I'm probably the only one who saw it

[Adam]

JVB 3 whistle. I’m C in transition. B1 catches ball near division line, both feet in front court. As he begins to race towards his basket, he takes a quick stutter step backwards to build momentum and start his dribble. Problem is he didn’t have room for that move and his short step took him into BC territory; right in front of me as C. I had the call, but didn’t like making it for a variety of reasons.

Question: is this a call the C should get?

Rant: I hate calling things that only I can see.

Observation: I really need to get more 3 whistle games to develop better partner awareness. Fortunately, 4 of my 5 games next week are three person.

[Scratch85]

Originally Posted by Snaqwells

Question: is this a call the C should get?

C has Tip to Tip, sideline to sideline in transition. Yes, that is C's call

[HawkeyeCubP]

This exact topic has been brought up twice in recent college pregames I've been on. I say get it, for sure. Just sell it.

[Rufus]

First, that's great their doing 3-man for JV games in your area. I wish we had that here.

Second, I think if you have the call you need to make it regardless of location. I know we've discussed numerous times covering your primary, but in this case it seems you had a clear view of the play. Your partners may wonder simply because they may not have seen it, but that goes with the territory of trusting the folks you work with (or should).

[chartrusepengui]

Did you see it?
Yes - call it!
No - don't call it!
Not sure - don't call it!

[Adam]

Originally Posted by Rufus

First, that's great their doing 3-man for JV games in your area. I wish we had that here.

Agreed. This area is, I think, the first in CO to do JV this way. $6 less per game, but well worth it for the 3-person experience as well as the extra games it provides.

I was pretty sure this is C's call, especially on my sideline 5 feet away from me. T was curious later and thought he'd had a good look at it. I could tell he disagreed, but he let it go after I told him what I saw.

[mick]

Originally Posted by Snaqwells

JVB 3 whistle. I’m C in transition. B1 catches ball near division line, both feet in front court. As he begins to race towards his basket, he takes a quick stutter step backwards to build momentum and start his dribble. Problem is he didn’t have room for that move and his short step took him into BC territory; right in front of me as C. I had the call, but didn’t like making it for a variety of reasons.

Question: is this a call the C should get?

Rant: I hate calling things that only I can see.

Observation: I really need to get more 3 whistle games to develop better partner awareness. Fortunately, 4 of my 5 games next week are three person.

YU.P.
The Center [ahead of the ball] should pause at the division line to take a trouble call just like that.
We'll get it next time.

[zm1283]

I would call it. It really is the T's line, but if he isn't far enough up court yet, you really have to get it if you see it. Better to get it than see it and let it go just because it may not be "your call".

[rockyroad]

Originally Posted by Snaqwells

Agreed. This area is, I think, the first in CO to do JV this way. $6 less per game, but well worth it for the 3-person experience as well as the extra games it provides.

I was pretty sure this is C's call, especially on my sideline 5 feet away from me. T was curious later and thought he'd had a good look at it. I could tell he disagreed, but he let it go after I told him what I saw.

In 3-person, you have the "alley" from sideline to sideline when in transition...you are the only one who can see this, so call it. The same would be true if there was a big crash PC/block type call - the C has to come across and get those because as T, I am looking at nothing but the ball-handler's back. These are fantastic C calls.