The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Baseball (https://forum.officiating.com/baseball/)
-   -   catch? (https://forum.officiating.com/baseball/14759-catch.html)

yankeesfan Tue Jul 27, 2004 07:16pm

a ball is hit deep to the outfield, the center fielder has the ball hit off his glove,then the ball hits the fence and then the centerfielder catches the ball before the ball hits the ground. do we have an out?

Atl Blue Tue Jul 27, 2004 07:45pm

Only if you throw the ball back into the infield and tag a runner while off the base!

Jeremiah Tue Jul 27, 2004 07:49pm

Yeah, it's kind of like when a pop-up hits off the screen, it's no longer an "airborne" ball. Once the ball hits an unnatural object, the ball is no longer airborne.

-Jeremiah

mario Wed Aug 25, 2004 02:59pm

wrong!
 
5 minutes ago in the Olympic final between Cuba and Australia, it happened and the umpire gave the fly out! It looks like the ball can it the fence... weird!

greymule Wed Aug 25, 2004 03:06pm

Good rule for you, Mario: Do not assume every ruling you see is correct, even in the Major Leagues.

Another rule: Do not trust anything a TV announcer says.

mario Wed Aug 25, 2004 03:26pm

Having second thoughts it's impossible that the ball has actually hit the fence, as I agree with you. But: (1) I have seen it with my eyes, I'll get new glasses and (2) the TV people didn't say a word about it being not a proper out. Anyway, if I am right we'll read it on some paper tomorrow. Ciao

Atl Blue Wed Aug 25, 2004 03:54pm

A fly ball that hits the fence is no longer in flight and cannot be caught for an out. It is however, still "in flight" if it hits the fence and continues OVER the fence, and is therefore a home run.

On the call in the Cuba-Australia game, the umpire did not rule that it was an out even though it hit the fence, he ruled it never hit the fence.

He didn't blow the rule, he's just blind.

mario Wed Aug 25, 2004 04:06pm

Thanks, I am glad I can save money on my glasses.

jicecone Thu Aug 26, 2004 06:58am

Whew, thought for a minute there that there was a new Euro-Greko-Olympio Rule.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:15pm.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1