Rating Umpires

[rskinner]

Our association is redesigning our ratings program for members as we feel it has produced only limited success. I am on a committee to investigate other rating programs and would like to hear from anyone who can define the system used by their association to rate and evaluate its members.
Interested parties can investigate the system used by the New Hampshire Baseball Umpires Association at http://www.nhbua.org/evaluati.htm
Thanks for the help