JRutledge 12:18 in the second half. There is a foul where the commentators went on about a travel then foul. It looked like a good call, but I would like the play slowed down. Peace
letemplay I think Roger is calling the reach in (slight contact and not sure it is not on the ball) a bit before or same time as the walk occurred. His view of dribblers feet is obstructed by defenders legs.
Raymond ballgame99 wroteHe calls it on White3, not the secondary defender, so it looks like a good call Yes, it was obvious he called it on W3. Still looked like the contact for the foul came after the travel.
Indianaref letemplay wroteI think Roger is calling the reach in (slight contact and not sure it is not on the ball) a bit before or same time as the walk occurred. His view of dribblers feet is obstructed by defenders legs. That's exactly how I see it. Which came first, "the chicken or the egg".
Welpe BadNewsRef wroteLooks like the contact Roger is whistling for a foul came after the travel. That's what I'm seeing.
BillyMac Indianaref wroteWhich came first, "the chicken or the egg". Eggs have been around for hundreds of millions of years. Chickens have only been around for about five thousand years.
Texref Replay def a travel. Live speed, I'm not calling a travel, maybe even the foul from C. T has that play the whole way. Middle of key though so I can see C having the foul and no travel. I've probably called that move both ways in the past depending on my position.
fullor30 canuckrefguy wroteTravel first. The contact by W3 did not cause the violation. I don't think that has anything to do with OP, foul was called on 3, before anything else occurred.
Raymond fullor30 wroteI don't think that has anything to do with OP, foul was called on 3, before anything else occurred. Watching it again, I would say the contact occurred just a little before the travel, so Roger got it right.
canuckrefguy fullor30 wroteI don't think that has anything to do with OP, foul was called on 3, before anything else occurred. Huh? W3 is the primary defender. Contact by him would have been the only possible justification for the foul.