Excessively swinging of arms or elbows, violation question?

[cmathews]

our state hasn't sent us our books yet so bear with me here... is this a new interp of the elbows rule or was it that way last year too...it seems to me that once the shot is in the air, it shouldn't be blown dead for a violation, because if the same thing happened with contact and you had a T you wouldn't blow it dead...or if A2 pushed B1 you wouldn't blow it dead...it doesn't make good sense to me to blow it dead in this instance...