Detroit @ Boston foul tip that wasn't call...

[kape]

Originally Posted by mbyron

This one was called foul with no runners moving. But what if R1 had been running?

To me, this is the problem with replay in baseball. So much hinges on what has happened immediately before that I am fine with living with the bad calls. Once umpires start placing runners it begins to resemble a board game.

You might say, Well, reserve replay for the boundary calls or for when there are no runners on base. Why should baseball fix some umpiring errors but not others? I say, live with them all.