NCAA must call this different-with video

[oc]

I ref HS ball and sometimes rec ball with NCAA rules. Although I do some HS Varsity boys games we don't get much action above the rim in my area. Does NCAA have a much more liberal interpretation for hanging on the rim?

At the 36 second point of this video I've got an obvious T-especially when the player then hits the backboard.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4bGg7...eature=related

[JugglingReferee]

I can see this being passed in NCAA and called in HS.

[grunewar]

I asked a similar question Sunday and got a similar response.

Hanging on the Rim

Apparently, those of us "more junior" officials see this as more of an egregious infraction than our more experienced brethren.....and so, once again, I file away more information/experience from the forum......

[socalreff]

Originally Posted by grunewar

I asked a similar question Sunday and got a similar response.

Hanging on the Rim

Apparently, those of us "more junior" officials see this as more of an egregious infraction than our more experienced brethren.....and so, once again, I file away more information/experience from the forum......

It's not up to us to decide to set aside a rule...technical foul.

[Corndog89]

As a lifelong Vanderbilt fan I've got a travel on every play followed by multiple T's and ejections, just on GPs!! Otherwise, looks good to me.

[Scrapper1]

The chin-up and backboard slap should be a T at both the HS and NCAA level, IMHO. Even in the -- wait for it --

[Rich]

Originally Posted by grunewar

I asked a similar question Sunday and got a similar response.

Hanging on the Rim

Apparently, those of us "more junior" officials see this as more of an egregious infraction than our more experienced brethren.....and so, once again, I file away more information/experience from the forum......

I don't know where I sit on the experience barometer, but I don't have anything. It wasn't exactly a chin-up and he tapped the board lightly on the way down. Big deal.

[IREFU2]

Originally Posted by RichMSN

I don't know where I sit on the experience barometer, but I don't have anything. It wasn't exactly a chin-up and he tapped the board lightly on the way down. Big deal.

They get away with it on the NC2A Level, but in HS/FED, Every chin up I have seen has been called. Hanging on the rim is a T as well unless you are protecting yourself or rather someone is under you.

[JRutledge]

Maybe many of you here have never seen a chin up, but I did not see a chin up. I saw a dunk by players flying to the basket. If those are Ts, then I must have missed the memo, because those are not even close to what I have seen on video which was requested to be called.

Peace

[Rich]

Originally Posted by IREFU2

They get away with it on the NC2A Level, but in HS/FED, Every chin up I have seen has been called. Hanging on the rim is a T as well unless you are protecting yourself or rather someone is under you.

I see a fair number of dunks in a season. Technicals in those situations call themselves. Calling one on this play in any games means the official went after it. If there was a chin-up, it wasn't that obvious to me.

Still waiting for someone to mention how calling a technical here betters the game.