone, but looking at the language of the rule and considering some other possibilities, I'm no longer sure.

The rule says that the 1st direct or indirect to HC "results in loss of coaching box privilege and the head coach must remain seated. . ." We say that the assistant doesn't get to stand because only the HC can stand, and we dumped him. But, if we extend that logic, what happens when a player on the bench MF's us? Rule says we charge that indirectly to HC, but we dumped the HC. We can't have it both ways, can we?

[Ignats75]

Loss of box is permanent for the game. No second chance after ejection. Why would you reward a team for extremely bad behavior?

[Adam]

Let me just pose this question.

Do you really think the rules committee wants the team to gain an advantage (renewed use of the coaching box) from their coach earning a 2nd direct T?

[Ignats75]

HAH! Beat you to it!

[Adam]

Originally Posted by Ignats75

HAH! Beat you to it!

I've been asking that question all day in the other thread.

[Ignats75]

Originally Posted by Snaqwells

I've been asking that question all day in the other thread.

Doesn't count. Its off topic.

[Adam]

Originally Posted by Ignats75

Doesn't count. Its off topic.

Shut up.

[Scratch85]

Originally Posted by jearef

"We can't have it both ways, can we?

We aren't having it both ways. IMO, in HS (FED), the adult replacing the HC is now acting as HC and has all the same privelelges that the HC had when ejected. We need to quit thinking of it as "the HC is seatbelted" and think of it only as "coaching box priveleges are gone."

[Mark T. DeNucci, Sr.]

Originally Posted by Scratch85

We aren't having it both ways. IMO, in HS (FED), the adult replacing the HC is now acting as HC and has all the same privelelges that the HC had when ejected. We need to quit thinking of it as "the HC is seatbelted" and think of it only as "coaching box priveleges are gone."

Scratch:

I could not have said it better myself. Well done lad.

MTD, Sr.

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by Mark T. DeNucci, Sr.

Scratch:

I could not have said it better myself. Well done lad.

MTD, Sr.

Come on, give yourself some credit. Your spelling would have been better.

From 10.5.1 SITUATION F: ...Whenever the coach has been charged (directly or indirectly) with a technical foul , he/she shall be informed that the privilege of using the coaching box has been lost for the entire game...

Slightly off-topic (from the category of "I did not know that":
From 10.5.1 SITUATION E:...However, if the coach begins the game by sitting somewhere other than where the box is located, he/she may not use the box privileges any time during the game. The coach must begin the game in a position within the box if he/she wishes to stand when permitted under the optional coaching-box provisions.

I wonder how many cowards are afraid to enforce this rule.

[Scratch85]

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef

Come on, give yourself some credit. Your spelling would have been better.

Slightly off-topic (from the category of "I did not know that":
From 10.5.1 SITUATION E:...However, if the coach begins the game by sitting somewhere other than where the box is located, he/she may not use the box privileges any time during the game. The coach must begin the game in a position within the box if he/she wishes to stand when permitted under the optional coaching-box provisions.

I wonder how many cowards are afraid to enforce this rule.

Thanks for that bit of info. I definitely did not know that. And I am probably one of those cowards you refer to. But, I like to think of it as game management not cowardice.

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by Scratch85

Thanks for that bit of info. I definitely did not know that. And I am probably one of those cowards you refer to. But, I like to think of it as game management not cowardice.

You obviously are not yet an esteemed member.

[bob jenkins]

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef

Slightly off-topic (from the category of "I did not know that":
From 10.5.1 SITUATION E:...However, if the coach begins the game by sitting somewhere other than where the box is located, he/she may not use the box privileges any time during the game. The coach must begin the game in a position within the box if he/she wishes to stand when permitted under the optional coaching-box provisions.

I wonder how many cowards are afraid to enforce this rule.

Had it in our regional game the other night. We told the coach we would enforce it. He chose to sit in the box to start the game.

[WreckRef]

From 2005-2006 points of emphasis:

"D. Coaching box: The committee wants coaches to stay in the coaching box. There is a constant problem when coaches wander...

Once the coaching box has been removed because of a technical foul, all related rules restrictions must apply. There's no way to get the box back after the privilege has been lost."

http://www.nfhs.org/web/2005/05/2005..._emphasis.aspx

To me that says once the privilege has been removed, it can't come back.

Sort of a side question. If the HC is ejected does this mean that any T's that would have been indirectly applied to the HC do not get applied to the AC? I would say they can't because the AC doesn't magically become the HC, he's still the AC.

Yes or no?

[mick]

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef

Slightly off-topic (from the category of "I did not know that":
From 10.5.1 SITUATION E:...However, if the coach begins the game by sitting somewhere other than where the box is located, he/she may not use the box privileges any time during the game. The coach must begin the game in a position within the box if he/she wishes to stand when permitted under the optional coaching-box provisions.

I wonder how many cowards are afraid to enforce this rule.

I reminded both VB coaches of that last night.