home run ground rule

ggk

fly ball hits the top of an outfield fence - the portion that is painted yellow. the ball then bounces back into the outfield. some fields i have worked have considered this a home run during ground rules, some have not and they state that this ball would be in play and have to clear the fence completely for a home run.

why would the yellow line be considered a home run? would be a tough call wouldn't it? thoughts?

DG

ggk wrote
fly ball hits the top of an outfield fence - the portion that is painted yellow. the ball then bounces back into the outfield. some fields i have worked have considered this a home run during ground rules, some have not and they state that this ball would be in play and have to clear the fence completely for a home run.

why would the yellow line be considered a home run? would be a tough call wouldn't it? thoughts?

A ground rule that permitted a home run for a ball striking the yellow and bouncing back would be an illegal ground rule and shall not be permitted. If a ball in flight leaves the field over fair territory, or strikes a foul pole, it is a home run, if not it is whatever it ends up being (double, triple, etc.).

GarthB

DG wrote
A ground rule that permitted a home run for a ball striking the yellow and bouncing back would be an illegal ground rule and shall not be permitted. If a ball in flight leaves the field over fair territory, or strikes a foul pole, it is a home run, if not it is whatever it ends up being (double, triple, etc.).

I have worked a number of fields in residential areas that have fences in excess of 20 feet tall for safety reasons. Most of these have a "yellow" line around the 12' level and have league approved ground rules that declare any batted ball that hits the line or above, a homerun.

Some umpires may wish to argue with league approved ground rules. I pick my battles more carefully.

WhatWuzThatBlue

Unless that ball has yellow paint on it, "Coach that ball hit just above the line." would be my answer. If it has yellow paint on it, your dilema is already fixed.

I've got pretty good eyes, but seeing an eight inch ball hit a four inch yellow line two hundred feet away is one that always goes in favor of the umpire.

SanDiegoSteve

DG wrote
A ground rule that permitted a home run for a ball striking the yellow and bouncing back would be an illegal ground rule and shall not be permitted. If a ball in flight leaves the field over fair territory, or strikes a foul pole, it is a home run, if not it is whatever it ends up being (double, triple, etc.).

In SBC Park in San Francisco, the yellow line represents a home run if hit by a batted ball. Very legal ground rule.

DG

I was thinking of an actual top of the fence, that is painted yellow, to provide contrast so it is easier to determine when a ball actually goes over it, not a line drawn on a wall. Some fences, also have yellow tubing installed on top of the chain link to protect players who jump up to catch fly balls near the fence.

Carbide Keyman

DG wrote
I was thinking of an actual top of the fence, that is painted yellow, to provide contrast so it is easier to determine when a ball actually goes over it, not a line drawn on a wall. Some fences, also have yellow tubing installed on top of the chain link to protect players who jump up to catch fly balls near the fence.

I was of the same opinion as DG. If it hits this type of fence, its a home run if it bounces over or "Play On, McDuff", if it bounces into the field of play.

Doug

3appleshigh

What many places have decided is that the yellow line is Yellow to match the foul pole, and consider that when the ball hits it is is like when it hits the foul pole and therefore a homerun. In my area I have half the diamonds with Yellow and half with Black top lines and only like one place where the yellow is considered a homerun. It is annoying.