GHSA Forces Replay of Game's Final Second

[FormerUmp]

Originally Posted by BigT

This happened here. Game ends in a tie and the player who tried to drive to win go and chest pumps the Lead and F bombs him. Technical foul. They misapply the rule and the T is shoot in regulation and its game over. If the coach told the state we should have had over time would you guys be upset that they had an OT at a later date.

In my opinion a misapplication like this at the end of the game is something that should be redone when the final mispplication affects only the end of the game. Not the 1st quarter.

The problem is that the rules don't support allowing a protest.

Additionally, the GHSA last spring overturned an umpire's judgment call despite the obvious rule preventing that. They denied the protest of a judgment call in a football game this fall. They just seem to do whatever feels good at the time with no thought to the rules or consistency.

[crosscountry55]

Originally Posted by FormerUmp

The problem is that the rules don't support allowing a protest.

Additionally, the GHSA last spring overturned an umpire's judgment call despite the obvious rule preventing that. They denied the protest of a judgment call in a football game this fall. They just seem to do whatever feels good at the time with no thought to the rules or consistency.

You know, if I'm Collins Hill and I'm feeling frisky, I could easily file suit to stay the GSHA's decision based on the disregard for their own bylaws. And I'd probably eventually win the case.

[voiceoflg]

Collins Hill wins big, loses replay of Saturday's game vs. Discovery | Sports | gwinnettprepsports.com

Discovery won the one second continuation, but Collins Hill won the rematch.

[frezer11]

Originally Posted by voiceoflg

Collins Hill wins big, loses replay of Saturday's game vs. Discovery | Sports | gwinnettprepsports.com

Discovery won the one second continuation, but Collins Hill won the rematch.

I wonder why they played the regularly scheduled game first, and then the replay? Seems logical that they should have done the 1 second thing first, and then played a full game.

[Nevadaref]

Originally Posted by FormerUmp

The problem is that the rules don't support allowing a protest.

Additionally, the GHSA last spring overturned an umpire's judgment call despite the obvious rule preventing that. They denied the protest of a judgment call in a football game this fall. They just seem to do whatever feels good at the time with no thought to the rules or consistency.

Isn't this the same organization that played its State Championship games with the baskets positioned incorrectly a couple of years ago?

[frezer11]

Originally Posted by Nevadaref

Isn't this the same organization that played its State Championship games with the baskets positioned incorrectly a couple of years ago?

Good Memory.

https://forum.officiating.com/basket...n-baskets.html