IRISHMAFIA derwil wrote 4. Runner beats out a throw at 1B. Her speed carries her through the base several steps. She stops and thaks a few steps back towards first the her coach yells to her go to second. Ball is is back in the circle at this point. She reaches second without a problem because 2B was covering 1B and SS was asleep. I called time and was about to put her back to first for making her initial move back to 1B, but partner said that was leagal - she was looking for the ball position. I wasn't happy about it but I wasn't going to argue with him. Any ideas? The ball was in the pitcher's hands in the circle WHEN? If the ball was back in the circle prior to the runner deviating her path toward 1B, that is a LBR violation and the runner should have been declared out.
[deleted] derwil said in the OP: 1. Hard hit ball to third base. Initially hits the ground 5 ft past 3b, about 1 ft foul. PU (not me) signals fair ball. His explination is that it was fair when it went past 3b. Is this correct? I understand if it was a grounder past 3b but the inital contact was in foul territory. NCASAUmp in response: Not if it first touched the ground beyond 3B... That's a foul ball, blue. One thing to keep in mind, and this pisses off the players more often than not, is if the ball bounds over any part of the base in fair territory, where it lands after that is irrelevant. The PU in the OP probably saw the ball go over the base in fair territory.
Skahtboi Ref Ump Welsch wrotederwil said in the OP: NCASAUmp in response: One thing to keep in mind, and this pisses off the players more often than not, is if the ball bounds over any part of the base in fair territory, where it lands after that is irrelevant. The PU in the OP probably saw the ball go over the base in fair territory. But, it was a fly ball (a liner, not a bounding ball) that landed foul 5 ft past the bag. So, it doesn't matter if it did cross the bag, it is still a foul ball.
CecilOne Ref Ump Welsch wroteNCASAUmp in response: One thing to keep in mind, (snipped irrelevancy), is if the ball bounds over any part of the base in fair territory, where it lands after that is irrelevant. The PU in the OP probably saw the ball go over the base in fair territory. derwil said in the OP: "His explination is that it was fair when it went past 3b. " 😕 What are you getting at? 😕
NCASAUmp Ref Ump Welsch wrotederwil said in the OP: NCASAUmp in response: One thing to keep in mind, and this pisses off the players more often than not, is if the ball bounds over any part of the base in fair territory, where it lands after that is irrelevant. The PU in the OP probably saw the ball go over the base in fair territory. Of course, but that's assuming it first touched the ground BEFORE passing 3B. In the OP, the ball first touched the ground in foul territory beyond 3B. It did not "bound past 3B."
[deleted] Ooops...sorry, didn't have my morning caffiene fix before I posted. I missed the word "initially" in the OP. I'll go to the shed and flog myself now.
JEL derwil, Was this the Viper Tournament? If so, make sure you read up on rule 6-10-E FP (not that you don't, or this was you, but some one up there may have missed one). I don't want my brother in law calling complaining anymore!
7in60 IRISHMAFIA wroteThe ball was in the pitcher's hands in the circle WHEN? If the ball was back in the circle prior to the runner deviating her path toward 1B, that is a LBR violation and the runner should have been declared out. Thank goodness we don't have to worry about this in Canada.
IRISHMAFIA 7in60 wroteThank goodness we don't have to worry about this in Canada. If I had my druthers, we wouldn't in this country, either. I bet about 20 posters just said, "damn, I hope he doesn't get on his Let's Kill the LBR soapbox again." 😎
Skahtboi IRISHMAFIA wroteIf I had my druthers, we wouldn't in this country, either. I bet about 20 posters just said, "damn, I hope he doesn't get on his Let's Kill the LBR soapbox again." :cool: Actually, I am one who agrees.
greymule derwil, exactly what and where was this tournament? I'm in Blount Springs and would have gone to see some of it.
steveshane67 derwil wroteHad a pretty good ASA tourney here in B'ham this weekend. Temps on Sat were a little cool but Sunday was perfect. Couple situations I wanted to run by ya'll.......... 1. Hard hit ball to third base. Initially hits the ground 5 ft past 3b, about 1 ft foul. PU (not me) signals fair ball. His explination is that it was fair when it went past 3b. Is this correct? I understand if it was a grounder past 3b but the inital contact was in foul territory. if it were true, then the foul poles would be at first and third base and there would be no foul lines in the outfield.
NCASAUmp steveshane67 wroteif it were true, then the foul poles would be at first and third base and there would be no foul lines in the outfield. And people would still argue.