NCAA Shot Clock Violation Question

[crosscountry55]

Originally Posted by Raymond

Per your description, there should have been a whistle for a violation.

As IAABO would say, “Let’s go to the video tape!”

The announcers even said something like, “Indiana picks it up so we’ll just go the other way.” They said it almost matter-of-factly which is why I thought maybe there had been a recent rule change I was unaware of.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[BillyMac]

Originally Posted by crosscountry55

As IAABO would say, “Let’s go to the video tape!”

They stole this from Warner Wolf, a local news sports anchor in Washington, D.C. and New York City.

[JRutledge]

I just saw the video. I can post this. But it seems like you can make a case that the defender has the ball secure, if that is the case then you would not call a violation or stop play. This to me is either way decision. If Iowa was near the ball or was contesting the possession of the ball, then I think you have to call a violation.

Peace

[crosscountry55]

Originally Posted by JRutledge

I just saw the video. I can post this. But it seems like you can make a case that the defender has the ball secure, if that is the case then you would not call a violation or stop play. This to me is either way decision. If Iowa was near the ball or was contesting the possession of the ball, then I think you have to call a violation.



Peace

That seemed to be the opinion of the announcers, too. But I would like to have a debate about this with the video. I don’t remember this being “bang bang.” The horn sounded mid-flight, then the try missed the rim. Plenty of time to process and then whistle the violation. I think this was a deliberate bending of the rule by the crew. Maybe this is something the assignor wants done in the Big Ten?

There’s no doubt a call here would have been a game interruptor. I’m just wondering if by bending the rules it’s not the top of a slippery slope?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[SC Official]

I've had a few of these situations in my college games.

Horn sounds while the ball is in flight, doesn't get iron, defense secures rebound, and no one blows except me.

I had to look up the rule once to make sure I wasn't crazy. One time I asked my partners in the dressing room, "That ball didn't hit the rim, right?"

"No."
"So it's a shot clock violation."
"Yes, technically."

I guess there are some MSU officials out there who won't blow this play dead and maybe some assigners want that, but any crew I am on we will have a whistle for a shot clock violation. It's not a game interrupter - what if you don't blow and the player who got the rebound has the ball snatched away from him before he can fully "secure" the ball?

I have not had this be an issue more often than not though.

[SC Official]

Originally Posted by crosscountry55

I think this was a deliberate bending of the rule by the crew.

Or maybe they just had a brain fart and/or thought it hit the rim.

[crosscountry55]

Originally Posted by SC Official

Or maybe they just had a brain fart and/or thought it hit the rim.

Twice in one half? It happened again a few minutes later. On the other end. Hey, at least they were consistent!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[bucky]

I'd like to see that be a rule. If the defense gains control during a shot clock violation, then play on. Get rid of the game disruption.

Ex. Offense shoots, shot clock signals, airball shot is caught by defense. = play on.