Exhumed Question from the Dead File

[M&M Guy]

Originally posted by ChuckElias

You know, this isn't a bad solution. I might just administer the FT so that he catches it outside the semi-circle.

I could see doing something like this could, in rare instances, work out. But in this example, where a hard-headed ref is having A shoot 1-and-1 when they should get the ball OOB, your fix of the violation would give the ball to B, and A completely loses a posession. So, maybe in this case two wrongs really don't make a right?