In my experience, the OC are poor quality -- the last I bought had problems with the cut of the collar. On one, the length of the two collars was completely different, and on another the collar points were way too high. I ordered two navy shirts, same size -- one came as a "knit" style and one came as a micromesh / "holes" style -- shipped in the same box.

I prefer the "knit" of the Cliff Keen and OC to the "holes" of the Honig's.

I prefer the color of the Honig's polo blue to the light blue of the Cliff Keen.

I suppose that's why there are so many manufacturers -- to met the different tastes.

Has anyone tried the "lower cost" Cliff Keen from Davis?