![]() |
The local AD assigned me to a junior high school game last week with a local college kid as my partner. (The son of one of the local teachers.)
I'm standing on the court when my partner shows up 5 minutes before game time and walks across the court towards me. I could not believe my eyes! He had on white sneakers, grey sweat pants, a zebra shirt with a turtle neck shirt, an outsized wristwatch, a sea shell necklace, three "cancer bracelets" and a circular earring in his ear. (I had just finshed telling one girl to take a hard barrette out of her hair.) He had played on the local high school team two years ago that won a state title so he has seem plenty of basketball officials. I told him that he had to take it all off before he could ref with me. His response was: "Your kidding me right!" He decided that he would only take off the wrist watch and said again: "Your kidding me right!". I went back into the locker room and tried calling the AD on my cell but she had already left for the day. I went back out on the court and told him one of us was not going to ref the game and seeing as I was the patched official he should go home and that I would work the game solo. At which point he left and I did the game by myself. The next day I called the local AD and told her what had happened. My partner (and his mother) had alread met with the AD. The AD proceeded to tell me that I did not have the authority to send him off the floor; and besides: "he needed the money for college and had always wanted to be a ref". I offered to sit with him and point him in the right direction but she said that she would have a talk with him before he does another game. She also said that she has me working with him again next week. Every other game I have ever done for her I have worked with another patched official. The AD gives me about 15 games a year, which I enjoy doing because both the middle school and high schools are only a mile from my home. My regular assigner would typically be sending me an hour out of town for the same money. What should I do? Let it go and run the risk of another pre-game confrontation with this kid or take a stand and refuse to work with him and run risk of losing 15 games next season? |
Quote:
If we did not have that rule, I would work the game in accordance with my agreement. mick |
I wonder if the insurance company that provides catastrophic onsurance coverage for the school knows that she is using unpatched officials for her games.
|
Sounds to me that your assignor needs to get it together! Too bad you were put in that position to have to tell the "newbie" how to grow up. If this person really wants to be an official, he should get started the correct way....first, check the attitude...then conform with appropriate attire.
In Wisconsin, games at the middle school/junior high up to high school freshmen, JV and Varsity all require a minimum of two "registered" officials before the game can even begin! Sounds to me this is an issue that needs to be addressed. Aren't there insurance liabilities caused by assigning "non-patched" people to work these games? Lots of other issues here too! Good luck....you did right in my book! wl |
Around here, junior high schools who are members of the IESA only require one patched official. But they always hire two. They just do that as a last minute thing or if an official would happen to get hurt on the court...something of that nature.
|
NOT THE OLD MR. T STARTER KIT
I see officials with rope chains..rings on damn near all there fingers..and once with an ear ring....Some officials just don't care about there appearance...Just the check!
|
Re: NOT THE OLD MR. T STARTER KIT
Quote:
|
If it were me, I'd tell the AD that if he shows up not in proper uniform next game, he'll be working it alone. I understand it's a fun and convenient place to work, but you have to consider that if this is the way they're running their program, do you want to be affiliated with it?
|
Quote:
Also, with regard to the kid, obviously nobody told him what to do, so maybe you could have been a little less confrontational (of course I wasn't there). Explain to him how officials should dress and why they shouldn't wear jewelery (the fact that you told a player to take some off is reason enough for consistency), and offer to help out. I don't know what type of attitude the kid had, but you could have been more positive with him and established yourself as sort of a mentor to him rather than acting standoffish and alienating him. I doubt he'll show up the same way next week, do the game and try to mend fences. If he truly wants to be an official, he'll make the effort to improve. |
Seems to me that Padgett's standard response is very appropriate here. TO the partner who won't take off jewelry, "My insurance won't cover the liability suit if a player gets hurt, so I won't work the game if you have that stuff on." Then go home and call insurance people. Get final ruling, and then call AD and say, "I won't work with that stuff on the floor if he shows up with it again, because of insurance. And if this is how you want your games run, I won't work any more of them at all."
Period. |
I went to a Pac-10 men's game last night (Oregon State at Washington) and one of the three officials had a gold chain on. Most of the time you couldn't see it, but sometimes it was visible and obvious because of the glare. Very tacky, IMHO.
Z |
1. bling bling
n. synonym for expensive, often flashy jewelry sported mostly by African American hip-hop artists and <U>middle class Caucasian adolescents</U>. mick :) |
middle school game. This sounds like a step up from around here.
|
I once had a partner with one of those big cubic zirconias in his ear. Lucky for him the assignor showed up half way through the game for a quick peek at the officiating. At half time, the official was instructed to remove the earring by the assignor and I don't think I've seen him ref again with it in.
BTW we are allowed to wear gold chains, but they are to be kept underneath our shirts. I personally don't wear anything like that off the court, so I'm not worried about having to take it off when I officiate. |
Liability?
What does having a "patch" has to do with liability of the school? Unless there is some organization that is setting some type of standards, not sure how liability is going to be greater by an unlicensed official that officiates a basketball game. I could see having a license might give the official more insurance from some liability, but not sure how this gives the school more liability? If that is the case than anyone that assigns an AAU game must have a licensed official at every game? So what if a college official is working a game. Are primary college officials not qualified to work AAU or Men's League games?
I guess I do not understand what having a license has to do with liability? Peace |
I would think that somewhere in the insurance policy it would refer to qualified or certified officials.
I know that my insurance doesn't cover me if I work with a "non-patched" official. Although, I've seen referees who haven't yet put their patch on their shirt, does that mean I'm not covered if I work with them???;) |
Quote:
Quote:
Peace |
Quote:
It was stated in the orginal post that the kid is unlicensed in his state. One needn't jump to conclusions if one has read the original post. I know in Iowa, at the middle school level, only one of the officials has to be licensed by the state. At the high school level, all officials need to be licensed. |
Quote:
Peace |
He said he was "unpatched," which in the cotext of the post indicates he is unlicensed. he didn't say how he knew, but he did say it. We're not making assumptions here, other than in the accuracy of his post (which is always the case when responding to various situations posted here.)
|
I'm not too concerned about personal liability insurance, per se'....just that I believe school districts could risk legal liability issues should there be injuries. I'm not an attorney, but with everyone looking to file legal action whenever something happens....I think the AD or assignor...or school district should get a legal opinion about the district's responsibility on risk management and personal injury liabilities.
Heck, if I get injured, my state association has insurance coverage on me which is part of the state registration fee. Your personal health insurance should cover what's left over. My point earlier in this thread was that the AD didn't seem to care much about who got hired, what type of risk the district could be put in....let alone any other liability issues that could be connected...etc., etc. Too many loose ends in this operation. Think I'd look to work games in a more organized situation! JMHO...:D wl |
Officials Snitching On There Partners To Athletic Directors!
I am not about to begin snitching on my partner to any Athletic Directors! If an official practices wearing jewelry to a game it is just a matter of time before he/she get's nailed!
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
Peace |
The way things work up here, every game is assigned by an assignor. In the locations I work, we have 2. One for high school games, one for everything else. These assignors only assign licensed officials. I know that if I'm working a game assigned by an assignor, that I'm going to have a licensed official as a partner.
|
Quote:
Peace |
I'm not exactly getting what you're trying to say.
But to explain, I believe it is written into the policy that we have to work with a certified official in order for coverage to apply. If we don't work with a certified official than I don't think we're covered in the case of an accident. Now I don't have the policy in front of me, but I believe that's what it states. |
Quote:
Peace |
As far as I know, I haven't worked with a partner who wasn't certified, and I don't ineted to do any games with one any time soon.
|
I feel bad :(Everyone talking about not working with un certified officials). I am not "certified", and cannot get "certified" untill I am 18, however, I can still call Jr.High games.
|
Quote:
Jeff -- Around here, both refs are liable for everything. Insurance covers the liability if both refs are working within the restrictions set by the insurance company. If not, neither ref is covered. So if I worked with this guy, and something happened, and we were sued, we'd both be liable, not just him. |
Quote:
|
In Texas, you have to be a memeber of TASO in order to call a game. Each Chapter's Assisgnor assigns the game. There is no way an AD could give a game to anybody off the street. That said, I have seen intermeral and rec league officials dressed like that but never an official in any interschool contest dressed this way.
|
pretty much when these kids sign up for rec ball their parents sign a waiver. does that not carry any weight? maybe this is something i should be but so far i have not really been concerned about being sued. should i change my thoughts on this?
rec, ms, hs, aau, aybt, mayb, ..... |
Un Certified Officials!
How will you know if a official is certified or not? Do you ask he/she to show you some proof during your pre-game conference?
|
Waivers generally mean nothing if a good lawyer is involved . . .
Now, I agree with JRut on this one - it shouldn't matter who your partner is, your insurance should cover you. However, whether successful or not, an injured player's lawyer is going to sue everyone involved in the game, and let the chips fall where they may. As such, he may try to show that the 'licensed' official is liable for working with an unlicensed official. |
I work with many different partners, especially when officiating younger-aged games. I cannot verify that all these partners are NFHS (state)-certified. I do not believe that it should be my responsibility. The schools, who are members of the state association (WIAA) are directed to only hire certified officials and must have two officials in order for the game to be played.
Yes, we do live in a very litigious society; however, I sincerely doubt a rationale-thinking group of people (Jury) or judge could find any certified official culpable of negligence for working with a non-certified partner, especially given the abovementioned state policies. Of course, I am aware of some nearly unbelieveable court settlements. Anyone for some HOT coffee? :rolleyes: |
1) If they have a state patch on their shirt or not.
2) When you get you schedule and you see who you partener is, you can look on this piece of paper and it will tell you if this official is certified or not. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
I don't know how we got off the "bling" subject, but my two cents is that I wear no jewelry, including my wedding band. If we ask the players to forego it, I will too. That's just a left-over from a league that I was lucky enough to work a few years ago that stressed no jewelry for anybody.
|
Does a watch count? I wear my watch, but that's it. As far as accessories go, that is.
|
Why would you wear a watch on the court? Worried about how long the game is taking? :confused: A watch is a major no-no.
|
I wear my wedding ring, but only because it is a major pain to take off. I haven't heard any problems with it, but it's also relatively subdued.
A watch is just a target for a coach. No need for it, the only clock that matters on the court moves backwards and doesn't sync with your watch. Leave it in the locker room. |
Quote:
Peace |
Answer is obvious
The answer about liability/responsibility is rather simple. Isn't it?
The officials are responsible for conduct of the game. And, you don't become an official by acquiring a game assignment. You become an official for high school athletics by taking and passing the NFHS Part II test. A college freshman/sophmore blinged out and wearing sweats is likely not certified. A derelict off the street is likely not certified either. So for my mind it is not a far stretch to say that if I work with someone that is not certified, I am the only one that is responsible, and therefore liable, for the conduct of the game. I am now responsible for the derelict's (or other future society dropout's) method of conducting the game - his calls, his lack of calls, the collisions that happen in his primary area, the fights that will ensue... All my responsibility/liability. There is no way I would work a high school varsity match with such a derelict. Perhaps a Junior high or lesser but I don't think I would work even a JV match that I didn't know the other official had taken the NFHS test (perhaps not passed but at least taken). Sweats maybe for the lower levels. Jewelry - NO WAY. You want to work? You come properly prepared, in the correct uniform, and at a proper time. If you don't know the correct answer for those three items, then you don't belong here. I can help you later, and I would be happy to help you, but right now I've got to work this game and I'm working it alone. |
Quote:
|
Re: Answer is obvious
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Peace |
Dork partner
Quote:
and if you showed up looking like that I wouldn't work with you either. That may be alright for YMCA games where the kids aren't even in uniforms - in which case I might be in shorts also. But it is inappropriate for an organized contest. Certification is surely different for different locations. I'm glad you can pass the Part I test and that you don't have a criminal background. Show up at one of my games in sweats and bling 5 minutes for game time and prove it to me. I think you are sorely mistaken about liability and I hope that you never find out that you really are. I'm not a lawyer but for me it is extremely simple to follow the line of responsibility and say that one of the officials is trained and certified, and that particular official allowed someone else who is not trained, and who is not certified to officiate. Therefore, the trained official is ultimately responsible. I think even the simplest of lawyers would also say the assigner has some responsibility for making the assignment. For you to say that you could pick anyone out of the stands and say "Yeah, come on down and officiate with me. Here's a whistle. I hope your home owner's insurance is good because I'm not covering your butt and your bad calls. You're on your own. When the situations get thick, you're still on your own." And those statements, or that situation, and you would be beyond responsibility for the overall contest is ridiculous. Nothing you can say, will absolve you of your responsibility. Ooh and Jeff, I always get a really jolly laugh out of your confrontational posts and that you sign off with "Peace." Yeah same to you. Good luck. You're on your own. |
Quote:
[/B][/QUOTE]We have to list all of our officials with our insurance carrier. There is a specific coda in our policy stating that our coverage for any official working with a non-insured or non-certified official is void. Iow, if I work with an uninsured official, my insurance is void. Our policy specifically says that. Policies are different, Jeff. Just because your policy says certain things does not mean that all policies will say the same thing. Obviously, our insurance coverage is different than your's. We issue a dress code to all of our officials too. If they don't follow our dress code, they don't officiate. [Edited by Jurassic Referee on Jan 17th, 2005 at 04:49 PM] |
Re: Dork partner
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
BTW, the "Peace" is just a salutation. It does not mean what it did in the 1960s when people were smoking weed and snorting LSD and acid. It is just a way to say goodbye. It is very commonly used amongst people that are used to current pop culture. It has nothing to do with a war or opposition to the government. It is just salutation. <a href='http://www.smileycentral.com/?partner=ZSzeb008_ZSzeb008' target='_blank'><img src='http://smileys.smileycentral.com/cat/23/23_6_111.gif' alt='' border=0></a> |
No Jewelry Here!
I wear my jewelry to my games and then I take everything off, including my wedding ring. I am a firm believer that our appearance is so important. I worked with a official just the other day who wore glasses and the first call that he made some folks in the stands started making fun of his glasses. If I worked with a guy who wore a watch I probably would wonder if he has a game afterwards and needs to monitor the time. Remember everyone there are "EYES IN THE SKY" and you never know who is in the stands. So take notice and govern yourselfs accordingly!
|
Quote:
Quote:
Peace |
Quote:
|
I've over-reacted.
Jeff you are arguing different things. Liability and insurance coverage are not the same thing. Having insurance coverage does not remove liability. Insurance coverage just means that (perhaps, if they want to and can't find a legal escape) the insurance company will pay for losses if you are found liable for malfeasance. It does not remove your responsibility for proper conduct of the contest. The uniform, in a great way, says you are certified and capable to the casual observer. And the lack of a uniform, disregard for timeliness, and disregard for the safety of the contest (the reason for not allowing jewelry) strongly says the opposite; that person is not qualified, not certified, and not capable. Of course these are just appearances - he maybe certified and a dork. I contend, strongly, that if an official allows someone with this blatant disregard, to participate in the game, that official is liable for the actions of his "disregarding" partner. If it is obvious to the public, it is going to be obvious to a lawyer too. As an official, you're wearing a necklace, keep it in your shirt. Wedding band, no biggie. I may chastise you for something as stupid and unimportant as a necklace and embarrass that person into removing it. But the blatant disregard of this college student, to work an organized JH game, I would not tolerate. I'm sure you've got 9th graders in Chicago that stuff the ball and play a highly physical game just like here. I'm thinking safety and capability to work the game are important. I'm done. |
Nevermind the fact that you can be sued even if not ultimately liable. You may have substantial legal costs if sued even if you are found not liable and not judgement is found against you. When someone is hurt and they decide to su, they file suit against anyone they can think of...not just those that may really be at fault (if any).
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
Peace |
Quote:
|
Yeah....I don't understand this patch thing either. In Wisconsin we go with the "clean shirt". It's hard to remember how long ago it was when our state association would send us the state patch when we registered and paid our fees. The patch would change colors each year and we would have to either remove old one and replace with current one....or just buy a new shirt to put the current patch on. The patch was required to be sewn on the left sleeve. It must have been about 20-25 years ago that we did that. Thank god we don't do that anymore...didn't have velcro back then. I got pretty good at sewing....my wife thought it would be a great way for me to learn how to do those "minor" repair jobs....like when you blow the seam out of your pants???
"Patches?" .... "We don't need no stink'n Patches!" ;) wl [Edited by imaref on Jan 18th, 2005 at 11:35 AM] |
I think there are a lot of states that require their officials to wear a patch when they officiate. In Illinois we are required to wear an IHSA patch on our left sleeve for all high school games. I know other states have similar requirements for their high school officials as well. At least when I see pictures in Referee Magazine, I see all kinds of patches in all different places on the uniform.
Peace |
Quote:
Peace |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
If that is what is written into the policy, then it is up to the assignor to be sure that everyone is working with certified officials so that the coverage is in force. If your assignor screwed up and scheduled you with someone that wasn't, then you'd probably have to come back and sue them for allowing your coverage to be voided out. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
And it's much easier to ask "Honey, can you iron this on for me?" than it is to ask "Honey, can you sew this on for me?" ;) |
In Colorado, I wore a patch. There it ment that you passed the requirements to join IAABO. Rules and Floor test. You can work without the patch but you cannot do a Varsity game without one. Here in Texas I wear no patches whatsoever. Kind of makes you feel naked.
|
Quote:
|
OverAndBack....
I knew it was just a matter of time that someone would pick-up on the "clean shirt" term!!! phewww....:rolleyes: wl |
Quote:
I have 6-7 shirts and don't feel like buying that many patches. The velcro-patch attachment takes no more than a minute. |
Quote:
|
Speaking of patches and uniforms, where do you put the US flag on your shirt? Also, is it required?
Sleeve or middle back collar? |
Quote:
In Wisconsin officials choosing to place an American flag (no larger than 2" x 3") on their shirt must sew it on the left sleeve (three to four inches above the elbow). Officials that choose to display a flag on their shirt must display the flag in the same manner. (ie: your crew all wear or none wear.) wl p.s. This thread sure changes subject to subject.... :confused: [Edited by imaref on Jan 18th, 2005 at 09:24 PM] |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:02pm. |