The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Basketball (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/)
-   -   Why the Seeming Discrepancy? (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/50238-why-seeming-discrepancy.html)

Freddy Mon Dec 08, 2008 10:29pm

Why the Seeming Discrepancy?
 
2-10-5, on the topic of correctible errors, says, "Points scored...prior to the recognition of an error, shall not be nullified."

But 2.10.1.G says, "A1 is fouled prior to the bonus, but erroneously A1 is awarded a one-and-one. The error is discovered: ... (b) after A1 makes both. RULING: In ... (b), the successful free throw(s) is cancelled..."

The rule seems to state that points cannot be nullified; the casebook states clearly that points can be nullified.

Can you help me understand the obvious point I'm missing here?

(happened tonite--we applied the casebook situation)

Adam Mon Dec 08, 2008 10:38pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Freddy (Post 556547)
2-10-5, on the topic of correctible errors, says, "Points scored...prior to the recognition of an error, shall not be nullified."

Think of this situation. A1 fouled on a three point attempt. Officials erroneously give A1 only 2 shots. A3 rebounds the missed 2nd shot and makes a basket. During the dead ball, the officials realize the error and award A1 his last free throw. A3's basket does not get nullified.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Freddy (Post 556547)
But 2.10.1.G says, "A1 is fouled prior to the bonus, but erroneously A1 is awarded a one-and-one. The error is discovered: ... (b) after A1 makes both. RULING: In ... (b), the successful free throw(s) is cancelled..."

The rule seems to state that points cannot be nullified; the casebook states clearly that points can be nullified.

Can you help me understand the obvious point I'm missing here?

(happened tonite--we applied the casebook situation)

The only points that can be nullified are the ones that were the error (unmerited free throws, counting a three instead of two).

bob jenkins Tue Dec 09, 2008 09:23am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Freddy (Post 556547)
2-10-5, on the topic of correctible errors, says, "Points scored...prior to the recognition of an error, shall not be nullified."


Yes, but 2-10-4 says that unmerited FTs are cancelled.

So, 2-10-5 means "Other" points ... are not nullified.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:32pm.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1