The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Baseball (https://forum.officiating.com/baseball/)
-   -   "ground" rule double (https://forum.officiating.com/baseball/58756-ground-rule-double.html)

jimpiano Sun Aug 01, 2010 11:00pm

"ground" rule double
 
Evan Longoria hit a long fly to the corner in right field against the Yankees Sunday at Tropicana Field. The ball landed in fair territory and bounced up and struck the extended foul pole screen above the yellow line on the outfield fence and then returned to the field of play. The play was halted, Longoria was awarded a double and the runner on first was held at third.

So, by rule, if a fair batted ball bounces up and hits any part of the foul pole above a yellow line is the ball dead and the batter awarded a double? Is this rule unique to MLB or is it standard at most levels?

Thanks in advance for any answer.

johnnyg08 Sun Aug 01, 2010 11:22pm

"standard" basically it could go from the foul pole or left down the left field line or foul pole or right down the right field line.

JPNY25 Sun Aug 01, 2010 11:23pm

If the foul pole is located behind the fence, yes.

mbyron Mon Aug 02, 2010 07:43am

6.09(e): A fair ball, after touching the ground, bounds into the stands,
or passes through, over or under a fence, or through or under a scoreboard,
or through or under shrubbery, or vines on the fence, in which case the
batter and the runners shall be entitled to advance two bases.

bob jenkins Mon Aug 02, 2010 08:00am

Quote:

Originally Posted by jimpiano (Post 687484)
Evan Longoria hit a long fly to the corner in right field against the Yankees Sunday at Tropicana Field. The ball landed in fair territory and bounced up and struck the extended foul pole screen above the yellow line on the outfield fence and then returned to the field of play. The play was halted, Longoria was awarded a double and the runner on first was held at third.

So, by rule, if a fair batted ball bounces up and hits any part of the foul pole above a yellow line is the ball dead and the batter awarded a double? Is this rule unique to MLB or is it standard at most levels?

Thanks in advance for any answer.

I'm sure you've seen or know that a fly ball that hits this "screen" is a home-run. So a two-base award on a bounding ball is consistent with this.

jimpiano Mon Aug 02, 2010 08:56pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by bob jenkins (Post 687510)
I'm sure you've seen or know that a fly ball that hits this "screen" is a home-run. So a two-base award on a bounding ball is consistent with this.

Thanks to all for the answers.

Yes, Bob the ball hitting the foul pole or the screen is universally understood as a home run. But the question of the ball bouncing into the screen was a question posed to me and I was not able to convince the questioner about the logic of the screen and foul pole having the same effect on a fair ball that bounded into either.

Thanks to this forum the answer is simple. The pole and the screen are in the stands and serve as visual aides for the umpire to determine whether the ball entering the stands was fair or foul. If fair on a fly=HR. On a bounce from fair ground=Double.

Thanks

Rich Mon Aug 02, 2010 09:22pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by jimpiano (Post 687633)
Thanks to all for the answers.

Yes, Bob the ball hitting the foul pole or the screen is universally understood as a home run. But the question of the ball bouncing into the screen was a question posed to me and I was not able to convince the questioner about the logic of the screen and foul pole having the same effect on a fair ball that bounded into either.

Thanks to this forum the answer is simple. The pole and the screen are in the stands and serve as visual aides for the umpire to determine whether the ball entering the stands was fair or foul. If fair on a fly=HR. On a bounce from fair ground=Double.

Thanks

It doesn't matter if the ball bounces from fair ground into FOUL stands, it's still a double. I don't understand why anyone would find this difficult to understand.

nopachunts Mon Aug 02, 2010 09:24pm

Ground Rule Double
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jimpiano (Post 687633)
But the question of the ball bouncing into the screen was a question posed to me and I was not able to convince the questioner about the logic of the screen and foul pole having the same effect on a fair ball that bounded into either.

Where would the ball have gone if the pole and screen were not there?

jimpiano Tue Aug 03, 2010 06:37am

Quote:

Originally Posted by RichMSN (Post 687636)
It doesn't matter if the ball bounces from fair ground into FOUL stands, it's still a double. I don't understand why anyone would find this difficult to understand.

The difficulty was grasping that the foul pole and screen are part of the stands.
He understands the ball landing fair and bouncing into the stands in foul ground is a fair ball. He thought the pole and screen were part of the playing field and, therefore, a ball bouncing into either and then back on to the field was ion play.

mbyron Tue Aug 03, 2010 08:04am

Quote:

Originally Posted by jimpiano (Post 687660)
The difficulty was grasping that the foul pole and screen are part of the stands.
He understands the ball landing fair and bouncing into the stands in foul ground is a fair ball. He thought the pole and screen were part of the playing field and, therefore, a ball bouncing into either and then back on to the field was ion play.

Some HS fields (though none around here) have foul poles that are inside the fence. Those are in play. All MLB parks have their poles outside the fence and thus out of play.

Rich Ives Tue Aug 03, 2010 08:53am

Quote:

Originally Posted by mbyron (Post 687662)
Some HS fields (though none around here) have foul poles that are inside the fence. Those are in play. All MLB parks have their poles outside the fence and thus out of play.


They don't groundrule them "outside"? Wow!

Besides, unless its far from the fence it's a pretty easy "fix" to put a short piece of fence in front of it.

Rich Tue Aug 03, 2010 11:25am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rich Ives (Post 687673)
They don't groundrule them "outside"? Wow!

Besides, unless its far from the fence it's a pretty easy "fix" to put a short piece of fence in front of it.

Around here if that happens, there's usually a line on the pole -- above the line, it's out. In this situation, a double.

Sven K Tue Aug 03, 2010 11:45am

How about the line toward the centerfield side of the Green Monster in Fenway? If it hits the line is it in play? My guess would be that it would need to be clear of the line on the centerfield side to be a homer but I'm not that familiar with Fenway. Been there just once.

mbyron Tue Aug 03, 2010 11:48am

Quote:

Originally Posted by RichMSN (Post 687699)
Around here if that happens, there's usually a line on the pole -- above the line, it's out. In this situation, a double.

Yep, same here.

bob jenkins Tue Aug 03, 2010 01:19pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by RichMSN (Post 687699)
Around here if that happens, there's usually a line on the pole -- above the line, it's out. In this situation, a double.

Agreed. But, it's in direct conflict with some FED interp (for those who are sticklers about such things).

yawetag Tue Aug 03, 2010 02:15pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by nopachunts (Post 687637)
Where would the ball have gone if the pole and screen were not there?

Using this logic, a ball that bounces and hits the outfield wall would also be a double.

MD Longhorn Tue Aug 03, 2010 02:25pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by yawetag (Post 687731)
Using this logic, a ball that bounces and hits the outfield wall would also be a double.

Or a fielder.

Sven K Tue Aug 03, 2010 04:41pm

I believe the old Tiger Stadium in Detroit had a flagpole in fair territory about 440 feet from home plate which had a line on it. I'm not exactly sure if there was a ground rule for a ball on a bounce, but it would be a shame to hit one 440 feet, have it bounce up, hit the pole above the line, and not have a chance to leg out a triple!

Rich Ives Tue Aug 03, 2010 09:34pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by yawetag (Post 687731)
Using this logic, a ball that bounces and hits the outfield wall would also be a double.

HUH?

If the pole/screen wasn't there it would continue on and go over the fence and be a double.

bob jenkins Wed Aug 04, 2010 07:41am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rich Ives (Post 687803)
HUH?

If the pole/screen wasn't there it would continue on and go over the fence and be a double.

And if the fence wasn't there, the ball would continue into dead ball territory and be a double.

The rule *could have been* written so the foul pole / screen was just part of the fence (e.g., the fence is 8' high except for the last 18" on each side where it's 25' feet high), and a ball bouncing off it and remaining in play is still live. But, it wasn't.

TxUmp Wed Aug 04, 2010 04:40pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sven K (Post 687764)
I believe the old Tiger Stadium in Detroit had a flagpole in fair territory about 440 feet from home plate which had a line on it. I'm not exactly sure if there was a ground rule for a ball on a bounce, but it would be a shame to hit one 440 feet, have it bounce up, hit the pole above the line, and not have a chance to leg out a triple!

Minute Maid Park in Houston has a flag pole inside the fence in deep center field, which is also on a steeply sloping "terrace". I don't have the details, but a few years ago, a fly ball hit the pole 30-40 feet above the ground and the ball remained in play. I believe the BR got a double on what clearly would have neen a HR absent the pole.

nopachunts Wed Aug 04, 2010 05:13pm

Groound Rules - Minute Maid Park
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TxUmp (Post 687895)
Minute Maid Park in Houston has a flag pole inside the fence in deep center field, which is also on a steeply sloping "terrace". I don't have the details, but a few years ago, a fly ball hit the pole 30-40 feet above the ground and the ball remained in play. I believe the BR got a double on what clearly would have neen a HR absent the pole.

Ball hits flagpole and leaves field - HOME RUN.
Ball remains on field - IN PLAY. Ball hits flag pole, bounces on ground and then over fence - TWO BASES.

MD Longhorn Thu Aug 05, 2010 08:02am

Quote:

Originally Posted by nopachunts (Post 687899)
Ball hits flagpole and leaves field - HOME RUN.
Ball remains on field - IN PLAY. Ball hits flag pole, bounces on ground and then over fence - TWO BASES.

And Ball bounces, hits pole, then over fence - also 2 bases.

Sven K Fri Aug 06, 2010 09:11pm

Fenway Park ground rules (note that a ball striking the dividing line in center is a homerun)

Foul poles, screen poles and screen on top of left field fence are outside playing field.
A ball going through scoreboard, either on the bound or fly, is two bases.
A fly ball striking left-center field wall to right of line behind flag pole is a home run.
A fly ball striking wall or flag pole and bounding into bleachers is a home run.
A fly ball striking line or right of same on wall in center is a home run.
A fly ball striking wall left of line and bounding into bullpen is a home run.
A ball sticking in the bullpen screen or bouncing into the bullpen is two bases.
A batted or thrown ball remaining behind or under canvas or in tarp cylinder is two bases.
A ball striking the top of the scoreboard in left field in the ladder below top of wall and bounding out of the park is two bases.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:55am.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1