is this right on college review?

[thedewed]

Originally Posted by Raymond

Well, coaches (& ADs) do write the rules.





The only time you can come back from a monitor review with a common foul is if a foul of any type is called in the first place.



Sent from my SM-N950U using Tapatalk

So if they miss a foul, and the ball is off the fouled team, they have to award the ball to the fouling team, i.e. get it wrong. that is a ridiculous result. delay the game and give the wrong team the ball. why not enable them to get it right? I know no one on here is an authority involved, just pointing out how wrong it is

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by thedewed

So if they miss a foul, and the ball is off the fouled team, they have to award the ball to the fouling team, i.e. get it wrong. that is a ridiculous result. delay the game and give the wrong team the ball. why not enable them to get it right? I know no one on here is an authority involved, just pointing out how wrong it is

Maybe one day somebody will have the brilliant idea of letting officials be part of the rules making committee. Until then...

Sent from my SM-N950U using Tapatalk

[BillyMac]

Originally Posted by Raymond

... letting officials be part of the rules making committee.

[Matt S.]

It's my understanding that they don't want judgment of contact to be re-officiated.

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by Matt S.

It's my understanding that they don't want judgment of contact to be re-officiated.

I would tend to agree. Folks already complain about the amount of time spent at the monitor.