Quote:
Originally posted by ChuckElias
Quote:
Originally posted by Jurassic Referee
We did have some great discussions on this play here years ago. It's an immediate violation as per that case book play- 9.2.2SitC- as soon as the throwing team takes the ball up court without going OOB.
|
Yeah, that was some debate, all right. I seem to remember that almost everybody thought you either continued your 5-second count or else you had a do-over. If memory serves, there were only 2 people on this whole forum who realized that it was really an immediate violation. Now. . . who were they? It's so long ago now, I can't really recall. . . Was it JR? No, I'm pretty sure it wasn't. . . Dan? No, not him. . . Must've been Tony, then. Wait a minute, no. It was wasn't Tony. . .
Jeez, I'm really stumped. Maybe one of you guys remembers. Anybody? 
|
I remember.
Nobody had it right because there wasn't a definitive answer under the rules until the FED issued one. We were all guessing.
Iow, guessing right is a helluva lot different than being right.
Sun Oct 30, 2005, 09:20am
Threaded Mode
