The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Basketball (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/)
-   -   Assignor Pay (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/104912-assignor-pay.html)

Player989random Mon Jan 13, 2020 03:45pm

Assignor Pay
 
I made a joke about becoming the assignor for our local HS group, and apparently some people thought that was a great idea. So I figured I'd ask y'all what the pay is for such a gig, and what are the pitfalls of such an activity.

Relevant facts: 16 Public HS, roughly 15 MS, 15 Private HS. No rec ball.

Questions:
What pay should I request? What is the minimum you'd take?
Main issues you people face?
Anything you'd care to share?

I've until after the season to accept the position, because quite frankly the current assigning system is a damn goat rodeo and I want my name no where near it until the following year.

Camron Rust Mon Jan 13, 2020 04:35pm

It will vary widely between organizations. And by widely, I mean WIDELY.

Rich Mon Jan 13, 2020 04:57pm

There are a lot of variables.

How many levels? How many slots to fill? What happens with rescheduled games?

You probably need to figure out what makes the gig worth it.

Player989random Mon Jan 13, 2020 05:20pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rich (Post 1036719)
There are a lot of variables.

How many levels? How many slots to fill? What happens with rescheduled games?

You probably need to figure out what makes the gig worth it.

There are a lot variables to this, but the following is simplified. 3 man for all varsity games, 2 man for all MS and JV games. Rescheduled games get pushed to another free date around here, anywhere from next day to 2 weeks.

16 Public HS, Roughly 15 MS, 15 Private HS

Assume JV & V for every school, B&G

Public HS: 32 V teams, 32 JV
Public MS: 60 teams (7th Grade is JV & 8th Varsity)
Private HS: 30 V teams, 30 JV

Assume 24 games per team, assume 9 games aren't assigned by us, leaves us with 15 games per team. And MS plays roughly 10 games.

930 Varsity Games, 2790 slots
930 JV Games, 1860 slots
600 MS Games, 1200 slots

2460 Games, 5850 assignments

There are other factors, such as all-girl schools, schools with no Girl's JV teams, some freshman teams. Playoffs, reschedules.

If I'm leaving anything out, please tell me. I have no idea what I might be walking into. Any thoughts on what you'd expect to paid for such a task?

BillyMac Mon Jan 13, 2020 05:59pm

Assignment Commissioner ...
 
My local board pays our assignment commissioner $31,920.00.

He assigns for about seventy high schools (boys, girls, varsity, junior varsity, freshman), and a few dozen middle schools (boys, girls).

We have about 320 officials on my local board.

We have an assistant assignment commissioner who assigns preseason scrimmages. His pay is $3,000.00 (he's also in charge of our evaluation process).

Scrapper1 Mon Jan 13, 2020 07:50pm

Our HS assignor is paid a game fee for each team's schedule that he assigns.

So if a school has boys and girls Varsity, JV, and Freshman teams, the assignor gets $88 + $88 + $67 + $67+ $67 + $67 to do all the games for that school.

Freddy Tue Jan 14, 2020 06:47am

Non-$$$ Considerations
 
One intangible or two that you might want to think about go beyond monetary renumeration. Does there exist an adequate pool of officials to assign to the games you'd be responsible for. If not, your role as assigner will be a frustrating experience from the start. Or whether, for the amount that you'd be receiving, you'd be able to evaluate and remain in touch with the levels of proficiency of the individuals in your assigning pool in order to match the most challenging games with the most proficient officials. Nowadays, some assigners are jumping into the business concerned only about gobbling up schools and conferences, then "filling slots", regardless of these concerns, and it's disbenefiting our vocation as a whole. Other assigners are going so far as hiring a trainer or training staff to enhance the skills of his/her assignees and identifying personally who's able and who's unable to do what.
Not disuading you. Only expressing some considerations that might come into play about which you might already be well aware.
Hopefully, important considerations like these will play a part in your decision whether or not to become an assigner.

BillyMac Tue Jan 14, 2020 09:46am

Observations ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Freddy (Post 1036725)
... you'd be able to evaluate and remain in touch with the levels of proficiency of the individuals in your assigning pool in order to match the most challenging games with the most proficient officials.

Our local assigner is out every night observing officials (as well as using peer evaluations, and evaluations by trained observers). A few seasons ago he missed only one night, his grandson's birthday.

Valley Man Tue Jan 14, 2020 10:30am

Our assigner gets 6% of every game fee. Regular season has about 2200 games.

Player989random Tue Jan 14, 2020 11:30am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Freddy (Post 1036725)
One intangible or two that you might want to think about go beyond monetary renumeration. Does there exist an adequate pool of officials to assign to the games you'd be responsible for. If not, your role as assigner will be a frustrating experience from the start. Or whether, for the amount that you'd be receiving, you'd be able to evaluate and remain in touch with the levels of proficiency of the individuals in your assigning pool in order to match the most challenging games with the most proficient officials. Nowadays, some assigners are jumping into the business concerned only about gobbling up schools and conferences, then "filling slots", regardless of these concerns, and it's disbenefiting our vocation as a whole. Other assigners are going so far as hiring a trainer or training staff to enhance the skills of his/her assignees and identifying personally who's able and who's unable to do what.
Not disuading you. Only expressing some considerations that might come into play about which you might already be well aware.
Hopefully, important considerations like these will play a part in your decision whether or not to become an assigner.

Full story:

Our assignments are coming to us with anywhere from 72-24 hours notice. All assignments. This is frustrating the hell out of our refs, and we're starting to lose people.

We lack development, and our top talent is either old or electing a college-only schedule. We could keep the latter if we got our act together, but I'd say inside 5 years we won't be able to provide quality officiating to games that need them. I'm also one of the top officials, and taking this role might take me off the HS court, and that's a big hit as I work a lot of games for this group.

It's a multi-level problem that starts from the bottom, and we'd need several key reforms starting at recruitment, development, and retention. Something that the entire nation is struggling with. But if schedules got better, we could hold on to enough people to allow us to "bring up the bench".

BillyMac Tue Jan 14, 2020 11:38am

'Nough Said ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Player989random (Post 1036731)
Our assignments are coming to us with anywhere from 72-24 hours notice. All assignments. This is frustrating the hell out of our refs, and we're starting to lose people. We lack development, and our top talent is either old or electing a college-only schedule ... I'd say inside 5 years we won't be able to provide quality officiating to games that need them.
It's a multi-level problem that starts from the bottom, and we'd need several key reforms starting at recruitment, development, and retention.

https://tse4.mm.bing.net/th?id=OIP.n...=0&w=338&h=178

https://tse4.mm.bing.net/th?id=OIP.o...=0&w=300&h=300

BigT Tue Jan 14, 2020 12:17pm

Here we have some JV assignors who were paid a few dollars a game. Then to cut costs it was dropped to 2000 per season. I think you are insane to do less than $5 a game.

Player989random Tue Jan 14, 2020 01:03pm

Yeah, yeah I know. The ship is full of holes, but it isn't sinking. Not yet anyway.

BillyMac Tue Jan 14, 2020 02:12pm

Abandon Ship ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Player989random (Post 1036738)
Yeah, yeah I know. The ship is full of holes, but it isn't sinking. Not yet anyway.

https://tse3.explicit.bing.net/th?id...=0&w=269&h=178

Camron Rust Tue Jan 14, 2020 04:38pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Player989random (Post 1036731)
Full story:

Our assignments are coming to us with anywhere from 72-24 hours notice. All assignments. This is frustrating the hell out of our refs, and we're starting to lose people.

I assume you mean your current assignor is giving out the assignments at that time. Or, do you mean your current assignor is getting the games from the schools less than a week before and then assigns them. That is...is it all on him or are there bigger problems?

Assigning is a lot more work than some may realize. Don't underestimate the work required.

Player989random Tue Jan 14, 2020 05:35pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Camron Rust (Post 1036742)
I assume you mean your current assignor is giving out the assignments at that time. Or, do you mean your current assignor is getting the games from the schools less than a week before and then assigns them. That is...is it all on him or are there bigger problems?

Assigning is a lot more work than some may realize. Don't underestimate the work required.

It’s on him. The schools give the schedule out on time. And I’m here precisely to figure out how much I should be paid for this.

BillyMac Tue Jan 14, 2020 06:43pm

Smoke Filled Back Rooms ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by BillyMac (Post 1036722)
My local board pays our assignment commissioner $31,920.00. He assigns for about seventy high schools (boys, girls, varsity, junior varsity, freshman), and a few dozen middle schools (boys, girls). We have about 320 officials on my local board.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Player989random (Post 1036720)
16 Public HS, Roughly 15 MS, 15 Private HS

Quote:

Originally Posted by Player989random (Post 1036743)
And I’m here precisely to figure out how much I should be paid for this.

It looks like you service about half of the schools that we service so how about $15,000.00 for an opening offer?

Just don't push a hard bargain and end up like Jimmy Hoffa. I may have seen him at a 7-11 last week? Maybe not?

bas2456 Wed Jan 15, 2020 01:20am

I'm confident you can do better than assigning officials 72-24 hours beforehand. I'm blown away by that.

I have no idea what you should charge. I just know that I'm about 60% full for NEXT SEASON already. It's not right that your officials find out they have games the same week on the regular.

Multiple Sports Wed Jan 15, 2020 06:44am

Where Do I Begin
 
Please don't underestimate this job. It is a 24 / 7 job. You will be attached to your phone. If you are married, please have conversation with your wife. You will receive turnbacks at all hours. If you have 100 officials, you have 100 differnt reasons why guys officiate.

Questions to consider....

What is your turnback policy ??

If you have small college officials will you accept turnbacks so they can work a D3 assignment ???

Do you value availability or ability more when assigning???

These are a few questions to ponder, I will post more as we continue this thread.

Player989random Wed Jan 15, 2020 08:26am

Quote:

Originally Posted by bas2456 (Post 1036750)
I'm confident you can do better than assigning officials 72-24 hours beforehand. I'm blown away by that.

I have no idea what you should charge. I just know that I'm about 60% full for NEXT SEASON already. It's not right that your officials find out they have games the same week on the regular.

I've spoken with the current assignor and the guy who quit before him. Apparently, the commissioner has to approve all assignments. This is what is holding up the entire operation. The guy who quit last year would fill out 1-2 months of the schedule, but none of the assignments would be approved ahead of time. Compounding this issue, during the week of the game, changes would be made by the commissioner.

Armed with this new info, I'm going to decline to be apart of this madness. I appreciate the advice of everyone who had something to say.

bob jenkins Wed Jan 15, 2020 08:28am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Player989random (Post 1036743)
It’s on him. The schools give the schedule out on time. And I’m here precisely to figure out how much I should be paid for this.

I would guess that, to a large degree, the fee is already set -- by the customs and practices in your area. Asking what others earn across the country won't be of much help. Instead, you need to figure out whether you are willing to do the work required for the fee being offered.

It's kind of like officiating fees -- just because BM gets $93.17 for a game in his corner doesn't mean I can get that where I work.

Player989random Wed Jan 15, 2020 08:55am

Quote:

Originally Posted by bob jenkins (Post 1036754)
I would guess that, to a large degree, the fee is already set -- by the customs and practices in your area. Asking what others earn across the country won't be of much help. Instead, you need to figure out whether you are willing to do the work required for the fee being offered.

Yup. I was also here to learn stuff about assigning, like the guy who told me I'd be married to a phone for the entire season. Learning that someone gets $31,000 for 70 schools was invaluable. I was picturing $5,000 originally, but right now I wouldn't take the job for less than $12,000.

Rich1 Wed Jan 15, 2020 09:25am

Let me do my job!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Player989random (Post 1036753)
I've spoken with the current assignor and the guy who quit before him. Apparently, the commissioner has to approve all assignments. This is what is holding up the entire operation. The guy who quit last year would fill out 1-2 months of the schedule, but none of the assignments would be approved ahead of time. Compounding this issue, during the week of the game, changes would be made by the commissioner.

Armed with this new info, I'm going to decline to be apart of this madness. I appreciate the advice of everyone who had something to say.

Why have an assignor if the commissioner ultimately sets the schedule? We are currently having this battle in my organization -- the 3 presidents (elect, current, and past) want to approve all games. The bulk of our members agree that we should trust the guys we are paying to do the schedule and if they are screwing it up the board can replace them. Unfortunately, some presidents/commissioners just want too much power.

Multiple Sports Wed Jan 15, 2020 09:45am

Administrators only really care that when they call the assigner, the assigner responds promptly later that day. Besides rescheduling a game, they have buses to worry about, notifying coaches and everything else in their day.
Whether Cam Rust and Billy Mac work the game or Raymond and Nevada Ref is really irrelevant to an AD. It's high school basketball and some guys are better than others.

Valley Man Wed Jan 15, 2020 10:46am

Commissioner for us doesnt touch assigning. THAT IS WHAT THE ASSIGNER IS FOR!

That would be the first thing I would fix if you took it.

BillyMac Wed Jan 15, 2020 11:35am

Four Corners ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bob jenkins (Post 1036754)
... BM gets $93.17 for a game in his corner ...

Entire State of Connecticut: Varsity Fee: $98.47, Sub Varsity Fee: $63.89 (Junior Varsity, Freshman, Middle Schools).

We're always looking for good officials. Anybody interested? Your two person mechanics have to be impeccable.

Raymond Wed Jan 15, 2020 11:38am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Valley Man (Post 1036759)
Commissioner for us doesnt touch assigning. THAT IS WHAT THE ASSIGNER IS FOR!

That would be the first thing I would fix if you took it.

Different system here in Virginia. You must belong to an association to officiate VHSL games, and the associations each have a commissioner whose main function is that of assigning as far as the state is concerned. In addition, the constitutions of most (if not all) VA organizations state the commissioner is responsible for negotiating all contracts with schools/conferences. We elect executive boards that are responsible for day-to-day operations of the association. The commissioner/assignor is supposed to be working FOR the association and its members, but in reality they are the face of the organization and determine much of the strategic and long-term planning.

There are at least 2 associations in VA where the organization is actually owned by an individual, and I believe those commissioners are chosen by the owner if the owner himself is not filling that role.

Player989random Wed Jan 15, 2020 11:51am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rich1 (Post 1036757)
Why have an assignor if the commissioner ultimately sets the schedule? We are currently having this battle in my organization -- the 3 presidents (elect, current, and past) want to approve all games. The bulk of our members agree that we should trust the guys we are paying to do the schedule and if they are screwing it up the board can replace them. Unfortunately, some presidents/commissioners just want too much power.

This is the issue I'm starting to suspect. I'm not sure we can fix that. Not in a pretty manner anyway. We don't have "voting rights" in my group. As Raymond mentioned, we're owned by one guy, and he calls the shots.

LRZ Wed Jan 15, 2020 12:18pm

"we're owned by one guy, and he calls the shots."

Let him do the assigning in the first place (not just final approval), with turnbacks, canceled/rescheduled games, last-minute replacements, late night phone calls about problems, etc., and see how long that arrangement lasts.

Camron Rust Wed Jan 15, 2020 01:07pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Player989random (Post 1036764)
This is the issue I'm starting to suspect. I'm not sure we can fix that. Not in a pretty manner anyway. We don't have "voting rights" in my group. As Raymond mentioned, we're owned by one guy, and he calls the shots.

Unless you can fix that, you're going to face exactly the same problems as the current and previous assignors. It may not be a headache worth getting into unless you can get (in writing) an agreement that he as to make his say some number of days before the games and that you are free to release them if he has not.

And I'm not sure I'd even do it for $12,000 as you're considering.

Player989random Wed Jan 15, 2020 01:33pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Camron Rust (Post 1036767)
Unless you can fix that, you're going to face exactly the same problems as the current and previous assignors. It may not be a headache worth getting into unless you can get (in writing) and agreement that he as to make his say some number of days before the games and that you are free to release them if he has not.

And I'm not sure I'd even do it for $12,000 as you're considering.

That's why I've made the decision to turn down any possible offer. Unless by some miracle they cede control of the assigning to the actual assignor, it's a figurehead position.

bob jenkins Wed Jan 15, 2020 01:52pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by BillyMac;1036760[COLOR="Red"
You're[/COLOR] two person mechanics have to be impeccable.

But your grammar can be flawed.

Raymond Wed Jan 15, 2020 03:41pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by bob jenkins (Post 1036769)
But your grammar can be flawed.

As can be your formatting. :D

BillyMac Wed Jan 15, 2020 04:43pm

Spellcheck ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bob jenkins (Post 1036769)
But you're grammar can be flawed.

Stupid spellcheck.

If God intended us to make spelling errors why did he allow Al Gore to invent spellcheck so that a robot can make spelling errors.

bob jenkins Thu Jan 16, 2020 08:29am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Raymond (Post 1036772)
As can be your formatting. :D

That's really weird because I didn't do the formatting manually -- I clicked the icons in the posting software.

The_Rookie Thu Jan 16, 2020 12:12pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rich1 (Post 1036757)
Why have an assignor if the commissioner ultimately sets the schedule? We are currently having this battle in my organization -- the 3 presidents (elect, current, and past) want to approve all games. The bulk of our members agree that we should trust the guys we are paying to do the schedule and if they are screwing it up the board can replace them. Unfortunately, some presidents/commissioners just want too much power.

TOO MANY COOKS IN THE KITCHEN....People need to learn to stay in your own lane:mad::mad:

The_Rookie Thu Jan 16, 2020 12:16pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Player989random (Post 1036720)
There are a lot variables to this, but the following is simplified. 3 man for all varsity games, 2 man for all MS and JV games. Rescheduled games get pushed to another free date around here, anywhere from next day to 2 weeks.

16 Public HS, Roughly 15 MS, 15 Private HS

Assume JV & V for every school, B&G

Public HS: 32 V teams, 32 JV
Public MS: 60 teams (7th Grade is JV & 8th Varsity)
Private HS: 30 V teams, 30 JV

Assume 24 games per team, assume 9 games aren't assigned by us, leaves us with 15 games per team. And MS plays roughly 10 games.

930 Varsity Games, 2790 slots
930 JV Games, 1860 slots
600 MS Games, 1200 slots

2460 Games, 5850 assignments

There are other factors, such as all-girl schools, schools with no Girl's JV teams, some freshman teams. Playoffs, reschedules.

If I'm leaving anything out, please tell me. I have no idea what I might be walking into. Any thoughts on what you'd expect to paid for such a task?

In my area, the assignor is not paid by the schools or conferences. Paid by the officials at $4.00 per game by each official working that game. Same assignor fee for both JV and Varsity!

crosscountry55 Thu Jan 16, 2020 07:32pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by bas2456 (Post 1036750)
I'm confident you can do better than assigning officials 72-24 hours beforehand. I'm blown away by that.


Yeah no kidding! Just ask Rich. In Wisconsin he assigns officials 72-24 years in advance.



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Rich Thu Jan 16, 2020 08:01pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by crosscountry55 (Post 1036796)
Yeah no kidding! Just ask Rich. In Wisconsin he assigns officials 72-24 years in advance.



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk



I just signed a contract to officiate a game in 2023.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk Pro

ilyazhito Thu Jan 16, 2020 09:59pm

How does that make any sense? That's like 3 years away, and for all I know you could retire by then or move out of state.

If I get asked to be an observer down the road, I might be interested in doing that, but I am not interested in assigning, because I do not want to deal with complaints from coaches about the officials they get, or from officials about my assigning decisions.

Multiple Sports Thu Jan 16, 2020 11:52pm

$$$$$$$$$
 
Can't speak for other parts of the country but where Iive ( Mid Atlantic ), this job should pay anywhere from $26,000 to $32,500......

Raymond Fri Jan 17, 2020 08:27am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Multiple Sports (Post 1036807)
Can't speak for other parts of the country but where Iive ( Mid Atlantic ), this job should pay anywhere from $26,000 to $32,500......


I think Northern VA qualifies as Mid-Atlantic....:D

BillyMac Fri Jan 17, 2020 10:47am

One Day At A Time ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Rich (Post 1036798)
I just signed a contract to officiate a game in 2023.

I could be dead by then. Survived one heart attack, don't know it I'll survive the second.

Of course one could always get hit by a bus.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:24pm.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1