Oakland v Youngstown ending

[jas4yf]

Originally Posted by Camron Rust

Not really.

The foot movement that makes it a travel occurred when the player was holding the ball.....the jump. The player lifted the pivot foot while holding the ball and then started a dribble.

I mean sure, but by that logic 4-44-5b (the exception noted earlier) is only a travel because the player had been holding the ball first.

[Camron Rust]

Originally Posted by jas4yf

I mean sure, but by that logic 4-44-5b (the exception noted earlier) is only a travel because the player had been holding the ball first.

The difference is that every other case involves some foot movement while holding the ball. The stand-up case doesn't.

[jas4yf]

Originally Posted by Camron Rust

The difference is that every other case involves some foot movement while holding the ball. The stand-up case doesn't.

OK I can buy that ... you've convinced me!