![]() |
Quote:
That's got to be 1 healthy tap to displace a human. If that's the case then we're not discussing a tap, we're discussing a push. |
Quote:
Iow, I'm not talking "displacement"; I'm talking "breaking the shooter's concentration. Does that make any difference to you? |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
Quote:
|
Quote:
Contact that <b>affects</b> a shooter is a foul. Always. Contact that doesn't affect the shooter is incidental contact. |
Quote:
Let me ask you something. A1 attempts a 3-pointer, B1 comes in blocks the shot but his momentum carries him and his arm into A1 before A1 returns to the floor and knocks A1 to the floor, what do you have? Furthermore, when the coach asks you, did the player block the shot first, which the answer is yes, and continues to state if it didn't affect his shot why are we shooting 3, what do you answer? This is the exact same play that happened to me in a region tourney game last night. So it's the same concept as your play, and as you can see, I had foul. BTW, me not being quick on my feet with a response it took me the 2nd of 3 free throws to answer his question. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
There's little taps in certain places that can throw a shooter completely off. That usually includes any tap, no matter how light, on the shooting arm if the tap happens while the ball is being released. A light tap on the shooter's elbow can put the shot in the stands. That's the oldest trick in the book too. And....if the tap is in a spot where it can break the shooter's concentration, and it does so imo, then I'll call the foul. If it doesn't, also imo, I won't. It doesn't take much contact either on an airborne shooter to put him on his azz. Just brushing him on the way by will do it. You can't judge whether it's a foul or not by trying to factor in the severity of the contact. Jmo.....soooooo.....I guess we disagree. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Sorry, but any <b>contact</b> by a defender that was deliberately done to <b>distract</b> the shooter, and the tap attained it's goal, is a <b>foul</b>. If the tap actually distracted the shooter, the defender is gaining an unfair advantage that was never intended by the rules. Sorry, but using contact to <b>distract</b> a shooter is a foul. Always has been. Always will be. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:17pm. |