Fun With An Off The Ball Foul …

[bob jenkins]

Originally Posted by BillyMac

Actually took me a few times through the video to find any foul.

If only the question had given you the number(s) to watch....

On *this* play -- I have no foul because the ball went OOB, so there was no advantage gained.

If the ball had remained live, I have a foul on white for pulling the arm.

[BillyMac]

Originally Posted by bob jenkins

If only the question had given you the number(s) to watch ...

First watched the video without a "cheat sheet".

[rockyroad]

Originally Posted by bob jenkins

If only the question had given you the number(s) to watch....

On *this* play -- I have no foul because the ball went OOB, so there was no advantage gained.

If the ball had remained live, I have a foul on white for pulling the arm.

I like Bob's answer (as usual)...step in and tell them both to knock it off and play on.

[BillyMac]

Originally Posted by bob jenkins

I have no foul because the ball went OOB, so there was no advantage gained.

Originally Posted by rockyroad

I like Bob's answer (as usual) ... step in and tell them both to knock it off and play on.

Originally Posted by Kansas Ref

That greater than 10% of the respondents viewed this as a "play on" type of action is interesting; leading one to infer that this series of actions wasn't really all that "foul-worthy" to begin with.

13% is nothing to sneeze at, and should probably not be discounted, overlooked, or ignored.