When I played American Legion and college baseball in the 1960s, there was no crash rule, no FPSR, no nothing. Runners were expected to break up a double play. Runners coming home tried to dislodge the ball by crashing into the catcher, and the catchers were prepared for it. Know something? Nobody got hurt.

I remember, as a pitcher, covering home on a pitch that got away with a runner on 3B. The catcher retrieved the ball fast enough to throw it to me three steps ahead of the runner. I expected to get hit; the runner did not slow down but went straight into me standing up. I moved a little to the side and tagged him with the ball in the glove and the bare hand squeezing the glove. Crash. Spun around. Out. I didn't get hurt, because I knew what the runner was going to do.

No fight. Nobody yelling about the runner has to slide. The runner went to the dugout and I went back to the mound.

I liked it better in the old days.

That's right, 40 years ago, we played and played hard. I don't remember too many arguments or fights either. We didn't seem to be that worried about safety but more with winning the game. Also, if the other team was kicking the crap out of us, we weren't whining either - there were no mercy rules! If you lost, you lost and it was your fault!

I guess that as time went by, the world turned into a bunch of sue happy, "it's not our fault", panty waist sissies!

Previously mentioned..
Rose-Fosse collision

Ended Fosse's career

The old times were fun, but people did get hurt.

Body types in high school baseball range from puny freshman to 18 yr old men. Since HS baseball should be more about participation than body type I'm all in favor of most of Feds safety rules.

It did end Fosse's career, but it was during an event where the collision was unlikely, and Fosse was not ready. The allstar game was a surprising place to find such a collision, the injury was more a result of the lack of preparation, than from the force of the blow itself.

It was also only in 1980 or 1981 that the crash rule was instituted in ASA softball. These safety rules haven't been there forever.

Incidentally, I am certainly not recommending a return to the old days for school ball. High school teams are no longer composed of boys who had played sandlot ball all summer from age 6.

Trenton (NJ) High School used to be a baseball power. One of the guys I umpire with, who attended that school in the early 1960s, told me that when he showed up for baseball tryouts, he was competing with 135 other boys. That meant that some darned good players were cut. Today, they have trouble getting enough to field a team. You can't apply pro rules in that situation.

I had 2 concussions that I know of in my football career and in each case I was 'ready' for the collision and had a helmet to boot. I still got hurt.
You can split hairs on the Rose-Fosse collision if you like, but the fact is collisions will eventually cause injury.
I agree that being ready is better than not, but when it comes down to it, collisions are violent and violence can cause damage.

No doubt Collission will cause injuries.

I know guys who got concussions from getting hit in the head with a pitch too, so I guess we should change to lob ball, or just from the side a little lob like in BP.

I know guys who got concussions from taking a ground ball to the jaw, so how do we change that??

I know guys that have severly damaged thier Ankles sliding in to bases, feet first, while others have been KO'd sliding head first. Why don't we just not allow kids to play anything just make thier clothing out of bubble wrap and keep them in round rooms with round tables, with pillows to sit on.

I believe over protection causes injuries way more than allowing people to be prepared for possible outcomes. Telling people {as coaches do} that people have to slide, then a kid comes home running, trys to get out of the way, but clips a player, that will cause more injuries than an expected full out collision. Ask boxers, its the punch not seen that does the most damage, not just THE PUNCH.

Maybe the batting helmet should no longer be allowed then. I guess if batters didn't wear helmets they would try harder to avoid getting hit in the head by the pitch, thus preventing injuries.

I can't believe that you are arguing that banning dangerous acts causes more injuries. How about blocking below the waist in football? Would there be less knee injuries if blocks below the waist were allowed?

How is a collision at the plate a dangerous act??

Do I think that the guy comming home, should be allowed to Kick the catcher in the nuts? NO, but to run into him yes. Elbow him in the teeth? No. Their is a difference in Contact and deliberatly trying to injure someone. I think people can judge this as fairly as Safe and out.

This took an interesting turn. I agree, there are a great deal of coaches out there that keep the "myths" of baseball alive simply because they have "never read" the rule book. Maybe a section here or there when an Umpire has shown him off the field for arguing a myth. The safety slide rules are good rules for youth players. I also agree, kids now days don't know how to play as we did as kids growing up. We hunted out our friends to play "500", pepper, four on four, with right or left field closed. Imagine that, we actually knew how to pull the ball for a hit, something a good deal of kids don't learn till they're in college or the minors. If we coudn't find someone to play we threw a ball against a wall to perfect that pitch we loved to throw. We played hard, in league, we had a baseball hat under our masks when catching, our batting helmets were ear protectors only, (ouch, I know I'm getting older now) and yes, we were ready for contact at the plate. We never fought, we laughed and joked after the game. Today, a kid thinks he's something special because he can hit 70 homers in the first half of a computer game season. There is no sand lot play, and no matter what, little Johnny makes the team and gets two innings of play. We played six innings of baseball, no mercy rule, and yes, I was on both ends of those. Not as many play the game today, our kids sit on their arses and play computer games. If you want to see kids playing ball as we did, you have to go to other countries, were the game is still played as we did growing up, everyday, with passion. OK... getting off the soap box now