The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Basketball (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/)
-   -   Ruling (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/51445-ruling.html)

fullor30 Thu Feb 05, 2009 11:04am

Ruling
 
Just got this situation via e-mail and doing a cut and paste. Haven't checked books. I'm saying sub should have shot free throws. This actually happened recently. I also think below is correctable if fouled out player shot.


"Close to the end of the game, a player gets fouled and retaliates by shoving the player who fouled him and gets introduced to "Mr T" for his efforts.

The player who was fouled shoots his free throws and makes both of them, followed by the T shots. After the free throws are all shot, the scorer notifies the officials that the player who got the T (and made 2 free throws) had fouled out.

What do you do?"

bob jenkins Thu Feb 05, 2009 11:09am

Quote:

Originally Posted by fullor30 (Post 576024)
Just got this situation via e-mail and doing a cut and paste. Haven't checked books. [/I]


Check your books.

The play stands -- the player is not DQ'd until you're notified.

refguy Thu Feb 05, 2009 11:09am

Notify the coach that he has fouled out. Beckon the sub on the court and continue from the throw-in at the division line.

stosh Thu Feb 05, 2009 11:11am

IMO, a correctable error and the two free throws (not the "T throws") are reshot, whether they were good or not, since it was caught prior to the ball ever becoming live.

referee99 Thu Feb 05, 2009 11:13am

What's done is done.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by fullor30 (Post 576024)
"Close to the end of the game, a player gets fouled and retaliates by shoving the player who fouled him and gets introduced to "Mr T" for his efforts.

The player who was fouled shoots his free throws and makes both of them, followed by the T shots. After the free throws are all shot, the scorer notifies the officials that the player who got the T (and made 2 free throws) had fouled out.

What do you do?"

To parse your OP, A1 is fouled by B1 and A1 responds by contacting B1. Intentional player technical is called on A1.

A1 shoots his FTs, and then a Team B player shoots their FTs for the technical.

Officials are then notified that A1 has 5 fouls.

If that is the correct parsing:
Inform Team A coach that A1 is disqualified, once a substitute is in, Team B ball for a division line throw-in. A1's made free-throws are 'in the barn'.

refguy Thu Feb 05, 2009 11:13am

It is not correctable. The right player shot the free throws since the scorer never notified the officials that he was disqualified. What Bob said above.

Adam Thu Feb 05, 2009 11:17am

Quote:

Originally Posted by stosh (Post 576033)
IMO, a correctable error and the two free throws (not the "T throws") are reshot, whether they were good or not, since it was caught prior to the ball ever becoming live.

Always listen to Bob.

fullor30 Thu Feb 05, 2009 11:32am

Quote:

Originally Posted by bob jenkins (Post 576027)
Check your books.

The play stands -- the player is not DQ'd until you're notified.

Another situation, if you were notified, but erroneously allowed player to shoot FT's , then realize the error of your ways, would it be correctable in the allowed timeline? I'm assuming 2-10-1c would apply.

mbyron Thu Feb 05, 2009 11:47am

Quote:

Originally Posted by fullor30 (Post 576046)
Another situation, if you were notified, but erroneously allowed player to shoot FT's , then realize the error of your ways, would it be correctable in the allowed timeline? I'm assuming 2-10-1c would apply.

Yes. You've administered unmerited FT's. I can't see anyone doing this, but... yes.

Scrapper1 Thu Feb 05, 2009 11:53am

Quote:

Originally Posted by bob jenkins (Post 576027)
The play stands -- the player is not DQ'd until you're notified.

Quote:

Originally Posted by refguy (Post 576036)
It is not correctable. The right player shot the free throws since the scorer never notified the officials that he was disqualified. What Bob said above.

As refguy says, it is NOT correctable. However, he and Bob are not correct about WHEN the player is disqualified. The player is not DQ'd until the official notifies the COACH that the player has been DQ'd. 4-14-2.

CMHCoachNRef Thu Feb 05, 2009 08:56pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by fullor30 (Post 576024)
Just got this situation via e-mail and doing a cut and paste. Haven't checked books. I'm saying sub should have shot free throws. This actually happened recently. I also think below is correctable if fouled out player shot.


"Close to the end of the game, a player gets fouled and retaliates by shoving the player who fouled him and gets introduced to "Mr T" for his efforts.

The player who was fouled shoots his free throws and makes both of them, followed by the T shots. After the free throws are all shot, the scorer notifies the officials that the player who got the T (and made 2 free throws) had fouled out.

What do you do?"

OK, we have determined that in this case, the 2 FTs by the player-with-5-fouls-but-not-yet-DQ'd stand.

How about these three situations:
Player A5 has committed his 5th foul as in the OP. He is shooting two FTs as in the OP.
Situation 1: A5 has the ball at his disposal for the first free throw when the trail official is notified of the DQ.
Situation 2: A5 has released the ball for his first FT, but it is clearly not yet to the basket when the trail official is notified of the DQ.
Situation 3: A5 has released the ball on his first FT, as the ball is in the air B1 violates by going below the FT line extended and the ball does not go in. The trail official is notified of the DQ as the ball was in the air.

How are the three situations handled? In Sitch 1 and Sitch 2, does the FT have to complete once the ball is at the disposition of the shooter or in the air or are you going to cancel the FT and have A6 take the FTs? In Sitch 3, does A5 get to take the replacement FT?

refguy Thu Feb 05, 2009 09:29pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Scrapper1 (Post 576062)
As refguy says, it is NOT correctable. However, he and Bob are not correct about WHEN the player is disqualified. The player is not DQ'd until the official notifies the COACH that the player has been DQ'd. 4-14-2.

I guess I didn't finish the thought in an effort toward expediency. I guess I shouldn't assume that all officials would immediately notify the coach when notified by the scorer. Those that wouldn't should probably go see a short term memory specialist.

hugheske44 Thu Feb 05, 2009 11:28pm

This may sounds stupid...but when A1 fouls out and we catch it before he shoots his shots for the personal foul....does team A still get 2 shots for the personal foul, or since hes disqualified would someone else shoot them or no shots because he became disqualified?

Sorry for the long run on sentence there:eek:

HawkeyeCubP Fri Feb 06, 2009 01:39am

Quote:

Originally Posted by hugheske44 (Post 576232)
This may sounds stupid...but when A1 fouls out and we catch it before he shoots his shots for the personal foul....does team A still get 2 shots for the personal foul, or since hes disqualified would someone else shoot them or no shots because he became disqualified?

Sorry for the long run on sentence there:eek:

His sub shoots the free throws.

Nevadaref Fri Feb 06, 2009 05:53am

Consult the PAST INTERPS ARCHIVE!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by fullor30 (Post 576024)
Just got this situation via e-mail and doing a cut and paste. Haven't checked books. I'm saying sub should have shot free throws. This actually happened recently. I also think below is correctable if fouled out player shot.


"Close to the end of the game, a player gets fouled and retaliates by shoving the player who fouled him and gets introduced to "Mr T" for his efforts.

The player who was fouled shoots his free throws and makes both of them, followed by the T shots. After the free throws are all shot, the scorer notifies the officials that the player who got the T (and made 2 free throws) had fouled out.

What do you do?"

This situation pops up every now and then. The NFHS has provided a definitive answer. It is in our past interps archive.

http://forum.officiating.com/showpos...8&postcount=33


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:51am.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1