Last night I had to T up two Asst Coaches trying to be Bobby Knight. In both instances the coaches jumped off the bench and yelled at the top of their lungs at my partner.
Well, when I got home I was telling my 17 year old son (who plays HS B-Ball) what happened and he said "Dad I know they didn't yell at you". I replied no, but why do you say that and he asks "were they White Coaches", I said yes, "with White players" I say yes "and was your partner White" I say yes, my son ended, "they are not going to yell and scream at a Black Referee because they are afraid of how you might react". It made me think for a minute and you know, noone has yelled or screamed in my face, YET! Since I'm new to officiating is this somewhat true? |
I think....
the fact that you have't been screamed at yet by a coach is more the result of you're being a relatively new official, than it is the fact that you're black. Do this long enough; it will happen to you, too. UNLESS, you're a 6'-6" 280# black man. Then, you may never have a coach scream at you. And if that's the case, I'll take you as a partner anytime!! |
Quote:
Woodee, Dunno, ignorant people do strange things. Like your son implied, wait 'til they get to know you better, ... or maybe you are simply just that good! I always thought *white hair* had some advantages. mick |
Could be lots of things
Could be a bias, could be rookie syndrome, could be they thought the other ref was more "workable." You can never know.
I have seen rookies handled in two ways. One is to ride only the rookie hoping he'll crack and give you some calls. The other is to ride his partner hoping he'll take pity on you for the "mistakes" his inexperienced partner is making and give you some calls. I am not sure that these techniques actually work, but coaches are coaches. That said, I see bias all the time and it is naive not to suggest that it exists. I work with a man who won't sit down at lunch with our coworkers when it is just the females, will readily sit down if another male is already present. I have worked with another man who would direct questions of a technical nature only to males, never to the females, even when the females were the technical experts in the area that he need info (and the women knew it!). I have seen similar dynamics between blacks and whites, and both directions. The bias may be a conscious prejudice or an unconscious bias that the person is not even aware exists. But if biases are evident in the workplace, they exist everywhere and will be there on the court. I also see plenty of people who demonstrate no bias in this regard. I would like to include myself in this category, but I am not naive enough to think I am qualified to judge myself. We all have preconceptions we carry around with us and they come into play in the most subtle ways at times. |
Quote:
|
One of my high school partners (white) told me this story:
He was working rec ball and showed up for a game with one team consisting solely of black players. After he called a foul on one of the players, the player turned and called him a "cracker." My partner ejected the player and the player got a very short suspension (1-2 games). My partner feels that had the races been reversed and a slur used the penalty would've been more sever. I'm not sure about that. Truth is, the only colors I see when I'm working are the colors of the uniforms. I'm not smart enough to favor one team over another for any reason. |
Woodee,
There are several counties in my state that have zero black population. It is not rare for everyone in the gym to be white but an official. These people are redneck as steretyped on TV but they are polite to a black official. There will be a collective groan when a call goes against their team but you don't see the personal insults like they aim at me. Go figure. Mulk |
RE:
I'm a Black Official and in my 3rd season. I have never had a coach scream at me but I had a few who were upset at some of my calls. When that happens and they go overboard T them up
|
Hawks Coach,
Excellent synopsis. One of the best, most concise ones I have read or heard. I appreciate your well thought and expressed observations. |
I read this and said no way at first. Then I thought about my experiences with coaches over the years. It does have some merit. I also think over time your personality will be the deciding factor with your treatment. Most coaches want to know what they are getting in an official. If you are black and you are fair then they will eventually accpept what you are doing. Now, they will not like it all of the time but they will accept it for the most part. There are coaches that will never learn how to conduct themselves on the sideline but they want consistent calls. So, sure they might have treated you that way because you are black or it could be that you're a rookie. Stay at it and it will all even out.
|
Not much has changed.
Woodee,
I think you have to understand that coaches bring their biases on the court. No matter what color they are. So if you are dealing with white coaches that have very little interaction with officials like us, then that can be problematic if that coach has feelings about authoritiy figures that are African-American. It is the nature of the beast. And in my circles often talked about. I happen to have started my career in mostly rurual communities, where in many cases I was the only African-American in the gym. So I had to deal with some things that not many had to. I even had an incident where a Principal was trying to get me off a game because he did not like the game I called a week before. And he only signaled me out, and left my white partner out of it. Considering the community he came from and the school involved, that was not a shock what the motivation was. But having said all that, just because we have come are separated from Jim Crow laws or the 60s, does not mean all is well in this country when it comes to race. The only thing has chanced is that it is not PC to openly express certain points of view, but the way people are treated are not that different. And yes it affects Black officials when we try to officiate games with coaches that are not of color. At least it does with the guys I officiate with. Peace |
Re: Not much has changed.
Quote:
I ask because I have a similiar situation. Two years ago, a AD who is black and works at a pre-dominantly black school, marked me off. He did not mark off either of my two partners. Should I suspect that the markoff is racially motivated? More importantly, how can I KNOW that's why he marked me off? |
You KNOW better than I would.
Quote:
Quote:
Peace |
Re: You KNOW better than I would.
Quote:
I've also seen situations where people attempted to play the race card when it wasn't happening. And you've seen it, too. We've all seen it. And that hurts those who really are being discriminated against. It can be like the boy who cried wolf. In the end, whether it's you or me, unless a man tells us that he didn't want us there because we're black or white, it's simply speculation and perception as to why we're not wanted back. Unless we're told, I have no way of KNOWING and you have no way of KNOWING. Just wanted to make that point. I'm done. Incidentally, I still work football games at that same school. |
Re: Re: You KNOW better than I would.
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Peace |
Good Discussions!
Quote:
I asked two of my mentors both Blacks with 20 + yrs experience and one said "he never thought about it before, but quickly trying to remember he said "NOONE has ever pulled a Bobby Knight on him". The other person said "it was because I did a good job and thats why they didn't yell at me". He also mentioned that when I do this longer I will eventually get it. The purpose for this thread was to make us think about it. Personally if a Coach is afraid of me because of my race, well SHAME on him or her. Please keep in mind I don't want any Coach yelling at me. I carry a 9 millimeter! Good discussions! |
Another satisfied CMG user!!!
Uh, mick, we could use a moderator...ahem...a referee right about now!!! |
I realize that I am not the smartest person and I do get easily confused but was it not you that responded to basketball ref by pointing out that "we" don't get but 1 school out of 12 implying that it is because "we" are black. I have no problem with you saying that or believing that. But, I do have a problem when you bragging over and over about your schedule. I guess you mean that it would be even better if you were white?
Either the games are based on ability (which you point out over and over) or they are based on some something else. Which is it? |
Re: Good Discussions!
Quote:
That's all I got to say on that one. |
OK Mulky.
Quote:
Quote:
Happy hunting. :rolleyes: Peace |
Quote:
|
Quote:
YU.P. |
The problem is in the assigning method, as far as I'm concerned.
Everywhere else I've lived the officials association acts as a buffer, gets the game contracts, and assigns officials. In the best run places, coaches didn't even have redlining or scratching capabilities. The games were evenly distributed amongst the varsity-quality officials and officials NEVER had to call schools and ask them if they can get scheduled. Why someone gets or doesn't get assigned certain games is a complicated matter. When I lived in a big city with a large African-American population, I had a hard time getting assigned to the best basketball schools, which were highly African-American. Is this any better or any different than Jeff not getting assignments at certain schools? I don't know. I know that I was just as good on the floor as those officials and occasionally did get to prove it. But it wasn't a coincidence that all-White crews were sent to mostly White schools and vice-versa. Right now I'm having mixed success where I live, where the assignments are handled in the same fashion as in Illinois -- I am able to get a lot of assignments in some conferences and can't even get the courtesy of a reply from the commissioner of other conferences -- conferences where I've watched officials work who I felt were of lesser quality than myself and my regualr partner. What's our problem? We're TRANSFER officials, only 2 years in the area. But there's a bright side to all this -- I may have to drive farther to my games (90 miles one way tomorrow night -- don't gasp, we get paid for mileage) but I do control my own schedule. And because of that, I am able to go to places where I know we're appreciated because in very rural areas there aren't many or any good officials. And when I get tired of driving that far, I'll have to decide whether to continue doing this or hope I'm able to break into some of the closer conferences. |
Factually speaking (I am not going to play Ron's game).
I work for about 9 give or take different assignors. I used to live in an area where you get games only by the AD. I still do a few games a year at some of those schools. But now I live in an area that most, if not all the conferences assign the games thru and assignor. The best way I can explain it is like the NCAA Conferences. Each conference has their own assignment chairperson and has its own concerns. The best way to get assigned in each conference is to be seen by the assignement person or to have the right person recommend you. One of them assigns crews for his games. So I can bring who I want to when he assigns me for the most part. Rich happens to work for one of them as well.
Two of the assignment people that I work for made a point to me to hire more African-American officials for their conferences. Mainly because their suburban schools had some mostly Black schools and the coaches wanted to see more Black official in those conferences. But everything that Juulie said and Rich said was right on. I just wanted to clarify that I am not doing games that are assigned by only schools and AD. But I have and that does bring a different level of challenges. And that story that I was referencing, happen to be a school that normally assigned their own officials. But the game this Pricipal was trying to scratch me from was assigned by another school for a conference tournament. It just happen to be hosted by the school of this Principal. Peace |
All of our conferences assign by crews where I live. In WI we work 2-official crews and I could literally choose to work every game with the same official all season long. But we all have some personal conflicts throughout the year and openings come up, so in the end I'll probably work with 5 or 6 people before the season is over.
I do work boys varsity games in Illinois for 2 conferences and those games are assigned to crews. One of the crews that I work on for one of those conferences consists of 3 officials that drive down from WI to work. So I have a shirt with a patch for those games and we drive down in one car -- sometimes quite a shorter distance than we drive for games in our "own" state. But I love the different style of basketball and I love working 3-official mechanics. ------------- Frankly, the coaches and the ADs wield a lot of power where I am. That works to my advantage most of the time as I've received more positive feedback from coaches and ADs than anything else. But it has also caused some interesting things to happen. Last season I was working a varsity boys game WAY out in the sticks. At least 90-100 miles from home. Visiting assistant coach comes out on the floor to complain about a non-call during a live ball and my partner (rightly) whacks him. As I'm calmly and professionally seating the head coach he makes a comment about how we just lost a school. I was stunned at the blatant nature of the comment, so much so that I neglected to call the flagrant technical he deserved for it. Some coaches aren't very smart in some regards, though. He may control HIS home schedule, but most teams do play road games and I notice he's on my schedule twice in February. It won't affect anything, but my smile will be a bit bigger than usual when we greet him before the game. [Edited by Rich Fronheiser on Jan 8th, 2004 at 11:51 PM] |
Quote:
"Hey, 100 miles away in the dead of winter! Please, please coach, mark me off! But before I go, take this with you! WHACK!!" :D Oh dear, I bet that gets BBallCoach going again! :( |
Quote:
To be honest, we had a good laugh on the way home using just about the same words you did. I just mapped it, BTW -- it is 115 miles one way to his school. We weren't actually at his school and haven't ever been -- they were the visiting team and we were probably about 40 miles closer at the time. My personal limit for a regular season game is about 90 miles, BTW. Unless I'm not the one driving :) |
Re: Re: Good Discussions!
Quote:
This might sound bad, but it isn't meant to be, its reality. My son has been raised in an enviroment just as he described so he knows. He is a military brat and all of his friends are White, so he has heard somethings. He is a good kid! BTW, The Coaches were very, very apologetic after the T's. |
Great Post
Rainmaker,
Great post. Very articulate. I am just so tired of hearing about Rut's schedule that I cannot be objective anymore when it comes to games he gets or does not get. It's like it don't matter what is in the rulebook or it doesn't matter what others' opinion are on a topic, ACA is all that matters. When he is on TV and doing D1 ballplayers out the ying yang, it is because of how good he is. When the system lets him down, it is because he is black. But, sure can't say anything negative about your post. Could you send it to my email address so that I can save it. Mulk |
Re: Great Post
Quote:
I understand your annoyance with Jeff. He views this board as a group of friends swapping yarns, and not so much of a public arena. So to someone who feels more like a spectator, he might look a little vain, I suppose. If you can look past some of his gruff exterior you will find a wealth of reffing wisdom which can be applied to many different situations, along with a little of the crotchety arrogance that we all need at times in order to do a good job on the floor. Occasionally, he loses his temper about race issues, but then we all have our buttons, don't we? It's just a shame when we lose it with each other instead of saving the righteous indignation for those that really deserve it, namely anyone besides the refs! |
Re: Great Post
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
But then again, you live in Atlanta. You probably think YOU know. BTW, I have family that lives in Atlanta. Wonderful city and surrounding area. But you probably have never looked around and talked to anyone there. ;) Peace |
Race Card
Rut,
Somebody else brought up the racecard because you got knocked out of an assignment by some principal because he was white and from a white neighborhood. All your friends, assignors, etc. felt the same way. (if I knew how, I would paste your words here, not mine). The poster pointed out that you could not KNOW unless that is what you were told. Is any of this ringing a bell? Anyway, in the last 12 hours: You have told me to shut up You have called me stupid Now, you are telling me what I can say on this board or that board. And, you are wanting to give me life lessons? |
Ronny, Rut,
C'mon fellas. Yer both good refs and good people. http://www.deephousepage.com/smilies/deadhorse.gif mick |
neither
i am not a good person or a good ref but i would like to be. everytime i get close, i keep getting put down by the black man. you know, calling me stupid, telling me to shutup, making fun of where i live, telling me what i can't do or can do.
I just can't take it anymore. Help me, Mick. |
Quote:
I think Mulk has some personal issues to deal with. Especially when someone is so wrapped up in what I say about anything. I can only speak about personal experience. I can only talk about what works for me. The reason I always talk about my area (which everyone and their Grandmother does). I can only talk about the level I do. Sorry if that is 4 and 5 JV games during the week, when I do not do them. I have one tommorrow morning BTW. And if you notice, I do not come here asking anyone any questions about what to do in my games. For one, if I have any real issues with a situation, that is what the rulebook, casebook is for. And I have extensive access to phone numbers of officials that I trust their opinion to ask. Then if the situation is unclear to me, I might come here and ask for opinions after I have consulted with many officials I know personally, but with the complete understanding that it might not apply to where I live. I think Mulk does not understand the underlining issues that affect everyone's officiating life. It does not revolve around our individual feelings. Peace |
You cannot handle the truth.
Quote:
Quote:
I'm out!! Peace |
ACA rulebook
Is that the rulebook or casebook that is issued to those Chicago area refs trying to advance?
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
Got a saddle for him,yet? |
Quote:
|
Sarcastic but serious questions.
Quote:
You call everything to the letter of the rulebook and casebook? You never call anything based on a philosophy or what people call the "spirit of the rules?" So you call 3 seconds no matter what the player is doing? You call all uniform and administrative rules to the letter (Shadow lines, size of the numbers, length of the net). You T every coach that has a foot outside of the coaching box? Have you ever attended a camp of any kind? Have you ever spoken to an official at a level above yourself? How many officials do you know that want to work 7th and 8th grade games all season long? I am not talking about the 30 year veterans that had their college schedules and State Final credentials that now their knees cannot take the punishment of kids more than 2 times their age. I am talking about the new officials that has just started or been around for a few years. Because if all these answers are what I think they are, then I really do not see how you can even play a game, let alone not start every game with a T. But that is what the rules say. Better yet, read the "3 second" post that has started sometime today and tell all those officials what rulebook are they reading. Why don't you tell them how wrong they are and to look up the rules in the rulebook and casebook. See how far that gets you. ;) Peace [Edited by JRutledge on Jan 9th, 2004 at 03:59 PM] |
Re: Re: Great Post
Quote:
On topic, however, I can see how some whites who have not been around people of color, might become a little paranoid about how they speak out of fear of being accused of being racist. I don't think that fear is necessarily racism, I think it may well be ignorance. Particularly in the cited case, those assistants displayed a whole bunch of ignorance thinking they could ride an official without getting T'd up. And a final aside, I don't think I've ever seen a T given that wasn't well deserved, or at least required by the rules. I don't know how you officials put up with half the stuff I have heard/seen. If I ever make the leap to the side of the force (away from the dark side of coaching), that may be my biggest challenge. |
Re: Re: Re: Great Post
Quote:
|
Re: Re: Re: Re: Great Post
Quote:
I agree!! Butch -- We have an unwritten rule around here, which I suppose should be stated more often. Any coach who: 1)continues to post here, and 2)takes the attitude that the refs are often correct, and even when they're not, they deserve to be treated as adults, and 3)never blames the losses on the refs isn't included in the general, blanket criticisms. This means you, CYO Butch -- you are the exception to the rule, and nothing we say negative about coaches applies to you. Unless you want it to. Ronny Mulkey -- It's okay to be annoyed with Jeff. You won't be the only one. But it doesn't have to have a lot to do with race. Jeff is a little abrasive at times just like a lot of Caucasian, Latino, Asian, and any other race guys. Just because race is the subject that you disagree about, doesn't mean that all blacks are like this or all whites are like that. Ya gotta shrug it off the way you would with Jurassic, or that obnoxious coach that keeps starting new threads about Dan. Or Dan, for that matter. I know you know that, but I just want you not to leave the board because of an irritation with one person. PS. The only way to pull this off is to let him have the last word. No one will think less of you. |
Quote:
Quote:
Only after a bath. Prior to that he smells like low tide. |
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Great Post
Quote:
Say what now?...hey Chuck, you're the the bright kid in the class...is this good or bad?? Quote:
|
Quote:
Just because race is the subject that you disagree about, doesn't mean that all blacks are like this or all whites are like that. Ya gotta shrug it off the way you would with Jurassic, or that obnoxious coach that keeps starting new threads about Dan. [/B][/QUOTE]Pardon? Exactly wherethell did I post about race- either in this thread or any other thread? I don't appreciate being brought into this argument. |
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Great Post
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Re: neither
Quote:
I don't know, maybe you are joking. I've heard this statement used jokingly before. If you are then use a smiley face or something. Rainmaker and Mulkey, I'm curious now to know the whole story with Rut and this schedule thing. Do you guys really have a problem with him or is this just some ribbing? |
History
Rainmaker,
Two or three years ago, Rut lampooned a mechanics issue regarding the non-calling official informing the coach. That was fine but what he did to personalize it was to question people's (mine especially) manhood. i.e. "if you are scared of the coach, you can't ACA. I'm a man and I am not scared to go over there and stand by my call. You must not be a man. You must be stupid". It went on and on. Of course, the Fed finally changed that mechanic to reflect what had already become a good game management technique practiced in a lot of areas (outside of Chicago). Then, he question's your schedule or your ability. Eventually, you do lose sight of the intent of the original post. My part in this thread is not about race. It is about Rut's great schedule that we all have to hear about all the time. Rut played the race card. Race relations have come a long way down here. To illustrate I'll tell you this story: 3 guys are in the maternity ward awaiting the first child of each. One is white and from rural Georgia, one is a black man from Atlanta and one is white from Chicago. The doctor comes out and tells them we have 3 healthy baby boys in there but we have misidentified them. Let's all go in and see if we can straighten this out. The good old rural boy runs in there and claims the black kid. The black guy looks at him and the good old boy exclaims "there is no way in hell I am going to even take a chance that my kid is from Chicago" |
Ronny, a very wise man I know is noted for saying "Get in, get done, get out".
Good advice for this thread. |
Juraissic,
Probably good advice. But, do you mind telling me why? You can email me offline. Mulk |
Quote:
Exactly wherethell did I post about race- either in this thread or any other thread? I don't appreciate being brought into this argument. [/B][/QUOTE] Woody -- Sorry to bring you in to it. and sorry to be so clumsy about it. I was just referring to your crotchety nature and not to anything you've ever said about race. I was trying to say that Ronny should use the same patience with Jeff that some might need to deal with the "old coots" on the board. I hereby let you OUT of this thread officially and completely. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
Sorry to bring you in to it. and sorry to be so clumsy about it. I was just referring to your crotchety nature and not to anything you've ever said about race. I was trying to say that Ronny should use the same patience with Jeff that some might need to deal with the "old coots" on the board. I hereby let you OUT of this thread officially and completely. [/B][/QUOTE]"Crotchety" I can live with, Juulie. http://www.gifs.net/animate/history.gif I just wanted to make sure that "crotchety" doesn't include never listening to someone else's viewpoint and then admitting it if I was wrong. As in the BBallCoach mentioned in the same sentence as me. When you get into these racially-themed posts, you are never gonna change another poster's mind- no matter how compelling your argument(or logic) might be. The arguments are usually more emotional than logical, and that's why I keep away from them. |
Re: History
Quote:
And how long ago was that. Get over it already. A <b>real man</b> would have been moved on from that. Now you sound like a girl I once dated that brought up something that I did when we first met. There is a reason I do not date her anymore. That was about 2 or 3 years ago. Good Lord!!! :rolleyes: Peace |
Rut, man it isn't worth the argument. Even though you know some things, they are better left unsaid.
|
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:41pm. |