The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Basketball (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/)
-   -   HEY, COACH!!! (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/18319-hey-coach.html)

rainmaker Wed Feb 09, 2005 01:28am

I'm only gonna say this once so, LISTEN UP!! As long as you blame the refs, your players aren't going to get better. It's very simple really. When the players think they don't need to work on their skills, their plays, their teamwork, their attitudes, they don't work on their skills, etc. So when you're yelling at me, you're letting them off the hook. See? Get it? Besides, I've got plenty of others coaching me. I DON"T NEED YOU TO HELP!!

Thanks for listening. I feel better now that I"ve got that off my chest...

Adam Wed Feb 09, 2005 01:30am

This moment of catharsis brought to you by: All of us at Officials Anonymous.

rainmaker Wed Feb 09, 2005 01:34am

Quote:

Originally posted by Snaqwells
This moment of catharsis brought to you by: All of us at Officials Anonymous.
plop, plop, fizz, fizz.... (even if no one else gets this, dinosaurs such as Clark, Jurassic, and Tim will!)

Adam Wed Feb 09, 2005 01:41am

Do you have to relieve yourself in front of everyone? :D

TimTaylor Wed Feb 09, 2005 02:37am

Quote:

Originally posted by rainmaker
Quote:

Originally posted by Snaqwells
This moment of catharsis brought to you by: All of us at Officials Anonymous.
plop, plop, fizz, fizz.... (even if no one else gets this, dinosaurs such as Clark, Jurassic, and Tim will!)

Boy do I remember those commercials......

You must have had a "fun" game tonight. I had a PIL boys double-header. There were a couple interesting moments, but overall both games were great. This must be my "PIL" week - Grant tonight, Benson tomorrow & Jeff on Thurs.

JugglingReferee Wed Feb 09, 2005 04:15am

Quote:

Originally posted by rainmaker
Quote:

Originally posted by Snaqwells
This moment of catharsis brought to you by: All of us at Officials Anonymous.
plop, plop, fizz, fizz.... (even if no one else gets this, dinosaurs such as Clark, Jurassic, and Tim will!)

Oh, what a relief it is.

Yes, I've seen the "remember this" shows on A&E. :)

ChrisSportsFan Wed Feb 09, 2005 08:32am

It drives me bonkers when you call a foul and the coach is telling his player "good job, that was good defense". How does that kid learn to move his feet if the coach is encouraging him for bad defense?

Adam Wed Feb 09, 2005 08:55am

He won't learn. :(

Damian Wed Feb 09, 2005 09:34am

I had a coach tell me once...
 
Sometimes when you call a block on a kid, he may know that the ref is correct, but wants to encourage the kid to keep trying, so he will say, "good job, that was good defense" or something like that. He told me, that is not a slight at the refs at all. But, doesn't want his kids to stop trying by yelling at them that they didn't do it right.

rainmaker Wed Feb 09, 2005 09:53am

Re: I had a coach tell me once...
 
Quote:

Originally posted by Damian
Sometimes when you call a block on a kid, he may know that the ref is correct, but wants to encourage the kid to keep trying, so he will say, "good job, that was good defense" or something like that. He told me, that is not a slight at the refs at all. But, doesn't want his kids to stop trying by yelling at them that they didn't do it right.
It's easy to tell by the tone of voice which way they mean it!

DownTownTonyBrown Wed Feb 09, 2005 10:01am

Alka your noggin
 
I can't believe you ate the whole thing!:D

rainmaker Wed Feb 09, 2005 10:04am

Re: Alka your noggin
 
Quote:

Originally posted by DownTownTonyBrown
I can't believe you ate the whole thing!:D
Oh, wow, you're a dinosaur, too! Welcome to the club.

ditttoo Wed Feb 09, 2005 01:41pm

It's possible we hear too much. Coaching a kid for "good defense" when he's just been whistled for a foul is not automatically a dig at the refs. As mentioned, coaches use the "encouragement" to motivate a kid to continue to keep trying and also at times to keep a kid from "blaming the refs". Regardless, trust the coach to "coach" and trust you and your partner to "call the game".

Absolutely there are "bad" coaches and there are "good" coaches, but there are also misunderstood coaches as well. Try not to get too involved in figuring out which coach is which - time will tell, just as it does with officiating. Good coaches (and officials) are not made or broken in a single night or by a single call.

stripes Wed Feb 09, 2005 03:08pm

I've told kids (after the good defense comment) that they can play good defense like that 4 more times tonight and then they have to sit on the bench. They usually get the picture.

tjones1 Wed Feb 09, 2005 03:25pm

Quote:

Originally posted by rainmaker
I'm only gonna say this once so, LISTEN UP!! As long as you blame the refs, your players aren't going to get better. It's very simple really. When the players think they don't need to work on their skills, their plays, their teamwork, their attitudes, they don't work on their skills, etc. So when you're yelling at me, you're letting them off the hook. See? Get it? Besides, I've got plenty of others coaching me. I DON"T NEED YOU TO HELP!!

Thanks for listening. I feel better now that I"ve got that off my chest...

What rainmaker said!!!

w_sohl Wed Feb 09, 2005 03:30pm

Quote:

Originally posted by rainmaker
Quote:

Originally posted by Snaqwells
This moment of catharsis brought to you by: All of us at Officials Anonymous.
plop, plop, fizz, fizz.... (even if no one else gets this, dinosaurs such as Clark, Jurassic, and Tim will!)

Oh what a relief it is....

Alkaseltzer...

and I'm only 30

lrpalmer3 Wed Feb 09, 2005 04:18pm

Re: Re: I had a coach tell me once...
 
Quote:

Originally posted by rainmaker

It's easy to tell by the tone of voice which way they mean it!

Slippery slope. I haven't had a more frustrating conversation than the one with my woman when she says, "..., it's the way you said it."

coachgbert Wed Feb 09, 2005 04:27pm

As a coach of 3-8th grade girls sometimes giving girls defensive instructions will have them back off defense completely and become timid. They'll be afraid to make mistakes because you might be "mad" at them. Girls also get sloppy when they get aggressive, forgetting everything they've been taught in the heat of the moment.

My 6th grade girls played in a tournament last weekend. The other team had 3 coaches and they yelled and screamed constantly. We won but his girls had 16 fouls in the first half to my team's 2. The coach screamed "call it both ways" so many times I thought I would scream. At the end we were up by 12 and I told the girls to run the clock and pass around. He screamed for them to foul my point. Foul they did, by knocking her to the ground.

It got uglier at the end with the coach screaming at the refs, me and facility management. Finally, one of the refs told him if he taught his girls to play the game then they might win. As might be imagined that didn't go over well. It almost caused a riot with the parents of his team wanting to fight. The other team's asst. coach told me that was the worst reffed game he'd ever had and asked why I wasn't more upset because he thought we were "cheated" out of calls too. I told him first it didn't seem to me to be unfairly reffed. I'd had these refs for several years and they've always called what mattered, not every bump, slap or little push. Second, no one will remember this game in a year, EXCEPT now the girls will forever remember that their coach wigged out over a game; and third my motto is that the refs ref, the coaches coach and that the parents of my team cheer. That's what we all sign as a code of conduct at the beginning of the season. Of course he disagreed because it was a "tournament" game.

We'll see what happens. I was supposed to feel guilty because I wasn't on board with the other coaches. I've learned a lot here, that's why I lurk.

Coach G.

TimTaylor Wed Feb 09, 2005 05:34pm

Coach G.,

Just curious....did the officials call an intentional foul when your point guard was knocked to the ground at the behest of their coach?

I wasn't there, so can only go by your description, but based on what you described I probably would have sent the opposing coach to the parking lot before it escalated. Others may disagree, but personally I tend to put up with a lot less misbehavior from GS/MS coaches.

williebfree Wed Feb 09, 2005 05:52pm

Quote:

Originally posted by coachgbert
... I told him first it didn't seem to me to be unfairly reffed. I'd had these refs for several years and they've always called what mattered, not every bump, slap or little push. Second, no one will remember this game in a year, EXCEPT now the girls will forever remember that their coach wigged out over a game; and third my motto is that the refs ref, the coaches coach and that the parents of my team cheer. That's what we all sign as a code of conduct at the beginning of the season. Of course he disagreed because it was a "tournament" game.

We'll see what happens. I was supposed to feel guilty because I wasn't on board with the other coaches. I've learned a lot here, that's why I lurk.

Coach G.

Superb Job Coach....

I appreciate when I have coaches like you on the bench. Keep up the great work! Continue to be a positive example for our kids!

canuckrefguy Wed Feb 09, 2005 06:01pm

Quote:

Originally posted by rainmaker
I'm only gonna say this once so, LISTEN UP!! As long as you blame the refs, your players aren't going to get better. It's very simple really. When the players think they don't need to work on their skills, their plays, their teamwork, their attitudes, they don't work on their skills, etc. So when you're yelling at me, you're letting them off the hook. See? Get it? Besides, I've got plenty of others coaching me. I DON"T NEED YOU TO HELP!!

Thanks for listening. I feel better now that I"ve got that off my chest...

WOW.....I don't think there are enough shoes available for all that puke ! ! ! ! :D

canuckrefguy Wed Feb 09, 2005 06:06pm

Re: I had a coach tell me once...
 
Quote:

Originally posted by Damian
Sometimes when you call a block on a kid, he may know that the ref is correct, but wants to encourage the kid to keep trying, so he will say, "good job, that was good defense" or something like that. He told me, that is not a slight at the refs at all. But, doesn't want his kids to stop trying by yelling at them that they didn't do it right.
Sorry, but I call bull****. ;)

Plenty of other ways to get that message across without directly (and loudly) contradicting my call. 999/1000 times the coach is saying "the ref blew it", not "nice effort, keep trying".

JugglingReferee Wed Feb 09, 2005 06:20pm

Quote:

Originally posted by stripes
I've told kids (after the good defense comment) that they can play good defense like that 4 more times tonight and then they have to sit on the bench. They usually get the picture.
Nice! I might use that.

rainmaker Wed Feb 09, 2005 06:53pm

Re: Re: I had a coach tell me once...
 
Quote:

Originally posted by canuckrefguy
Quote:

Originally posted by Damian
Sometimes when you call a block on a kid, he may know that the ref is correct, but wants to encourage the kid to keep trying, so he will say, "good job, that was good defense" or something like that. He told me, that is not a slight at the refs at all. But, doesn't want his kids to stop trying by yelling at them that they didn't do it right.
Sorry, but I call bull****. ;)

Plenty of other ways to get that message across without directly (and loudly) contradicting my call. 999/1000 times the coach is saying "the ref blew it", not "nice effort, keep trying".

I suppose it depends on what kind of games you're doing what the percentages are. I'd say of the times I hear this it's more like 900 out of 1000 are showing up the ref. But there are those other 100. Sometimes, I'll even say to a kid who looks discouraged, (I sidle over to them while everyone is lining up for free throws), "Hey, that was a good try. Next time get there a little sooner." Or, "You almost had it. Keep trying." Or, "Great foul, you stopped the ball." Fouling is part of the game, and can be okay. If a ref says that to a player, it takes out a little of the anti-ref attitude.

coachgbert Wed Feb 09, 2005 07:47pm

Quote:

Originally posted by TimTaylor
Coach G.,

Just curious....did the officials call an intentional foul when your point guard was knocked to the ground at the behest of their coach?

I wasn't there, so can only go by your description, but based on what you described I probably would have sent the opposing coach to the parking lot before it escalated. Others may disagree, but personally I tend to put up with a lot less misbehavior from GS/MS coaches.

No, he didn't call an intentional, but the ref did tell him that he got away with it this time, next game he wouldn't be so lucky. The ref told him about a half dozen times to stop, but he just kept screaming, foul her, foul her. I didn't think they would tackle her! The girls got as overexcited as their coach. The facility called me tonight to tell me that they informed the coach he could finish the tournament, but that he wouldn't be welcome back for any other leagues or tournaments in the future. The kids are the ones who suffer in the end.

Coach G

Mark Padgett Wed Feb 09, 2005 08:21pm

Quote:

Originally posted by coachgbert
The other team's asst. coach told me that was the worst reffed game he'd ever had...

You realize that a coach that says this most likely says it after every game. That should tell you something right there.

canuckrefguy Wed Feb 09, 2005 09:50pm

Re: Re: Re: I had a coach tell me once...
 
Quote:

Originally posted by rainmaker
Sometimes, I'll even say to a kid who looks discouraged, (I sidle over to them while everyone is lining up for free throws), "Hey, that was a good try. Next time get there a little sooner." Or, "You almost had it. Keep trying." Or, "Great foul, you stopped the ball." Fouling is part of the game, and can be okay. If a ref says that to a player, it takes out a little of the anti-ref attitude.
I agree - I do that sometimes, too. Even when a player is protesting, wondering what they did, I find a good, quick, low-key explanation while we're on the lane works just about every time.

I do think you're being a bit generous with the 900/1000 thing ;) - I'd maybe agree on 975/1000, but that's as low as I'll go :D


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:03am.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1