The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Basketball (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/)
-   -   Foul on jump ball to start game (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/50145-foul-jump-ball-start-game.html)

MidMadness Wed Dec 03, 2008 10:41am

Foul on jump ball to start game
 
Before the ball leaves the referees hand......Team B jumper is grabbing team A's wrist as if to hold him down. Umpire blows whistle and calls a foul on B1. This is a dead ball foul, would it have to be a technical?? Intentional??? Thanks

Rich Wed Dec 03, 2008 10:55am

Quote:

Originally Posted by MidMadness (Post 554921)
Before the ball leaves the referees hand......Team B jumper is grabbing team A's wrist as if to hold him down. Umpire blows whistle and calls a foul on B1. This is a dead ball foul, would it have to be a technical?? Intentional??? Thanks

Theoretical - I would step in and tell him to knock it off and then go back to my usual position.

Sorry, I know that's not the answer you're looking for :D

mbyron Wed Dec 03, 2008 10:56am

If the ball's still dead, I'd call a T.

Not intentional, since neither player has an advantageous position to be neutralized.

Adam Wed Dec 03, 2008 11:00am

Either a T or nothing. In this case, I'd do as Rich suggests. Tell him to knock it off, hand the ball to the thrower, and then call it a personal foul if he continues.

Rich Wed Dec 03, 2008 11:13am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Snaqwells (Post 554939)
Either a T or nothing. In this case, I'd do as Rich suggests. Tell him to knock it off, hand the ball to the thrower, and then call it a personal foul if he continues.

Opening jump. Makes it even more unlikely I'd call anything here, although this is what needs to be called if anything.

M&M Guy Wed Dec 03, 2008 11:14am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Snaqwells (Post 554939)
Either a T or nothing. In this case, I'd do as Rich suggests. Tell him to knock it off, hand the ball to the thrower, and then call it a personal foul if he continues.

Since this is during a jump ball, how did you end up with the ball? :D

Anyway, I like doing what Rich suggests, especially if there will be a few seconds before the ball is tossed; that could save the inevitable "patty-cake" that usually goes on. Or you could hold the whistle until after the ball is tossed and immediately call the foul, which sends the message that your crew isn't going to put up with that kind of crap that night.

Adam Wed Dec 03, 2008 11:16am

Quote:

Originally Posted by M&M Guy (Post 554952)
Since this is during a jump ball, how did you end up with the ball? :D

1. I'm the R.
2. Shut up.

IREFU2 Wed Dec 03, 2008 03:44pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by MidMadness (Post 554921)
Before the ball leaves the referees hand......Team B jumper is grabbing team A's wrist as if to hold him down. Umpire blows whistle and calls a foul on B1. This is a dead ball foul, would it have to be a technical?? Intentional??? Thanks

I agree with others, I would tell them to knock it off....

OHBBREF Wed Dec 03, 2008 04:27pm

Needs to be delt with:
 
What would you do if it was a throw in and before the ball is at the disposal there is jostling for position or some tugging going on?
I make sure that it is addressed openly so everyone in the gym knows we see it, before we have to call a foul of some sort here with a dead ball.

We specifically cover these types of things in pre-game so we are all on the same page, IMO if you step in and stop this action before hand, especially on the jump, it will go along way toward a better evening, than having to give a non-administrative T before we even have the toss.

The impression given right away about being in control of things should make for a much better game.

Back In The Saddle Wed Dec 03, 2008 05:29pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by OHBBREF (Post 555105)
What would you do if it was a throw in and before the ball is at the disposal there is jostling for position or some tugging going on?

This is one of my favorite bits of game management. I'm about to hand/bounce the ball to the thrower and notice two boneheads going at, banging like they were going for a rebound in the final seconds of a one point game. I'll just stand there and watch. Because of the noticeable delay in getting the ball live, everybody in the place is soon staring at them. They usually realize it fairly quickly, give me a sheepish grin, and calm right down. I don't even have to say a word.

AKOFL Wed Dec 03, 2008 05:35pm

perfect place for preventive officiating. A few words at the right time go a long way. The players will apreciate it even if they don't say so. I remember I did when I played

Nevadaref Wed Dec 03, 2008 07:23pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by mbyron (Post 554930)
If the ball's still dead, I'd call a T.

Not intentional, since neither player has an advantageous position to be neutralized.

You are a bit confused. Because this action takes place during a dead ball period, if called, the foul MUST be technical. However, it is only to be called if it is intentional or flagrant, otherwise the contact is to be ignored by rule.

Freddy Mon Dec 07, 2020 04:13am

Dead Ball Intentional Technical Before Game
 
Before the jump ball is administered, a foul is called on A1 who illegally contacts B1 to the extent that it is not merely incidental and could not be ignored. This is an intentional technical foul because it's during dead ball. By rule, does the A team coach lose his coaching box?

SNIPERBBB Mon Dec 07, 2020 07:25am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Freddy (Post 1040431)
Before the jump ball is administered, a foul is called on A1 who illegally contacts B1 to the extent that it is not merely incidental and could not be ignored. This is an intentional technical foul because it's during dead ball. By rule, does the A team coach lose his coaching box?

I'm sure the OP had this figured out in the 12 years since his original post

Freddy Mon Dec 07, 2020 08:14am

I customarily do a search before I post a question. My search came up with that thread which is admittedly old. However it did not include consideration of the actual question I have. So please entertain my actual question and if you have any feedback that can help me I would appreciate it.

SNIPERBBB Mon Dec 07, 2020 08:49am

They'd be players at that point. For a indirect T to a Coach the player would have to be bench personnel.

Raymond Mon Dec 07, 2020 08:53am

Quote:

Originally Posted by SNIPERBBB (Post 1040434)
They'd be players at that point. For a indirect T to a Coach the player would have to be bench personnel.

At what point do team members become players prior to the ball becoming live for the opening tip. No access to any rule books at the moment, but I don't ever remember reading what the line of demarcation is.

SNIPERBBB Mon Dec 07, 2020 10:04am

It's not during intermission for the purposes of penalizing behavior. So the people on the court have to be players, excepting illegal substitutes.

Nevadaref Mon Dec 07, 2020 12:49pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Raymond (Post 1040435)
At what point do team members become players prior to the ball becoming live for the opening tip. No access to any rule books at the moment, but I don't ever remember reading what the line of demarcation is.

Once the team members enter the court for the ensuing jumpball.

Clearly, all team members are bench personnel during pregame warm-ups, but we have some indicators that warmups have ended: the clock winds down, a horn sounds, the team members remove warmup garb such as shooting shirts, pants, etc., the teams usually go to their respective benches and huddle, the individuals marked as starters take the court. At this point we have ten players on the court, even though the ball has yet to become live to start the game.


PS This must be on some review exam because I’ve had two other people contact me about this same situation this Fall. I’m curious where Freddy saw the question.

SNIPERBBB Mon Dec 07, 2020 01:03pm

Another thing is we can have violations occur prior to the actual toss as well.

BillyMac Mon Dec 07, 2020 02:27pm

Jump For My Love (The Pointer Sisters, 1984) ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by SNIPERBBB (Post 1040440)
Another thing is we can have violations occur prior to the actual toss as well.

6-3-2: When the official is ready and until the ball is tossed, nonjumpers shall not:
a. Move onto the center restraining circle.
b. Change position around the center restraining circle.


6.3.2 SITUATION: The referee is ready to toss the ball to start the game. (a) A1 who was on the center restraining circle backs off; (b) B1 moves onto the restraining circle into an unoccupied spot; (c) B2 moves off the circle and goes behind A2 and is within 3 feet of the circle; or (d) B3 moves off the circle about 5 feet and moves around behind A3 and A4 who are occupying spaces on the circle. RULING: Legal in (a) and (d), but a violation in both (b) and (c). Moving off the restraining circle in (a), and around the circle when more than 3 feet away as in (d), is permissible. It is a violation to move onto the circle as in (b), until the ball leaves the official’s hand, or into an occupied space as in (c), until the ball is touched. The violation by B results in a throw-in for Team A. (4-3)

How does one know that the tossing official is ready?

When he sounds his or her whistle?

BillyMac Mon Dec 07, 2020 02:29pm

Might As Well Jump (Van Halen, 1983) ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Nevadaref (Post 1040438)
Once the team members enter the court for the ensuing jumpball. Clearly, all team members are bench personnel during pregame warm-ups, but we have some indicators that warmups have ended: the clock winds down, a horn sounds, the team members remove warmup garb such as shooting shirts, pants, etc., the teams usually go to their respective benches and huddle, the individuals marked as starters take the court. At this point we have ten players on the court, even though the ball has yet to become live to start the game.

4-34-1: A player is one of five team members who are legally on the court at any given time, except intermission.

Freddy Mon Dec 07, 2020 03:56pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nevadaref (Post 1040438)
. . . where Freddy saw the question.

My specific question was a further application of a rules question that was asked on a state rules exam. This question came up in further discussion on the original question.
It's just a situation I had never confronted before and never investigated. I thought maybe it would be included in the past NFHS interpretations somewhere but it was not.

BillyMac Mon Dec 07, 2020 06:38pm

Timeout Or Intermission ???
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by SNIPERBBB (Post 1040437)
It's not during intermission or a timeout ...

Timeouts? Aren't the five team members players during a timeout while everybody is bench personnel during an intermission?

SNIPERBBB Mon Dec 07, 2020 07:28pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by BillyMac (Post 1040458)
Timeouts? Aren't the five team members players during a timeout while everybody is bench personnel during an intermission?

Got ahead of myself.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:44pm.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1