The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Basketball (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/)
-   -   I called a forfeit (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/32164-i-called-forfeit.html)

DC_Ref12 Sat Feb 24, 2007 02:47pm

I called a forfeit
 
Oh, man, what a game. Church league boys, and Team A is ahead 27-26 with a few seconds left. A little context: for the last few minutes of the game, Team B and its fans have been complaining about the score, saying that they should be up by one. I have already gone to the official scorer to confirm that the score is wrong, so I'm just ignoring the crowd and shaking my head at Coach B and his players when they keep telling me the score is wrong.

So back to a few seconds left, when the ball rolls out of bounds as the clock is winding down. After my partner blows his whistle to stop the clock, it keeps running and the horn blows. He immediatley lets me know that he has 1 second left on the clock, I am near the score table and I let both teams know the game is not over and there is still time left.

Then all hell brakes loose.

Three players from Team B rip their jerseys off and throw them in the middle of the court and walk to their bench. B1 is on the bench, looking at me and running his mouth about how we cheated them. I call technical foul (trying to stay calm). Team B's players are all over the floor and Team B's coach is up in my face telling me how I'm trying to hand the game to Team A.

I've had enough, and I already have 3 technicals (1 on Team B's bench for B1 jawing, another on Team B's bench for the jerseys, and 1 on Team B's coach for his comments and being up in my face.)

Team B is clearly out of control, and despite the fact that there is one second left, and it's a one-point game, I call a forfeit in favor of Team A.

What do you think?

tjones1 Sat Feb 24, 2007 02:56pm

No way should you have called a forfeit. You penalized Team B for their actions and that's all that needs to be done. Shoot the free throws and make the throw-in to end the game. Certainly not grounds for a forfeit, imo.

Scrapper1 Sat Feb 24, 2007 03:02pm

In a church league boys game, I have no problem with it. Make sure you let the "commissioner" of the league exactly what was said prior to your decision.

Mark T. DeNucci, Sr. Sat Feb 24, 2007 03:45pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by tjones1
No way should you have called a forfeit. You penalized Team B for their actions and that's all that needs to be done. Shoot the free throws and make the throw-in to end the game. Certainly not grounds for a forfeit, imo.


tjones1:

I beg to differ, the actions of the Team B Head Coach and players, was a perfect example of when to forfeit the game, and I do not care what level the game is.

Three years ago, I had a boys' H.S. jr. varsity game. I charged Head Coach V with a direct technical foul in the second quarter for unsportsmanlike behavior. With just 55 seconds left in the game, Team V has the ball in its front court and is losing by four points. I am L opposite the ST and the ball is above the free throw line extended on the strong side, when V1 attempts a three-point field goal. V1's attempt is not good and during the scramble for the rebound, V2 (Team V's captain and the son the Head Coach) goes done with a knee injury just outside the free throw lane on the weak (Table) side of the court. The loose ball was going out of bounds on my endline on the weak side of the court. The ball goes out of bounds off of H1 and I stop the game for the violation as well as the injury. V-HC goes ballistic on my partner because there was no foul called against Team H when V2 went to the floor. While this is happening I am standing next to V2 and trying to get V-HC to direct his attention to V2's medical needs; at that point my partner charges V-HC with his second direct techincal foul of the game. There are 46 seconds left in the game at this time. Now V-HC goes nuclear and charges past his assistant coaches toward my partner and I at the ST screaming obscenities. V-HC's assistants grab him back toward their bench, but he is still screaming and it is the Home school's trainer who is attending to V2, no one from Team V's staff is with V2. V-HC will not leave the court and his assistants claim they cannot and will not make him leave the court. My parter (who was the R) decided that enough was enough and it was time to end the game. And that is what we did. We were not going to wait around while V's AD tried to convince V-HC to go to the locker room so that we could administer two free throws for Team A and then play out the last 46 seconds. This game was over. Team V actions should that it did not want to play basketball.

MTD, Sr.

grunewar Sat Feb 24, 2007 04:16pm

Mark - actions such as you describe above are great examples of veterans controlling a game us newer refs need to learn from.

I had one coach "go nuclear" on me earlier this year and I should have tossed him and didn't. I learned a valuable lesson. Now, as the year winds down, and I have learned and seen a lot, I'd like to think I would have less of a problem tossing a jerk!

JugglingReferee Sat Feb 24, 2007 04:48pm

I support your decision.

Old School Sat Feb 24, 2007 05:19pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by DC_Ref12
Oh, man, what a game. Church league boys, and Team A is ahead 27-26 with a few seconds left. A little context: for the last few minutes of the game, Team B and its fans have been complaining about the score, saying that they should be up by one. I have already gone to the official scorer to confirm that the score is wrong, so I'm just ignoring the crowd and shaking my head at Coach B and his players when they keep telling me the score is wrong.

Got a problem here. You confirm that the score was wrong and you didn't correct it? And you shook your head at the coach afterwards! What the hell! However, I agree with you calling the game after all the violations that occurred afterwards. No need in playing out the last few seconds if the technicals are against the team that's down. Thank goodness nothing happened to you with all the mess going on here. If I could add any input, you can't let things fester. You have to get an understanding / ending to a problem. Does the book match the scoreboard? If it does, the score is correct and you've done your part. The issue is now closed!

Unbelievable ending....

tjones1 Sat Feb 24, 2007 05:30pm

I read these situations differently I guess, and we might be missing some information. We all agree that Team B's coach is ejected from the game (1 direct and 2 indirect), if he didn't leave I completely agree with the forfeit. In Mark's situation, the coach refused it leave. Coach obviously failed to comply with the technical-foul penalty, therefore the referee made the right choice to forfeit.

blindmanwalking Sat Feb 24, 2007 05:31pm

Did you give them... the STOP SIGN? This probably would have fixed everything. ;)

Really, good job.

tjones1 Sat Feb 24, 2007 05:32pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Old School
No need in playing out the last few seconds if the technicals are against the team that's down.

There's still time on the clock, you have to shoot the free throws.

mick Sat Feb 24, 2007 06:23pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by tjones1
There's still time on the clock, you have to shoot the free throws.

Not me Tanner. It's done.
I don't have to be staying around that riot.
Nor do I have to return. :)

TimTaylor Sat Feb 24, 2007 06:38pm

Only 3 T's? Sounds more like 5 to me - each team member that removed his jersey get one of his very own...........

I can see both MTD's and tjones1's points & IMHO opinion you could have gone either way. The situations are different (though once you tossed B's coach they might not have been) & from a purely technical standpoint you probably should have at least gone through the procedure, but given the volatile situation & there only being 1 second on the clock just ending it as you did may have prevented further problems.

Bottom line - you & partner were there and had to make the immediate decision based on what you perceived the situation to be. We all get to sit back & analyze it after the fact.........

DC_Ref12 Sat Feb 24, 2007 07:08pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Old School
Got a problem here. You confirm that the score was wrong and you didn't correct it? And you shook your head at the coach afterwards! What the hell! However, I agree with you calling the game after all the violations that occurred afterwards. No need in playing out the last few seconds if the technicals are against the team that's down. Thank goodness nothing happened to you with all the mess going on here. If I could add any input, you can't let things fester. You have to get an understanding / ending to a problem. Does the book match the scoreboard? If it does, the score is correct and you've done your part. The issue is now closed!

Unbelievable ending....

Sorry, that was a typo. I confirmed with the scorekeeper that the score was correct.

I'm still torn as to if I did the right thing - maybe just because I feel bad for the kids on Team B that really didn't do anything wrong, but I know that shouldn't influence my decision.

In my opinion, the game was completely out of hand, and neither Team B's coach nor his players were listening to anything we were saying or doing. They were, in the truest sense of the phrase, out of control and I didn't feel like there was anything I could do to reel them in.

tjones1 Sat Feb 24, 2007 07:17pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by DC_Ref12
In my opinion, the game was completely out of hand, and neither Team B's coach nor his players were listening to anything we were saying or doing. They were, in the truest sense of the phrase, out of control and I didn't feel like there was anything I could do to reel them in.


Ok, with that information, I have no problem with calling forfeit. In that sense, they didn't comply with the penalty of the technical foul(s), thus the forfeit. Sounds good to me.

tjones1 Sat Feb 24, 2007 07:20pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by mick
Not me Tanner. It's done.
I don't have to be staying around that riot.
Nor do I have to return. :)

Yabut, what if they missed all their free throws, couldn't inbound the call and got a 5 second violation, and then hit a last second shot? :D :p

Old School Sat Feb 24, 2007 07:26pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by DC_Ref12
I'm still torn as to if I did the right thing - maybe just because I feel bad for the kids on Team B that really didn't do anything wrong, but I know that shouldn't influence my decision.

First of all, taking there jersey's off and throwing it into the stands before the game is over is wrong. 2nd, once you addressed and confirmed the score, you're done discussing it. If the coach still disagrees, you need to access a technical. 3rd, this was a game that went bad. Time to put it behind you. You are better than what you got this day. I would not work anymore games in this place and I would let the person know who assigned me why. Seek better places to work.

mick Sat Feb 24, 2007 08:47pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by tjones1
Yabut, what if they missed all their free throws, couldn't inbound the call and got a 5 second violation, and then hit a last second shot? :D :p

Didn't matter, Tanner.
On my floor they weren't shootin' anyway.:)

Terrapins Fan Sat Feb 24, 2007 10:27pm

My partner and I called a game a few years ago. under 30 seconds to go, Home team up by 8. Visitors are fouling intentionally to foul out of the game, we fouled 2 players out and after the 3rd player with 4 fouls fouled the home team, we call the game, they we making a travesty of the game.

truerookie Sat Feb 24, 2007 11:00pm

[QUOTE=DC_Ref12]
I've had enough, and I already have 3 technicals (1 on Team B's bench for B1 jawing, another on Team B's bench for the jerseys, and 1 on Team B's coach for his comments and being up in my face.)

Three technicals one direct two indirect. Coach ejected, no other adult on the sideline to finish the game. FORFEIT!! Is that about right?.

Teigan Sun Feb 25, 2007 12:53am

Quote:

Now coach goes nuclear
:D
I like that

GarthB Sun Feb 25, 2007 01:34am

In the local Mens "Wreck" League, three T's on the same team is an automatic forfeit.

Two nights ago, upon getting a foul called for blocking, a player grabbed the ball and slammed it against the wall near the scoreboard. My partner T'd him.

As he walked by me he turned to face me and said, "You guys are f@#king brutal." T number two. He has to leave the facility.

As he's leaving, another teammate walks towards me and says, "Why don't you a$$holes just give the game to those guys?"

I replied, "Didn't anyone ever tell you to be careful of what you ask for?" and presented him with a T....number three for the team, game over.

Back In The Saddle Sun Feb 25, 2007 12:57pm

Church leagues exist to provide fellowship, give lesser players a chance to play ball, encourage physical activity, teach sportsmanship and other life lessons. They are not the NBA finals (although many participants may not buy that). Often teams are coached by underqualified volunteers. If the game gets that out of control, and especially if the "adult leaders" get that out of control, the game has ceased to accomplish any of the purposes for which it was begun. Time to end it, without question.

Kelvin green Sun Feb 25, 2007 05:23pm

Unless I misread the post, putting time up on the clock benefitted Team B...otherwise game is over..

There is nothing wrong with calling the game...

When players and coaches decide they dont want to play, end the game. I have called several games (AAU, rec games, etc) over the past few years,

In one game that had some trouble, I asked the captain of the team if they wanted to continue playing because of the nonsense that was going on. When he said no, game was over...

Had a couple of others that thy started doing stupid things like described in the original post. When they dont want to play basketball the game is done...

Old School Sun Feb 25, 2007 08:08pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by GarthB
In the local Mens "Wreck" League, three T's on the same team is an automatic forfeit.

I love this guy, thanks for coming over from the baseball forum. You just said two things that I just love. One is WRECK LEAGUE!:D Now that's classic! From hence forward it will now be termed wreck league. #2.) 3 technicals on the same team at about the same time and the game is over. I love that too. Damn you're good!!! You've been there, I have nothing but respect and bow my head down to you!!!! BTW, can I use that 3 technicals and it's over?

Jurassic Referee Sun Feb 25, 2007 08:31pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Old School
I love this guy, thanks for coming over from the baseball forum. You just said two things that I just love. One is WRECK LEAGUE!:D Now that's classic! From hence forward it will now be termed wreck league. #2.) 3 technicals on the same team at about the same time and the game is over. I love that too. Damn you're good!!! You've been there, I have nothing but respect and bow my head down to you!!!! BTW, can I use that 3 technicals and it's over?

Garth, he's serious too....

It's true, it's true.....

I think that you have to adopt him now. It says so in the FAQ somewhere, I think.

GarthB Sun Feb 25, 2007 09:14pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Old School
BTW, can I use that 3 technicals and it's over?

You can if it's part of the written rules in your area as it is for the wreck leagues here.

GarthB Sun Feb 25, 2007 09:16pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jurassic Referee
Garth, he's serious too....

It's true, it's true.....

I think that you have to adopt him now. It says so in the FAQ somewhere, I think.

Okay, if I have to. I think I can find a job that he's capable of handling...doorstop, maybe.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:15pm.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1