The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Basketball (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/)
-   -   Goaltending, Basket Interference (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/2421-goaltending-basket-interference.html)

rainmaker Wed May 30, 2001 05:58pm

I haven't had to worry too much about Goaltending or Basket Interference (why am I capitalizing them!?) because, hey, let's face it, 6th grade girls don't get a lot of play above the rim! But I'll be doing some JV and Varsity boys this month in various circumstances and I suspect I'll need to know it at least once or twice. I don't need to feel 100% about every call, but I'd like to get the mechanics correct. Why is there no signal? How do I let everyone know what just happened, what the penalty is, and what happens next? What does happen next? Any help would be much appreciated...

Thanks!!

Mark Dexter Wed May 30, 2001 06:22pm

While there is no mechanic for GT or BI, you can probably use other mechanics to say what you need to say.

The most obvious are the count-the-basket (or 3-pt), and the don't-count-the-basket signals. If it's a situation where no points are awarded or cancelled, and people seem confused, it is probably best to say what the call is - BI or GT.

AK ref SE Wed May 30, 2001 06:33pm

Best advice I received about goaltending is.... Look at the shooter....look at the basket...... if the defensive player is more than half way (closer) to the shooter than the basket it is NOT goaltending. I know this may be hard to judge at times, but at least its a start.

AK ref SE

mick Wed May 30, 2001 06:58pm

yup
 
Quote:

Originally posted by Mark Dexter
While there is no mechanic for GT or BI, you can probably use other mechanics to say what you need to say.

The most obvious are the count-the-basket (or 3-pt), and the don't-count-the-basket signals. If it's a situation where no points are awarded or cancelled, and people seem confused, it is probably best to say what the call is - BI or GT.

Got yer Fox yet? :)
mick

Mark Dexter Wed May 30, 2001 08:44pm

Re: yup
 
Quote:

Originally posted by mick
Got yer Fox yet? :)
mick

Actually, I do finally. I bought one a few weeks ago to have it ready for when I help officiate at my school's field day this week. (No way was I going to use a flimsy plastic-pea whistle!)

BTW, what should a Fox-40 sound like to the user? Whenever I try to blow the whistle, it sounds very squeaky and weak. Is this right, or am I doing something wrong?

Mark Dexter Wed May 30, 2001 08:46pm

Exception to this rule . . .
 
Quote:

Originally posted by AK ref SE
Best advice I received about goaltending is.... Look at the shooter....look at the basket...... if the defensive player is more than half way (closer) to the shooter than the basket it is NOT goaltending. I know this may be hard to judge at times, but at least its a start.

AK ref SE

If the shooter is taller than the rim, this won't work. :)

BTW, the corollary is not necessarily true - the defender can be closer than halfway and still not have goaltending.

mick Wed May 30, 2001 08:59pm

Attaboy!
 
Quote:

Originally posted by Mark Dexter
Quote:

Originally posted by mick
Got yer Fox yet? :)
mick

Actually, I do finally. I bought one a few weeks ago to have it ready for when I help officiate at my school's field day this week. (No way was I going to use a flimsy plastic-pea whistle!)

BTW, what should a Fox-40 sound like to the user? Whenever I try to blow the whistle, it sounds very squeaky and weak. Is this right, or am I doing something wrong?

Okay, then pick your "favorite" Schoolmate to go to the other end of the gym with your whistle. Sounds good, yo?
Heck, I'm left-handed and I can make 'em work.
You have fun !!! :)

mick


Dan_ref Wed May 30, 2001 09:02pm

Quote:

Originally posted by rainmaker
I haven't had to worry too much about Goaltending or Basket Interference (why am I capitalizing them!?) because, hey, let's face it, 6th grade girls don't get a lot of play above the rim! But I'll be doing some JV and Varsity boys this month in various circumstances and I suspect I'll need to know it at least once or twice. I don't need to feel 100% about every call, but I'd like to get the mechanics correct. Why is there no signal? How do I let everyone know what just happened, what the penalty is, and what happens next? What does happen next? Any help would be much appreciated...

Thanks!!

If you're counting it (defensive) then give a strong
basket counts signal, followed by the 3 point signal
if needed. If you're not counting it (offensive) then give
a strong no basket signal. If there's a shot clock give
the shot clock reset signal. Finally, and this is important, know the difference between BI & GT. If you get
into a discussion with the coach you certainly don't want to
tell him BI when you actually have GT. That's about it.

Other advice: watch the pregame
warmups, you'll quickly see who's going above the rim & who
ain't. Also at the JV level many dunks are blown. Be
patient, it may look ugly but the kid can blow a dunk
without BI. If you see an alley-oop coming, make sure
the ball is not caught above the cylinder (BI). And
finally (this time I mean it), don't forget GT needs to
be a on a tap or try, BI does not, which means (among other
things) that you can have BI on a throw-in but *not* GT.
Have fun, let us know how it goes.

Dan_ref Wed May 30, 2001 09:06pm

Re: Re: yup
 
Quote:

Originally posted by Mark Dexter
Quote:

Originally posted by mick
Got yer Fox yet? :)
mick


BTW, what should a Fox-40 sound like to the user? Whenever I try to blow the whistle, it sounds very squeaky and weak. Is this right, or am I doing something wrong?

Get some air into that thing!

BktBallRef Wed May 30, 2001 10:08pm

Quote:

Originally posted by Dan_ref

If there's a shot clock give the shot clock reset signal.

A little help please, Dan.

Juulie, for heavens sake, don't don't "swirl the toilet." you know, one hand cupped like a basket, the other hand stirred the bowl! :D


Dexter, blow harder! :D

Dan_ref Thu May 31, 2001 09:40am

Quote:

Originally posted by BktBallRef
Quote:

Originally posted by Dan_ref

If there's a shot clock give the shot clock reset signal.

A little help please, Dan.

While I'm looking at the table telling them to count it I'll
remind them to reset the shot clock. It's just what I like
to do, it prevents confusion. And no, it's *not* the "flush
the toilet" motion :).

BTW, Juulie, I just thought of something else to keep in
mind. 99% of these calls are made by the T (or C in 3
person). You shouldn't see it as lead, but if you do give
your partner a chance. Although in last night's 76'ers game
the lead did call a GT late in the game, so what do I know!


BktBallRef Thu May 31, 2001 12:47pm

Quote:

Originally posted by Dan_ref

BTW, Juulie, I just thought of something else to keep in
mind. 99% of these calls are made by the T (or C in 3
person). You shouldn't see it as lead, but if you do give
your partner a chance. Although in last night's 76'ers game
the lead did call a GT late in the game, so what do I know!

It has become acceptable in college and the pros for the lead to call GT. But it's still the T or C's call in high school.

BTW, good call by Bennett Slavatore. He had the perfect angle to make the call.

Dan_ref Thu May 31, 2001 01:43pm

Quote:

Originally posted by BktBallRef


BTW, good call by Bennett Slavatore. He had the perfect angle to make the call.

Yes, it was a great call.

BTW, can you believe the way the Bucks gave that game to
Philly? That dope Cassell fouls an ice cold Iverson on a
3 pointer and then talks his way into a T? Two flagrants
in the 4th qtr? These guys are having a really tough time
handling the pressure. But it's all good, I'm looking
forward to an LA-Philly finals.

mick Thu May 31, 2001 01:54pm

I wouldn't hold my breath.
 
[QUOTE]Originally posted by Dan_ref
Quote:

I'm looking forward to an LA-Philly finals.
Sparky,
I think maybe an L.A.-L.A. final is probable. :(
mick


rockyroad Thu May 31, 2001 02:04pm

I thought the best thing about that GT call by Salvatore was the communication between himself and the C at the time (I think it was Ronnie Nunn)...Salvatore and Nunn had double whistles and Salvatore came off the baseline pointing at Nunn - they both called out to each other and then Salvatore gave the GT/count the basket signal...it was a great example of communication w/partner...and as far as the Finals goes, does it really matter whether Philly or Mil. wins the East - neith one of them has a chance with the way the Lakers are playing...

Dan_ref Thu May 31, 2001 02:31pm

Mick, rockyroad,

I heard that Barkley & Dr J will be suiting up for the
finals so there's nothing to worry about...now all we gotta
do is figure out how to take 20 yrs off of each of them! ;)
...OK, maybe 30 yrs for Julius...

BktBallRef Thu May 31, 2001 05:45pm

Quote:

Originally posted by Dan_ref
BTW, can you believe the way the Bucks gave that game to
Philly? That dope Cassell fouls an ice cold Iverson on a
3 pointer and then talks his way into a T? Two flagrants
in the 4th qtr? These guys are having a really tough time
handling the pressure.

With the mouth that Cassell has on him, I can't believe it ttok as long as it did for him to get popped. But the comments that Salvatore made to Ray Allen were interesing. He said "I gave him enough rope." Cassell took care of the rest! :)

I'm with mick. I think LA will become the first team to ever go through the playoffs undefeated.

mick Thu May 31, 2001 07:30pm

Quote:

Originally posted by BktBallRef
Quote:

Originally posted by Dan_ref
BTW, can you believe the way the Bucks gave that game to
Philly? That dope Cassell fouls an ice cold Iverson on a
3 pointer and then talks his way into a T? Two flagrants
in the 4th qtr? These guys are having a really tough time
handling the pressure.

With the mouth that Cassell has on him, I can't believe it ttok as long as it did for him to get popped. But the comments that Salvatore made to Ray Allen were interesing. He said "I gave him enough rope." Cassell took care of the rest! :)

I'm with mick. I think LA will become the first team to ever go through the playoffs undefeated.

They are wonderful. It'll be "Showtime" again.

Dan_ref Thu May 31, 2001 09:06pm

[QUOTE]Originally posted by mick
Quote:


They are wonderful. It'll be "Showtime" again.
Hmmm, not quite sure I can say that Shaq + Kobe =
Kareem + Magic, but man they are good. Maybe they
will sweep their next 4, I just wanted to see how Iverson
does against them (I'm not so optimistic given his
performance so far vs the Bucks).

Mark Dexter Fri Jun 01, 2001 04:06pm

Personal Experience
 
I had two BI calls today. First I hit the whistle and gave the "basket counts" foul-type signal. Second I hit the whistle and then gave the three-point signal.

Of course, both times that I called it, the ball was 90% through (and went all the way), so people just gave me a funny look like "what was that?"

mick Fri Jun 01, 2001 04:15pm

Re: Personal Experience
 
Quote:

Originally posted by Mark Dexter
I had two BI calls today. First I hit the whistle and gave the "basket counts" foul-type signal. Second I hit the whistle and then gave the three-point signal.

Of course, both times that I called it, the ball was 90% through (and went all the way), so people just gave me a funny look like "what was that?"

Mark,
Offensive?
Defensive?
mick

BktBallRef Fri Jun 01, 2001 04:30pm

Re: Re: Personal Experience
 
Quote:

Originally posted by mick

Mark,
Offensive?
Defensive?
mick

Hmmm. I'm betting it was on the defense. :)

Mark Dexter Fri Jun 01, 2001 10:42pm

Defensive (I hope I got the shirt colors right). Both were those brush-the-net-as-the-ball-drops-through type.

If it were offensive, the players would have probably outright attacked me.

rainmaker Fri Jun 01, 2001 11:51pm

Quote:

Originally posted by Mark Dexter
Defensive (I hope I got the shirt colors right). Both were those brush-the-net-as-the-ball-drops-through type.

How tight do you more experineced folks call this? I've tended to let it go in the past, if it's just a brush as the ball slides through. Should I be cracking down a little?

BktBallRef Sat Jun 02, 2001 12:26am

Mark, I hope both calls were against the defense if you counted the baskets! :)

Juulie, if the ball is in tha basket and goes through, then let it go. Obviously you want a whistle if the ball doesn't go through the basket. But if the ball is going through the net uninterrupted, don't interrupt the game by making the call.

Good advice for you too, Mark.

mick Sat Jun 02, 2001 06:52am

How often?
 
Quote:

Originally posted by rainmaker
How tight do you more experineced folks call this? I've tended to let it go in the past, if it's just a brush as the ball slides through. Should I be cracking down a little?
Jewel,
I called my only BI a couple years ago.
I saw the rim twitch from Trail.
mick

BktBallRef Sat Jun 02, 2001 09:27am

Re: How often?
 
Quote:

Originally posted by mick

Jewel,
I called my only BI a couple years ago.
I saw the rim twitch from Trail.
mick

AT&T or MCI mick? :)

mick Sat Jun 02, 2001 12:37pm

Nice Catch, Tony
 
Quote:

Originally posted by BktBallRef
Quote:

Originally posted by mick

Jewel,
I called my only BI a couple years ago.
I saw the rim twitch from Trail.
mick

AT&T or MCI mick? :)

Tony,
It was probably from C.
I know it was table side, though, maybe.... :confused:
Of course, I was nicely closed down on the shot ;)
mick

Mark Dexter Sat Jun 02, 2001 09:29pm

What about . . .
 
Quote:

Originally posted by BktBallRef
Mark, I hope both calls were against the defense if you counted the baskets! :)

Juulie, if the ball is in tha basket and goes through, then let it go. Obviously you want a whistle if the ball doesn't go through the basket. But if the ball is going through the net uninterrupted, don't interrupt the game by making the call.

Good advice for you too, Mark.

Yes, they were both on the defense.

I agree that this call should usually be passed (because the points are awarded either way.) However, something I discussed a few seasons back was end of period/game, where the whistle causes the clock to stop and lets subs in. What would you do (defensive BI, but good anyways) if:
(a) Stopping the clock benefited the defense
(a)(i) The defense purposely BI'd to stop the clock
(b) Stopping the clock benefited the offense
(c) It benefited both teams

BktBallRef Sat Jun 02, 2001 10:53pm

Re: What about . . .
 
Quote:

Originally posted by Mark Dexter
Yes, they were both on the defense.

I agree that this call should usually be passed (because the points are awarded either way.) However, something I discussed a few seasons back was end of period/game, where the whistle causes the clock to stop and lets subs in. What would you do (defensive BI, but good anyways) if:
(a) Stopping the clock benefited the defense
(a)(i) The defense purposely BI'd to stop the clock
(b) Stopping the clock benefited the offense
(c) It benefited both teams

I would pass on the whistle and let play continue.

BktBallRef Sat Jun 02, 2001 10:55pm

Re: Nice Catch, Tony
 
Quote:

AT&T or MCI mick? :) [/B]
Quote:

Originally posted by mick


Tony,
It was probably from C.
I know it was table side, though, maybe.... :confused:
Of course, I was nicely closed down on the shot ;)
mick

AT&T or MCI means that it sounded like a long distance call!
:)

Dan_ref Sun Jun 03, 2001 06:49pm

Re: What about . . .
 
Quote:

Originally posted by Mark Dexter
Quote:

Originally posted by BktBallRef
Mark, I hope both calls were against the defense if you counted the baskets! :)

Juulie, if the ball is in tha basket and goes through, then let it go. Obviously you want a whistle if the ball doesn't go through the basket. But if the ball is going through the net uninterrupted, don't interrupt the game by making the call.

Good advice for you too, Mark.

Yes, they were both on the defense.

I agree that this call should usually be passed (because the points are awarded either way.) However, something I discussed a few seasons back was end of period/game, where the whistle causes the clock to stop and lets subs in. What would you do (defensive BI, but good anyways) if:
(a) Stopping the clock benefited the defense
(a)(i) The defense purposely BI'd to stop the clock
(b) Stopping the clock benefited the offense
(c) It benefited both teams

Oh man, you are thinking too much! :) Player touches the net
as the ball goes thru, let it go. You have enough to worry
about already.

rainmaker Mon Jun 04, 2001 07:50am

I'm glad I asked this question because this weekend I needed it. I blew the call, but I learned something I would have missed if I hadn't been thinking about it. It was JV boys, too, if you can imagine. The shot went up, missed, and while it was still balancing on the rim a defender went up and tipped himself the rebound. I thought "Wait a minute... was that... " and then of course, the play was off down the court, and I could have called it back, but just brain-froze (NOT my only mistake all weekend!!) But I stashed that little picture away in my mind, and looked at it again on the next time out. It was definitely BI. So now I've learned something, which I can carry forward into my next "big" games which are tonight. Big means big for me, not that I'm so high up on the ladder.

dhodges007 Mon Jun 04, 2001 11:20am

Quote:

Originally posted by AK ref SE
Best advice I received about goaltending is.... Look at the shooter....look at the basket...... if the defensive player is more than half way (closer) to the shooter than the basket it is NOT goaltending. I know this may be hard to judge at times, but at least its a start.

AK ref SE

Good advice...Thanks!!


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:18pm.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1