Vid Request: Mich State vs Perdue - hook/hold = F1

[bucky]

I do not necessarily mind the rule, I am just not sure why it was created. If someone was holding a jersey during a rebound, it would be an F1 right? There is no specific text/rule regarding holding a jersey but we have the F1 text/rule. Why was it necessary to have specific wording for this play created? Why couldn't they just use the F1 text/rule to address the situation. I think they reaction from said calls/fouls would have been the same and perhaps that is why they went out of their way to create specific language for it. IDK.

(thanks JRUT for video)

[SC Official]

Originally Posted by bucky

I do not necessarily mind the rule, I am just not sure why it was created. If someone was holding a jersey during a rebound, it would be an F1 right? There is no specific text/rule regarding holding a jersey but we have the F1 text/rule. Why was it necessary to have specific wording for this play created? Why couldn't they just use the F1 text/rule to address the situation. I think they reaction from said calls/fouls would have been the same and perhaps that is why they went out of their way to create specific language for it. IDK.

Nowhere in the rules does it say that is it an automatic intentional (NFHS) or F1 (NCAA-M) foul to grab a jersey.

[bucky]

Originally Posted by SC Official

Nowhere in the rules does it say that is it an automatic intentional (NFHS) or F1 (NCAA-M) foul to grab a jersey.

That's kinda the point, which you are missing of course. It is not needed.

On another note, it is not mentioned in the local newspaper flyer either but you will essentially find it in the NFHS case book around page 28.

[BillyMac]

Originally Posted by bucky

... essentially find it in the NFHS case book around page 28.

4.19.3 SITUATION C: Team A leads by three points with four seconds remaining in the fourth quarter. Team A is to throw-in from a spot out of bounds on the end line. Players begin jockeying for positions just after the official has handed the ball to A1. B1, while trying to deny a pass from A1 to A2 (a) grabs A2’s jersey; or (b) pushes A2 from behind. RULING: In (a) and (b), it is an intentional personal foul designed to keep the clock from starting or to neutralize an opponent’s obvious advantageous position.

[thedewed]

The above is not saying that all grabbing of the Jersey is F1, you need one of those circumstances. This hook and hold deal should be reserved for the situations where there's a danger of somebody getting hurt. I'm not even sure this video is a foul. The hook and hold should be something that last for a period of time and creates fanger