Illegal Screen?
I "no-called" a play which had everyone in an uproar.
A1 has an uncontested lay-up, going down the tableside sideline, then heads towards the basket on a 45-degree angle with the end line. A2 and B2 in motion, meet up at the tableside lane space closest to the FT line. A2 is between B2 and the basket. A2 and B2 both move at the same speed and same direction, from where they started, towards the basket. There is no contact, but they are only an inch apart. It appears to all that A2 impeded B2's attempt to defend the play, as they moved together, step by step. But with no contact, no foul, correct? |
Stand your ground ChuckS.
I've had the same type of play in games where I did not see contact but rather just syncrhonous motion between Ax and Bx who happened to be in very close proximity as Ay is engaged in a try for goal. It's expected that the peanut gallery will rail against you; they don't have the well-positioned good "look/angle" on the play that you did. |
Quote:
You had Obstruction and you should have awarded Team B an Indirect Free Kick. Oops! Wrong sport, :p! MTD, Sr. |
Are there any fouls you can call that don't involve contact? What are those fouls and do they apply here?
Sent from my SM-N950U using Tapatalk |
Quote:
To call this, I assume I would have to deem that A2 deliberately impeded B2, rather than just being in the wrong place at the wrong time? |
In this instance, even if there was contact, I believe this is a case where a "moving screen" is legal. In fact, if B2 completely runs over A2, you might have a foul on B2.
4-40-6 When screening an opponent who is moving in the same path and direction as the screener, the player behind is responsible if contact is made because the player in front slows up or stops and the player behind overruns his/her opponent. |
Personal fouls involve contact. Period.
(And no, technical fouls are not personal fouls.) |
Quote:
|
Even if there is contact it doesn't mean the offense did anything wrong. They are entitled to their space on the floor and screening principles don't necessarily apply here.
|
Quote:
If the defender is trying to get to the ball handler, why would they not apply? |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:33pm. |