Did we talk about this NFHS question yet?
I'm not sure if this came up, and my attempt to search didn't uncover it, but I wanted to ask something about a particular NFHS test question. In Virginia, we take the test online, and they mix them up, so the number is irrelevant.
Maybe I missed a few words in the question - and I didn't cut and paste it like I should have when I reviewed it - but it was essentially a question on 8-3-3a, where runners are awarded four bases when a ball is prevented from going over the fence by being by a spectator. Answer Key: False. What the he11? Someone in my association also asked about it, and from my recollection, it was worded exactly like the rulebook (I refuse to call it a "rules book") for 8-3-3a. My question is: a) did the test question not mention the words "in flight," thus making the question false, since you can't apply four bases to a ball that bounds over, or b) did the test writer $%^&# it up? I hope it's the latter, of course, for the obvious reasons, but also because I hate nit-noid questions like that. I know, we're supposed to know our rules, and know subtle details and blah blah blah, but it seems to me that could be done a little better than by just omitting two words from some long description. I'd like to think that, on the field, I'll know the d@mn ball was bouncing before the spectator kept it from going over the fence. I still kicked butt on the test, but I remember looking at the question during my review, and thinking, "I looked at the question, and compared it to page 51, so what did I miss?" Thanks. |
It's (a). The question (#87) says "a FAIR ball is prevented from going over a fence..." If the ball's fair/foul status has been determined, it can't still be in flight. It must have touched the ground or a fielder (or gone over the fence) while on or over fair territory. It would be a 2 base award.
|
(Before someone else says it) "But what if F9 leaps for one at the wall and deflects it off a fan who reaches over the fence and knocks the ball back onto the field?" Wouldn't that a 4-base award?
Maybe it is (b) HokieUmp. |
the question is missing the word "in flight" so I put false on that one
|
that figures...
Quote:
|
no worries...at the time of this reply, I had literally just finished the FED test so it was pretty fresh in my mind
|
There were a few of those in there this year...lots of little tricky ones...but the large majority of the questions are word-for-word out of the rule book
|
Quote:
|
The OP by HokieUmp said the FED answer key was FALSE.
|
Quote:
Certainly if the questions get "randomized", the answers have to follow. Either someone messed up in the translation or VA changed the answer. |
the question, as it's worded, doesn't even say "fair batted ball" the answer has to be false...it simply says fair ball. The answer key says True though huh??
|
Quote:
|
okay...I'll put true on my answer sheet...I'd hate to get a dumb one wrong
|
Quote:
The comments about "in flight" are relevant (imo), although the question is a direct quote from the FED rules book. |
any fair ball that's not in the air off of the bat could be a fair ball...what about a ball that's going over the fence on one hop and a fan swipes for the ball and it prevents it from going over the fence....are you going to call a ground rule double there? or a 4 base award?
|
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:41pm. |