The Official Forum - Did we get it Right???

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)

- Basketball (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/)

- - Did we get it Right??? (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/11467-did-we-get-right.html)

Quote:

Originally posted by davidw
So, those of you who do h.s., college--either or both, preferably both as I want an opinion on all three, which set of mechanics/rules do you prefer for this situation and why?

It seems to me that Fed. rules/mech. are most straight forward and easiest to admin. Any agreement with this?

HS rules are easier to administer, no question. Everything is in the order in which it occurred. Easy as pie to figure that out.

However, in this case, as I mentioned in my first post of the thread, the end result is exactly the same for both rule sets -- 2 FTs for red, 4 FTs for white, white ball at midcourt -- except that the coach doesn't lose the coaching box in NCAA.

In general, I prefer shooting Ts at the POI. (Actually, I prefer not to have any Ts, but if we get 'em. . .)

Quote:

Originally posted by ChuckElias

However, in this case, as I mentioned in my first post of the thread, the end result is exactly the same for both rule sets -- 2 FTs for red, 4 FTs for white, white ball at midcourt -- except that the coach doesn't lose the coaching box in NCAA.

...except for NCAA women, who get the ball at the spot closest to the foul for a flagrant T. (There is no intentional T for NCAA women---it was elimintated this year.)

Quote:

Originally posted by Lotto
...except for NCAA women, who get the ball at the spot closest to the foul for a flagrant T. (There is no intentional T for NCAA women---it was elimintated this year.)

Sigh. In two previous posts, I made clear that my comments were in reference to MEN'S rules. So I forget once. So from now on, my tagline shall read. . .