Quote:
|
We cannot ruin the tradition of baseball by changing calls based on what an instant replay shows. That is for hockey only. I wouldn't mind though if they showed replays of a close call; more entertainment for the fans, thus more revenue, thus higher umpire salaries. Everybody wins.
|
Quote:
With the stupidity that is the alignment of baseball stadiums and their funky signs/colors/walls and ground rules, I'm all right with getting it right for HR and fair/foul calls at the pole. Using "tradition" to excuse something that can be fixed easily is idiotic. The replay will take less time than the manager's tirade and subsequent ejection over the blown call. |
Quote:
Oh, getting the right call. Forgot that one. :D |
Personally, I'd hate to see IR. Baseball just does not lend itself well to this. The games are long enough as it is with out IR.
I'm afraid that once the door is open other plays will be subject to review as well taking the human element out of the game.:( |
My only real question is this: unlike football, where a team has to use a timeout to challenge something--and said timeout is not "used" if they win the challenge--how would this be done in baseball without totally reworking the rules? Would it be done via a challenge? If not, how? Methinks this is something that must be worked out if I.R. is gonna work at all.
|
Quote:
If the replay does not result in a change of the call, the calling umpire gets to kick the skipper who appealed the play in the balls. |
fitump commenting:
Ready? Here comes the Tpo Four "Reasons" to not have IR. Woops, I mean the Tpo Four Whines About IR. Whine One: Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Whine Four: Quote:
|
Quote:
The NBA and NHL already review plays without a coach request. |
Quote:
If IR slips in, there has to be some mechanism to determine when it would be used. Would it be used at the request of the manager or the discretion of the umpires? |
[QUOTE]
Quote:
I am not certain but if the GM\'s voted 25-5 then it stands to reason that for all practical purposes the owners have already given their vote of confidence. Therefore, all that is left is for the players union to agree and then it is a done deal. Pete Booth |
[QUOTE=PeteBooth]
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
<TABLE cellSpacing=0 cellPadding=6 width="100%" border=0><TBODY><TR><TD class=alt2 style="BORDER-RIGHT: 1px inset; BORDER-TOP: 1px inset; BORDER-LEFT: 1px inset; BORDER-BOTTOM: 1px inset">Originally Posted by BretMan
Here\'s what makes it, if not a big deal, then certainly a "trickier" deal: While a manager might ask for help, we are not necessarily always obliged to seek it. If IR slips in, there has to be some mechanism to determine when it would be used. Would it be used at the request of the manager or the discretion of the umpires? </TD></TR></TBODY></TABLE> Quote:
Then we\'ll see which umpires hide behing their girlie skirts; the same ones who are always mouthing about getting the call right. :rolleyes: There are going to be some egos deflated for sure. Good. |
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:13am. |