2-strike strikeout

BayStateRef

This is almost a week old...but I just found it.

NY Yankees catcher Chris Stewart is "struck out" on a 1-1 pitch. He swings at the third pitch (thinking it was strike 3) and returns to the dugout.

What is the correct mechanic here? He is never called out...and the umpire never signaled strike 3.

Your browser does not support iframes.

bob jenkins

If you know it was only strike 2 then I think the proper mechanic is just to bring the batter back out (I'd do it with some kind of joke).

If you're confused, too, then go with strike three. The "signals" aren't needed or what determines the out.

BayStateRef

There is no sign the umpire was confused. He made no signal on the first pitch (ball 1); second pitch was fouled; third pitch, swinging strike. At 1:01 in the video, he is clearly shown signaling strike 2.

bob jenkins

Agreed. In some story or another, the batter indicates how / why he was confused.

I haven't seen anything "official" on how MLB wants it handled, but I would bring the batter back in NCAA and below.

Rita C

bob jenkins wrote
Agreed. In some story or another, the batter indicates how / why he was confused.

I haven't seen anything "official" on how MLB wants it handled, but I would bring the batter back in NCAA and below.

You don't think 6.02 applies?

Rich

Rita C wrote
You don't think 6.02 applies?

No, I don't. He didn't "refuse" anything. You can't refuse unless you're asked to do something.

BayStateRef

Rita C wrote
You don't think 6.02 applies?

I have no problem with saying 6.02 applies...except that the umpire did not signal a strike nor declare the batter out -- both which are required under 6.02. (Bold and red are mine...to show what the rule requires.)

Rule 6.02(c)
If the batter refuses to take his position in the batter’s box during his time at bat, the umpire shall call a strike on the batter. The ball is dead, and no runners may advance. After the penalty, the batter may take his proper position and the regular ball and strike count shall continue. If the batter does not take his proper position before three strikes have been called, the batter shall be declared out.

Rita C

Rich wrote
No, I don't. He didn't "refuse" anything. You can't refuse unless you're asked to do something.

So I don't understand why he was called out.

Rita

bluehair

The video didn't show what happened after B left the BB. I've been told that PU did give an out mechanic (not in the video), but I don't know.

Hey kid, c'mon back. You get three strikes on Saturdays.

bob jenkins

Rita C wrote
So I don't understand why he was called out.

Rita

9.01c or error.