Swinging elbow contact (video)

[JetMetFan]

Originally Posted by AremRed

No way that can be a held ball. I see three cleanup fouls that could have been called which probably (except for the last one) prevent the elbow.

I can't see cleanup fouls here. Green #21 came out swinging (her body, at least) from the moment she grabbed the rebound. If there was a whistle against either player in White closest to the BH/D, that's not fair to either of them.

Originally Posted by Dad

I'll agree it's a cop out, but in my mind I'm ranking it like this:

1) Violation - good call
2) jump ball - bleh
3) no call - terrible.

I'm in no way advocating quick held ball calls to prevent rough play. I'm trying to point out the rough play is already occurring in this play. There's nothing to prevent, but there is something to stop.

If there's something to stop then stop it according to what happened. Your 2nd and 3rd options shouldn't even be on the menu. Green #21 was swinging her elbows. That's a violation. If that isn't called, get the foul - IF or FF - once contact takes place.

[Dad]

Originally Posted by JetMetFan

I can't see cleanup fouls here. Green #21 came out swinging (her body, at least) from the moment she grabbed the rebound. If there was a whistle against either player in White closest to the BH/D, that's not fair to either of them.




If there's something to stop then stop it according to what happened. Your 2nd and 3rd options shouldn't even be on the menu. Green #21 was swinging her elbows. That's a violation. If that isn't called, get the foul - IF or FF - once contact takes place.

[Raymond]

Someone saw a foul by the defense from this camera angle?

Sent from my SPH-L900 using Tapatalk

[OKREF]

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef

Someone saw a foul by the defense from this camera angle?

Sent from my SPH-L900 using Tapatalk

There could be one, just before the elbow landed. However I think even if you blow the whistle at that moment the elbow will still get thrown and connect.