![]() |
New Mexico St v Auburn vid request
Second half 3:00 left
Blocking foul on the primary defender or charge with the secondary defender? |
<iframe width="560" height="315" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/p4tDulpPocs" frameborder="0" allow="accelerometer; autoplay; encrypted-media; gyroscope; picture-in-picture" allowfullscreen></iframe>
Peace |
Charge -- if that defender got there in time
|
The first defender certainly fouled him then the offensive player charged.
I'd be fine with going with the first foul. Without it, the offensive player may have been able to avoid the charge. |
Quote:
Peace |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Everything avoided if C calls that first armbar-ish foul.
|
Quote:
Peace |
Quote:
Many times, when that first foul (armbar-ish) is not called, the subsequent play/action is difficult to officiate. IOW, by not calling it, something difficult to officiate results. By calling it, especially early in a game if possible, it sets a tone for players, specifically guards. It also is usually easy to match up on both ends because it is a frequent defensive tactic. Most college players are not able to play through it and it impacts their drive/play. From an overall game perspective, calling it helps out the entire game. It is rarely called in the NBA because players either stop or play through it. In both cases, the subsequent action is not difficult to officiate. |
Quote:
But this is why they call it judgment. Just saying if I called that then we would have many more fouls in most games. Not that is always a bad thing, but not appropriate for the game in most situation IMO. Peace |
I have a charge. As far as the arm bar, yes if this is an NCAAW game but on the men's side that arm bar is a no call, easy charge. You can't with 100% conviction say arm bar had an effect on the ball handler but the charge is a no brainer.
|
I let them play, but I see the first defender getting in to his body enough to turn it towards him.
|
Quote:
And before people hop in and say “Well, that’s not a call you want to make in the men’s game” I’ve seen multiple officials in this tournament apply 10-1-4 by the book. The “it didn’t affect the play” line of thinking is the entire reason that we have these automatic fouls now. |
Quote:
Peace |
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:26am. |