Washington/UNC

SC Official

First half 13:16–block/charge play with a double whistle

I couldn’t help but notice that following the free throws, the C chopped the clock on the throw-in.

SC Official

12:17–elbow play that went to the monitor. In some states it would be a mandatory intentional foul.

Nevadaref

First half 12:17.
How does Higgins not have a foul on the second elbow that splits open the defender’s mouth?
Then still nothing upon review. Ugh.

SC Official

I can understand how that would be missed in real time. The rule doesn’t allow them to go with a common foul at the monitor if nothing was called on the floor.

Nevadaref

SC Official wrote
I can understand how that would be missed in real time. The rule doesn’t allow them to go with a common foul at the monitor if nothing was called on the floor.

He swung BOTH elbows right in front of the defender’s face. It wasn’t a basketball move. It was just to clear space and intimidate. My opinion is that it was dangerous and deserving of a F1 once the second elbow connected. I would have an elbow swinging violation without contact.

Nevadaref

Update: tv broadcasters just announced that the Carolina defender #15 had a tooth knocked out by the elbow and another which is loose.

JRutledge

This was close to a cylinder play. I think nothing should have been called either. The elbows were tucked in as asked to be used and he is allowed to swing through. He did not measure the defender or go looking to hit him. I like the review and by rule they cannot just call a foul because.

Peace

SC Official

Nevadaref wrote
He swung BOTH elbows right in front of the defender’s face. It wasn’t a basketball move. It was just to clear space and intimidate. My opinion is that it was dangerous and deserving of a F1 once the second elbow connected. I would have an elbow swinging violation without contact.

Not a basketball move? Have you never seen ball handlers move the ball side to side above their head? He didn’t seek out the defender nor swing/extend his elbows in any unnatural manner. A flagrant 1 foul on this play would have been wrong. There’s a bigger case for a cylinder foul on the defender than an F1 on the offensive player.

Nevadaref wrote
Update: tv broadcasters just announced that the Carolina defender #15 had a tooth knocked out by the elbow and another which is loose.

Okay, so what’s your point?

JRutledge

SC Official wrote
First half 13:16–block/charge play with a double whistle

I couldn’t help but notice that following the free throws, the C chopped the clock on the throw-in.

Play #1:

Peace

JRutledge

SC Official wrote
12:17–elbow play that went to the monitor. In some states it would be a mandatory intentional foul.

Play #2

Peace

Kelvin green

Tough call on the elbow. Was the elbow outside his cylinder? I think there’d be an argument for that since the cylinder is normally about shoulder width. In a high school game with no replay, I’m going at least player control.